Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge ( Answered 2 out of 5 stars,   8 Comments )
Question  
Subject: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
Category: Reference, Education and News > General Reference
Asked by: gantonick-ga
List Price: $10.00
Posted: 10 May 2002 15:51 PDT
Expires: 09 Jun 2002 15:52 PDT
Question ID: 15113
where can I find a highly conceptual encyclopedia of knowledge that
compares fields?
 
for example, take Freud's 3rd psychosexual stage - the Oedipus
Complex. What is he saying conceptually? a child develops attraction
to the opposite sexual energy and has a fear of death that arises at
the same time? what other theories in anthropology, sociology etc are
similar?
 
Encyclopedia MUST be go beyond concreteness of theories and compare
theories across disciplines. eg Fall of Man - Adam, Eve, and apple.
This has many conceptual interpretations eg marks the origin of
conceptual distinctions in man, marks the origin of "should" etc.. and
this religous story has parallels in psychology, sociology theories. 

Clarification of Question by gantonick-ga on 10 May 2002 15:54 PDT
must be on-line. encyclopedia brittanica is OK but does not have
explicit focus on being highly conceptual or compare ideas across
fields.

Request for Question Clarification by jessamyn-ga on 14 May 2002 17:08 PDT
hi -- by saying "must be online" are you also looking for a free
resource, or would you be okay with one that had costs associated with
it if you were sure it was the source you were looking for?

Clarification of Question by gantonick-ga on 14 May 2002 18:48 PDT
hi. a fee-based resource like EB, WSJ, etc would be ok, though I'd prefer free.

Request for Question Clarification by easterangel-ga on 16 May 2002 02:12 PDT
Does it have to be a strict encyclopedia or a website which has a
database of cross discipline articles will be fine?

Clarification of Question by gantonick-ga on 17 May 2002 11:52 PDT
a website which has a database of cross discipline articles might
help, but is not complete. here's an example of what I'd like to do.
say I'm interested in how, say, a venus flytrap works, but
conceptually. so I might say a venus fly-trap is an an example of
*stealth*. so I now want to see many examples of stealth: in the
military, in politics, in psychology..

a parallel is an etymological dictionary. I tend to learn new words
best when I know the latin or gk root. what I'm looking for is an
etymological dictionary of concepts.
Answer  
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
Answered By: tehuti-ga on 18 May 2002 11:17 PDT
Rated:2 out of 5 stars
 
Hello,

I think that the nearest you will get to this online is
http://www.xrefer.com/ where you can perform a simultaneous keyword
search across the full text of a number of reference sources from a
variety of disciplines. The service is divided into a free section and
a paid-for subscription section with extra titles.  Unfortunately,
subscription is geared towards institutional users such as libraries
(lowest rate is $1500 per year for up to 2500 users) and no deals are
offered for individual users.

From the blurb on the site: "Cross-referencing is xreferplus' magic
ingredient. By fully exploiting the opportunities offered by the web,
xreferplus increases the value of reference content by creating an
additional network of over 5 million links which lead seamlessly from
a topic in one source to related topics in other works."

The free service contains the following:

art:
The Encyclopaedia of the Renaissance  
The Oxford Dictionary of Art  
The Thames & Hudson Dictionary of Art Terms  
The Thames & Hudson Dictionary of Art and Artists  

british history:
Dictionary of British History  

business & law:
A Dictionary of Law, Oxford University Press  
Dictionary of Accounting, Oxford University Press  
Dictionary of Business: Oxford University Press  
The Penguin Dictionary of Economics  
Wall Street Words  

dictionaries:
The Penguin Rhyming Dictionary  
The Pocket Oxford Dictionary of Current English  

encyclopedias:
A Dictionary of First Names, Oxford University Press  
Oxford Paperback Encyclopedia  
The Macmillan Dictionary of Women's Biography  
The Macmillan Encyclopedia 2001  
The Oxford English Reference Dictionary  
The Penguin Biographical Dictionary of Women  
Who's Who in the Twentieth Century: Oxford University Press  

english literature:
A Dictionary of Shakespeare, Oxford University Press  
The Oxford Companion to English Literature  

health:
A Dictionary of Food and Nutrition  
Concise Medical Dictionary: Oxford University Press  
Dictionary of Medicines, Oxford University Press  

language & usage:
The American HeritageŽ Dictionary of Idioms  
The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Linguistics, Oxford University Press
The New Fowler's Modern English Usage  
The Oxford Companion to the English Language  

music:
Oxford Dictionary of Music  
The Penguin Dictionary of Music  

philosophy:
The Oxford Companion to Philosophy  

place names:
A Dictionary of English Place-Names  

quotations:
Bloomsbury Biographical Dictionary of Quotations  
Bloomsbury Thematic Dictionary of Quotations  
The Oxford Dictionary of Quotations  

science:
A Dictionary of Earth Sciences  
A Dictionary of Geography  
A Dictionary of Science, Oxford University Press  
A Dictionary of Scientists, Oxford University Press  
Dictionary of Biology, Oxford University Press  
The New Penguin Dictionary of Science 
 
technology:
Compact American Dictionary of Computer Words  

thesaurus:
Bloomsbury Thesaurus  

I don't think that this goes all the way to meeting your need, but it
may be of some use to you.

Clarification of Answer by tehuti-ga on 23 May 2002 16:51 PDT
I said straight off in my response that this is a partial answer. 
However, I do honestly think that you will not get anything better on
or off the Web if what you are looking for is specific factual
information.  The concept you describe would require a truly
multidisciplinary approach; the Renaissance approach of da Vinci and
other great thinkers of that time.  Unfortunately "renaissance
thinking" is not something that is encouraged or rewarded in our
times.  In part this is due to the overload of information that we
face.  Most thinkers, in order to earn their daily bread, are forced
to focus on a narrow spectrum of activity, and find it difficult to
stay current even within that limited sphere.

One commentator has mentioned the work of Blavatsky.  Another approach
that can be used is to study the Jewish Kabbalah, or Qabala as it
tends to be caled in the Western esoteric tradition.  This originally
arose as a means employed by Jewish scholars to categorise the names
of God.  In Western esoteric tradition it is used to categorise a mass
of correspondences, mythological pantheons, etc.  Either way, it can
be used to explain the different processes, forces and forms that
operate throughout the universe.  This will not give you the answers,
but it could give you the tools to apply to your own consideration of
different subjects.  An Internet search on kabbalah, qabala or Tree of
Life will produce many references to follow.  However, two good places
to start are books: The Ladder of Lights, by William Gray (Weiser,
ISBN 0-87728-536-5) which takes the Western esoteric view, and Tree of
Life by Z'ev ben Shimon Halevi (Rider, ISBN 0-09-150011-7) which is
from the Jewish tradition.
gantonick-ga rated this answer:2 out of 5 stars
partial answer

Comments  
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: markd16-ga on 10 May 2002 22:45 PDT
 
Hi there,
Helena Blavatsky's Isis Unveiled and The Secret Doctrine(which was a
resource book on Einstein's desk) will open doors to the arcane book
that you are looking for.
I think that you will write the encylopedieac trestie.
Mark
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: gantonick-ga on 13 May 2002 16:41 PDT
 
Thanks, Mark.
Helena Blavatski's insightful, unifying, and remains innovative. I
began TSD over ten years ago and consider it a work in progress. I
think you're right.. it's a step in the right direction. What I'm
looking for is a bit more explicit.. and on-line.

Thanks again.

g
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: voila-ga on 15 May 2002 12:31 PDT
 
Hi there,

It looks like this organization's vision is something you'd be
interested in, but it's still in a work-in-progress stage.  You might
get on their newsletter mailing list though and check out the resource
groups assisting them in their efforts.  I'm afraid having something
this valuable without it being a subscription-based service might be
wishful thinking.  However, if it is free, sign me up immediately. 
What a gold mine, a veritable Fort Knox of Information!

http://www.bootstrap.org

Good luck with your search.  I'll be checking on this question
frequently for any updates and I hope Google will keep this question
open for you.
V

Google search terms:

encyclopedia of knowledge+conceptual
artificial intelligence+database
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: voila-ga on 17 May 2002 13:16 PDT
 
Another in the close but no cigar realm.  Still on the hunt though.

http://everything2.com

Google search terms:
"encylopedia of everything" {doh!}
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: voila-ga on 02 Jun 2002 00:00 PDT
 
passing along this taxonomy wordmap site:
http://www.wordmap.com/map_index.html
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: gantonick-ga on 02 Jun 2002 22:52 PDT
 
voila, 

the taxonomy wordmap site is very creative! thanks for passing it
along. As you can probably guess, I'm in the middle of creating
something similar... in fact, the map analogy is very important to me.

warm regards,

gary
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: voila-ga on 05 Jun 2002 11:54 PDT
 
Hi Gary,

Glad you found that link useful.  I keep returning to this question as
I've found it the most fascinating of those posted at GA thus far. 
Any spare research time I look for additional links that might be
remotely helpful to you.  Besides, my fellow researchers are far too
quick on the draw for me to answer any live questions. ;-)  I'm mostly
in this for the hunt.  If I pick up a few dollars...yippee!

Additional Google Search Terms:

"knowledge mosaic"
"knowledge mapping"

Best of luck with your project, Gary
V
Subject: Re: looking for a conceptual, cross-discipline encyclopedia of knowledge
From: voila-ga on 09 Jun 2002 13:36 PDT
 
Hi Gary,

Here's your final link roundup for this question.  I'm now thoroughly
convinced there is no free service online that fits your requirements.
 I tried a variety of search engines besides Google just to satisfy my
curiosity though.  Among them were:

http://www.ixquick.com
http://www.wisenut.com
http://www.vivisimo.com
http://www.turbo10.com

I tried your "venus flytrap" example on a several of encyclopedia
sites and this one had the most *related* information, just not for
the cross-discipline related findings of interest to you:

http://www.encyclopedia.com/html/v/venusfly.asp 

Since I seem to gravitate towards your questions (still working on
that book summaries one, BTW), I hope you'll find these links as
interesting as I did.  You probably already many of them but, if not,
please enjoy.

http://www.awesomelibrary.org/Library/Reference_and_Periodicals/Encyclopedias/Encyclopedias
http://faculty.washington.edu/wcalvin/talks/2002-04-09-psych_files/frame.htm#slide0887.htm
http://www.infotoday.com/default.htm 
http://www.cios.org/ 
http://www.universimmedia.com/semantopic.htm 
http://jodi.ecs.soton.ac.uk/Articles/v01/i08/Miller/ 
http://www.silverplatter.com/webspirs5/index.html
http://www.theknowledgerefinery.com/frm_cont_c03-01.htm 
http://www.nexus.edu.au/teachstud/gat/whitton.htm 
http://www.hpcc.gov/pubs/ngi/implementation/g2_hp_conn.html 
http://peer.berkeley.edu/yr4_research/ta4/4031999.html
http://www.edge.org/ 
http://www.chin.gc.ca/English/Standards/standards_organizations.html 

Again, good luck with your project and thanks for this crunchy
question.
V

Additional search terms:

"Bloom's taxonomy"
"4D learning"
"Dublin core"
"metadata"
"heuristics"
"ontology"

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy