Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Buying: Older vs. Newer Homes ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   3 Comments )
Question  
Subject: Buying: Older vs. Newer Homes
Category: Family and Home > Home
Asked by: myadventuregame-ga
List Price: $5.00
Posted: 02 Jan 2003 06:43 PST
Expires: 01 Feb 2003 06:43 PST
Question ID: 136391
Greetings Researchers & Readers!

I've made the decision that now is the time to buy a (first) home.  So
far I've looked at about 15 different homes -- ranch homes, bungalows,
colonials, big, small, etc.  And I think know what I want:
   - large (~2k sqft, 4+ bdrms) 
   - older (75+ yr) 
   - updated (new electric, plumbing, heating, windows, insulation,
etc.)

But what I don't know, however, is the economics of this choice.  I
don't plan on living in this house for more than 7 years and don’t
plan on raising a family within that time.  So, my question is, how
much more does it cost to own an older home versus a newer home?  What
maintenance costs can I expect if the previous owner already did major
updating (wiring, plumbing, heating, windows, insulation)?  What about
the resale value of the home?  What are things that I need to
consider?  What other questions should I ask?

Thanks in advance, please feel free to ask for clarification!

Alex

PS: My other GA account isn't working, so .... if you make an
edutaining game on MyAdventureGame.com about buying a home that's 30
pages and 10 pictures, you get an *additional* $20.00 tip.  Search for
"MyAdventureGame" in the GA search thing to see other questions and
details about making games.
Answer  
Subject: Re: Buying: Older vs. Newer Homes
Answered By: omnivorous-ga on 02 Jan 2003 11:13 PST
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Alex --

Purchasing and owning a home can be planned just like you would a
business.  You just need a larger "contingency" fund for an older
house!

RECURRING EXPENSES
-------------------

Your major annual recurring expenses for the home will be in the
following categories (excluding the mortgage itself):
1. property taxes
2. heating, cooling
3. insurance
4. electricity
5. water, sewer
6. garbage collection (if not a municipal service)
7. yard maintenance
8. homeowners association

In many states, the property listing will have estimates for each of
the categories.  You'll want to discuss those with the agent or your
professional service people to determine whether or not they are
realistic.

The most-variable item on the list will be heating/cooling expenses. 
Continual operation of central air conditioning will run an electric
bill into the hundreds of dollars in the summer; but you may not find
it necessary until Cleveland weather hits 90 degrees in 90% humidity.

One of the most-difficult things to judge in an older home is the
quality of the insulation.  Even if insulation has been upgraded,
there may be coldspots left.  We had reinsulated and added new
double-pane windows to a minor addition to our home in Chicago, yet it
remained cold.  Only then did we realize that while the walls and
ceiling were well insulated, we'd done nothing about the floor.  When
it was completed the room improved dramatically.

Insurance is one area in which you'll see large differences between
newer and older homes, with many insurers offering 10% discounts on
homes less than 5-10 years old.  Compounded with discounts for smoke
alarms or security systems, you may see differences of 25% or more.

Finally, you'll want to plan yard maintenance carefully.  Lawn
service, leaf removal, gutter cleaning, window washing, deck cleaning,
driveway sealing, snow removal (higher east of the Cuyahoga) all can
be done by the homeowner or contracted out.

PLANNING MAJOR REPAIRS, UPGRADES
---------------------------------

Not having owned a home, you're probably worried about the major
repair items, such as the roof, plumbing or appliances.  To help plan
for that, have a house inspection done by a professional.  We live in
a home that was new when purchased but we'd changed regions and felt
it wise to pay $250 just to have someone with whom to discuss routine
issues of water, mold/mildew, yard maintenance (this is Seattle).  It
paid dividends in a dozen small details that we'd have overlooked,
even as experienced homeowners and remodellers.

A good home inspection should tell you:
*  life of HVAC system; assessment of its efficiency
*  life expectancy of the appliances
*  economic life of roof, gutters
*  assess the quality of the plumbing; determine if there have been
leaks in the past
*  quality/integrity of windows
*  determination of quality of paint on windows, exterior
*  structural integrity of house and its framing
*  insulation quality

This do-it-yourself guide describes the process, but again a
professional who does home inspections every day will provide a wealth
of information on the materials in a house that even experienced
remodelers won't know:
ANZ Banking Group
"Pre-purchase house inspection"

The licensed professional engineers also discuss the top 10 nasty
surprises that you can face:
InspectAmerica Engineering
"Top 10 Home Defects"
http://www.inspectamerica.com/Get_Advice/Top_Ten_List/top_ten_list.html
http://www.anz.com/australia/channels/Promotion/HomeEssentials005/houseinspect.asp

InspectAmerica's home page also has a good list of issues for home
buyers or builders:
http://www.inspectamerica.com/index.html


Of course, you'll have your own input to this as certain carpeting or
wallpapering will certainly be candidate for replacement!

This way you can plan a budget of perhaps 20% of your mortgage for
improvements and repairs on an older home.  Experience has shown us
that initial costs of a new home can be very high in these
"improvement" areas: landscaping, window coverings and decorating. 
However, after about a year a new home tends to have lower costs for
maintenance items during the next 5-10 years.

The home inspection will give you a chance to outline what major
expenditures you want to tackle in the future.  If the roof has an
economic life of 30 years and 20 have already past, you may wish to
plan for its replacement in the next 5 years.  Leaks in the roof could
increase the cost of replacement beyond the value of delaying its
replacement for another year.


SOME OTHER CONSIDERATIONS
--------------------------

1.  Is there a homeowners association?  What are its responsibilities?
 Are there any major improvements being planned that might require an
assessment?

Often a homeowners association has responsibility for common areas,
such as streets, which you might have assumed to be municipal
property.  Check before buying.

2.  Does the community plan any major changes for which there might be
a special tax assessment?

3.  Resale value is tough to assess.  An "up-and-coming" area may
rebound the year after you decide to move; local employment changes
can cool a hot market quickly.  We've found a couple things in our
experience which you'll probably hear as part of the conventional
wisdom:
*  a new neighborhood appreciates very little in its first 5 years. 
When it does, houses tend to move together in a narrow range.
*  you'll see the best potential for appreciation when yours is the
least-expensive house in the neighborhood.

Good luck with the decision.  U.S. Census data predicts that you won't
be in the first house 7 years, as Americans move on average every 5
years!

Google search strategy:
"house inspections"

Best regards,

Omnivorous-GA
myadventuregame-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars and gave an additional tip of: $10.00
Thanks!  A superb answer!

Comments  
Subject: Re: Buying: Older vs. Newer Homes
From: easterangel-ga on 02 Jan 2003 07:00 PST
 
I am very happy for you myadventuregame-ga! New Year, New Home! Good
luck on making that decision.
Subject: Re: Buying: Older vs. Newer Homes
From: myadventuregame-ga on 02 Jan 2003 07:43 PST
 
Thanks easterangel!  I hope you had a great holiday and have a prosperous New Year!
Subject: Re: Buying: Older vs. Newer Homes
From: owain-ga on 05 Jan 2003 10:11 PST
 
I suspect the answer may be different in the US where land is probably
more readily available and possibly where newer houses are more
desirable. However, from a UK perspective, regarding the resale value
of property: older property generally has more space and more garden
ground. As populations and land cost increase, garden space will
become rarer and more desirable especially in town and city centres.
From this point of view, older property is a better investment.

The supply of period houses is fixed (or, due to demolition,
redevelopment etc, actually diminishing), whilst there will always be
new houses being built. The number of period houses relative to the
total housing stock is therefore decreasing, and if they are desirable
their price may increase at a greater rate than new property. From
this point of view, period property is a better investment.

If you buy a new house, you are paying for the developer's profit
margin (which in the UK is quite high) and shiny new paintwork and
fittings. In 7 years time, that paintwork won't be so shiny, the
builder's structural warranty will be running out, and you will be
selling in competition with newly-built properties.

In other words, 'newness' as an advantage to a property is lost over
(quite a short) period of time. 'Oldness' as an advantage increases
over time.

Owain

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy