Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: myth, fiction or reality? ( Answered 4 out of 5 stars,   2 Comments )
Question  
Subject: myth, fiction or reality?
Category: Miscellaneous
Asked by: baab-ga
List Price: $10.00
Posted: 18 Aug 2002 15:04 PDT
Expires: 17 Sep 2002 15:04 PDT
Question ID: 55978
My daughter is 22; she has purchased several battery powered wristwatches
over the years, all new and in working condition, not cheap ones either!
Every time, within 2-3 days or less of wearing one, the watch stops cold!
Other people may wear the watch, and runs ok -  but will NOT run when on
my daughters wrist!  Ive heard of self-winding watches with this happening
but not battery watches; can you shed any realworld light on this or is this
just one incredible coincidence?  This has happened countless time!
thanx in advance   bob mackey  (baab-ga)  smackey549@aol.com

Request for Question Clarification by lot-ga on 18 Aug 2002 15:09 PDT
Hello,
sounds very bizarre!
this happens to LCD watches as well? e.g. Casio.
regards lot-ga
Answer  
Subject: Re: myth, fiction or reality?
Answered By: nenna-ga on 18 Aug 2002 15:44 PDT
Rated:4 out of 5 stars
 
When I read this question I was immediatly interested, as I had heard
of this before. A family member of mine has always had this problem,
and he said once a while back that he was told by a doctor that some
people have very strong magnetism in their bodies, which makes a watch
quit working over time. Sometimes it can be a year, sometimes days.
So, I went and started to research this, being that I thought I might
have a head start on this question. I however, found mixed results.

First of all, it was very clear to me that magnetisim does affect a
watch as seen here in the excerpt....
"Avoiding Magnetism

Avoid exposing an analog quartz watch to magnetism. An analog quartz
crystal watch may sometimes temporarily stop working or show a time
gain or loss if it comes in close contact with a magnetic health
appliance, such as a magnetic necklace or bracelet. It may also be
affected by the magnetic part of a household electrical appliance that
generates strong magnetism. If the magnet in the appliance interferes
with the magnet in the watch's microminiature step motor, the watch
malfunctions.
In general, a digital quartz watch is resistant to magnetism, but a
combination watch is easily affected by magnetism at its analog
section."

http://www.jcpenney.net/guide/jewelry/care/watches.htm



There are other people who have been told the same thing, that their
body magnetism affects their watches...
I was able to find a few instances of this online as seen here...

"My body chemistry stops watches! I had no idea it might be related to
my narco... In college if I wore a watch, it would stop working
withing two weeks. I started wearing a watch on a necklace penant so
it wasn't right next to my skin. My mom suggested recently (about 3
years ago) that I could put a circular band-aid on the back of my
watch, and it works! I have had the same watch now for 2 years! The
band-aid is one of those new waterproof ones, so the material is
thicker, and has like a rubber feel to it."

http://www.sleepnet.com/narco6/messages/102.html

I've heard of putting something on the back of the watch and band to
decrease the contact between it and your body, or, a lot of people
just get a pocket/pendant watch to eliminate so much body contact.

But, then, on the flip side, I came across this article....

"So what's wrong when a watch doesn't run when worn? The problem is
the watch, not the person. More often than not, the watch is worn in
an environment for which it wasn't designed. For instance, a dress
style watch is often not protected sufficiently against dust or
moisture. Some watches designed to withstand brief contact with water
are subjected to prolonged submersion in a hot tub or pool. In
addition, many watches encounter problems because their seals and
gaskets aren't replaced periodically."

"A third problem found with watches not running while on the wrist –
but still operating off the wrist – is the workmanship and ability of
the repair person. It's not unusual for a repair person, even today,
to site "mysterious body magnetism/electricity" as an excuse for his
or her inability to service a timepiece. This excuse has been recorded
in horological literature since the 18th century."

"(Jeff Cody responds: "I have always been hesitant to tell customers
it's unlikely they are to blame for unexplained stoppages, especially
when they insist they've caused other electronic equipment to fail. We
always stress that we stand behind 'unidentified' watch failures. We
also are careful to explain to each customer what he or she can expect
from the watch.")"


http://www.professionaljeweler.com/archives/articles/1999/jul99/0799te2.html

So, I guess what I can tell you is this...try putting a backing on the
watch, and see if it being off her skin helps, for some it does, for
some it does not. I can't give you a total answer. Being as that some
say it's a reality them magnetisim affects watches, and some say it's
myth. The other thing you could do would be to contact the watchmaker
and see if they've had any other complaints about that...
If she works in a job where she comes into contact with a magnetic
field or electromagnetic field it might be best for her not to wear
her watch there.
You could also talk to your family doctor and see if they had any
answers for you. I hope this sheds some light onto the subject, and
gives you a solution to your problem.

If you need anything else, feel free to request a claification of my
answer, and if you liked it :) make sure to rate it :)

Nenna-GA

Clarification of Answer by nenna-ga on 18 Aug 2002 15:45 PDT
I'm sorry, I forgot to give you my search steps....

I researched the term 

body + magnetism + watch

On http://www.Google.com

Nenna-GA
baab-ga rated this answer:4 out of 5 stars
I knew this wouldnt have a "its black or white" answer, so the info
you
sent is as good as I think it could possibly be! The arguments FOR it
being
true (watches can stop when worn) herein seem more convincing to me
then the
arguments given for it being false, quackery, etc.  Body magnetics may
be a
lot more "powerful and present" than we think, and if so, some people
have
strong magnetic "aura" others none at all; a small battery could be
affected
by a little bit of magnetics I guess- the part about shorting out
light switches.....well, that I might have to see!  thanx!  excellent.

Comments  
Subject: Re: myth, fiction or reality?
From: davidsar-ga on 18 Aug 2002 16:59 PDT
 
I remember reading reports a few years ago about people who seem to
have the same effect on their credit cards or "smart" ID cards...for
some unidentified reason, they're always wiping out the information
stored in the magnetic strips on their cards.  Does your daughter ever
experience anything similar?
Subject: Re: myth, fiction or reality?
From: lstein0-ga on 18 Aug 2002 20:15 PDT
 
Interesting topic. I can't wear some watches, so far, the ones that I
'injure' seem to be battery operated, expensive ones. It all started
with a Movado watch that I purchased a few years back. I put it on,
and in about an hour I noticed that the time was off. I thought I
hadn't pushed the pin back in. I set the time again, and within
minutes, it wasn't working. I called my jeweler, he said that it was
probably a defective watch, and exchanged it. The same thing happened
to the second watch. He called his Movado rep. and she said that there
must have been something wrong with his batch. She arranged for me to
pick up a new watch in Chicago (I purchased in Philadelphia). Within
minutes, the watch once again stopped.

When my sister mentioned this to my mother, my mother said "Oh, yes,
that used to happen to your grandmother all the time, she would stop
watches." Since then, on a bet, I've put on other people's watches,
and also stopped them. It's not a fluke, at least for me.

After doing a little research, I found out that typically this happens
to inexpensive battery operated watches. I don't consider a Movado at
$1000 to be inexpensive. The next watch I purchased was manual, and I
loved the watch, hated winding it. I can wear a Swatch without a
problem.

So, I know this to be something that has some merit of truth to it.

As an aside, I am also known for shorting light switches quite often,
about once a week or so.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy