Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: software clone for MS Office suite ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   0 Comments )
Question  
Subject: software clone for MS Office suite
Category: Computers > Software
Asked by: aryaone-ga
List Price: $25.00
Posted: 27 Jan 2003 07:05 PST
Expires: 26 Feb 2003 07:05 PST
Question ID: 149070
wanted latest research on feasibility of using StarOffice 6.0 from Sun
Microsystems in lieu of MS Office Suite.
study should reflect acceptability as well as pitfalls, if there are
any.
Answer  
Subject: Re: software clone for MS Office suite
Answered By: kyrie26-ga on 27 Jan 2003 09:09 PST
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Hi aryaone-ga,

Thank you for your question. I found you some excellent documents that
compare StarOffice 6.0 with Microsoft Office. Because "feasibility"
depends on your specific situation, I've made the effort to look up
documents and articles  that are detailed in their comparison of the
two software suites, across different aspects. Have a look :

+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

StarOfficeTM 5.2 software and StarOfficeTM 6.0 software and
Microsoft Office XP Feature Comparison
http://www.math.mcgill.ca/sysdocs/staroffice/collateral/MS_COMPARISON.PDF

Here's a relevant excerpt :

"Overall, because of the familiarity of MS Office products, users may
find Office XP initially easier to use than StarOffice software.
However, usability and customer research shows that simple tasks are
easily performed and completed successfully by all StarOffice software
users. StarOffice software users continue to gain comfort with more
complex tasks after about a week of using StarOffice software. Then
after using StarOffice software for a while, productivity is
comparable and in some cases actually better due to the integration of
the StarOffice software product."

Comparison topics covered :

System Requirements
Product Offerings
Ease of Learning Features 
Ease of Use
General Formatting 
Word Processing
HTML / Web Publishing
Spreadsheet
Charting
Presentation
Extras
Desktop View
Accessibility
Localization
Interoperability
Graphic Support

+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Here is another article worth reading :

StarOffice 6.0 Review
http://www.unixreview.com/documents/s=7459/uni1029855913341/

"I will say, however, that StarOffice feels and looks somewhat more
polished than its free counterpart and that might be enough of a
reason to spend the money on StarOffice, particularly in an office
environment.  After all, when you compare StarOffice's $75.95 price
tag with Microsoft Office XP's at anywhere from $400 to $500, it's
hard to go wrong. "

+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Here's an article that is more slanted toward Microsoft Office :

StarOffice 6.0: End of the free ride
http://www.zdnet.com.au/reviews/software/business/story/0,2000023555,20265366,00.htm

"StarOffice 6.0 won't give Microsoft Office users who are equipped
with Office 2000 or XP any reason to switch. Likewise, the move to a
paid-for structure negates one of our strongest arguments for using
StarOffice as an alternative office suite. If you just need an
inexpensive suite, however, StarOffice provides you with all of the
fundamental applications -- a word processor, a spreadsheet, a
presentation maker and an illustration program."

+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Here are some other relevant articles  :

StarOffice 6.0 reviewed by PC Magazine
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,4149,1308,00.asp

ZDNet Sun Microsystems StarOffice 6.0 Review
http://www.zdnet.com/supercenter/stories/review/0,12070,535514,00.html

StarOffice 6.0 - Software Reviews - CNET.com
http://www.cnet.com/software/0-811003-8-9907132-1.html

+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+


Google search terms :

feasibility OR compare OR comparison StarOffice "MS Office" OR
"microsoft office"

StarOffice 6.0 "MS Office" OR "microsoft office" feasibility OR
assessment


I hope the above resources are what you are looking for, and will
assist you in making a well-informed decision. In the event that you
have any questions or need further information, please do not hesitate
to post a Request For Clarification and I will do my best to help you.
Thank you for using Google Answers!


Regards,

kyrie26-ga

Request for Answer Clarification by aryaone-ga on 28 Jan 2003 09:02 PST
your work is entirely satisfactory. but before we close may i request
you to look for some data on whether "the Sun Microsystems make
themslves very attractive in the beginning, but as time passes, they
tend to hike up the cost in terms of upgrades or support etc".

may i know your background in terms of expertise? 

dr k

Clarification of Answer by kyrie26-ga on 28 Jan 2003 19:48 PST
Hi again aryaone-ga,

It is anyone's guess whether or not Sun Microsystems will replace
Microsoft as the new "dictator" in the desktop business software
arena. There is no such data. My gut feeling is, no, nobody can beat
Microsoft's "take over the world" syndrome. However, I've dug up the
following articles so that you can make an informed decision.

In answer to your question, I am a Web Developer and have very many
years of IT experience.


+------------------------------------------------------+

ZDNet Tech Update Enterprise Applications - Microsoft unveils new
Office plans
http://techupdate.zdnet.com/techupdate/stories/main/0,14179,2872074,00.html

[begin excerpt]

While Microsoft still dominates the desktop business software market,
customers may be taking a closer look at competitive packages, such as
StarOffice. One reason: a new licensing plan aimed at businesses which
takes effect on July 31.

Though the plan is intended to make revenue more predictable for
Microsoft, it could also significantly raise prices for customers,
according to market researcher Gartner. As of last month, two-thirds
of Microsoft's largest customers had not yet signed up for the plan.

Raikes said Microsoft has not seen any reasons to be concerned about
competitors. "Anytime there is a challenge in the marketplace, people
like to talk and write about it. But what we see is that today people
want a relationship with Microsoft to get the latest Office technology
to get their jobs done."

[end excerpt]

+------------------------------------------------------+

Survey: Anger at Microsoft's new licensing - Tech News - CNET.com
http://news.com.com/2100-1001-273953.html

[begin excerpt]

Conducted by market researcher Giga and Windows NT/2000 integrator
Sunbelt Software, the survey of 4,550 technology professionals found
that 80 percent of those polled expected to pay more for Microsoft
software under the controversial new programs. About 42 percent said
their Microsoft software costs would increase anywhere from 20 percent
to 50 percent. Of the remainder, 19 percent said their costs would
double or triple, while 7 percent saw no change and another 2.6
percent expected a decrease.

The survey also found that 36 percent said they would consider
alternative products in light of the changes.

The high number of potential defectors is likely an emotional
reaction, said analysts, but it's a further indication that Microsoft
may have blundered when it enacted new licensing provisions Oct. 1.

The new licensing program discontinued the most popular means by which
businesses buy Microsoft software for desktops and back-end computer
operations. Under the new programs, customers don't simply buy
software and worry about upgrades in the future. Instead, they are
placed in a program that commits them to upgrading every two years.
According to market researcher Gartner, the program will raise prices
anywhere from 33 percent to 100 percent. Microsoft has also peppered
the contract with contingencies that get customers to switch to the
new maintenance deals sooner rather than later.

[end excerpt]

+------------------------------------------------------+

USATODAY.com - A new way to fight Microsoft
http://www.usatoday.com/tech/columnist/2002/06/20/sinrod.htm

[begin excerpt]

In a letter dated June 4 to Mitchell Daniels Jr., the director of the
Office of Management and Budget, Nader, along with James Love, of the
Consumer Project on Technology, asserts that while "the Department of
Justice is spending years in court trying to restrain very modest
elements of Microsoft's monopoly abuses," Microsoft still "has an
astounding market share for desktop operating systems and office
productivity software." Nader and Love complain that there are
"serious problems with the Microsoft monopoly, including those
associated with harm to innovation, security and pricing."

Nader and Love further state that the federal government "spends
billions of dollars on software purchases from one company [Microsoft]
that is continually raising prices, making its products incompatible
with previous versions in order to force upgrades, deliberately
creating interoperability problems with would-be competitors, and
[engages] in many other anticompetitive practices." They suggest that
a private business in the U.S. government's shoes would not be a
"passive consumer" as apparently is the government up to this point.

[end excerpt]

+------------------------------------------------------+

Is StarOffice ready to take on Microsoft Office?: ZDNet Australia News
& Tech: OS
http://www.zdnet.com.au/newstech/os/story/0,2000024997,20259611,00.htm

[begin excerpt]

Perhaps the most significant opportunity for StarOffice is the recent
increase in Office licensing costs. Our analysis shows that IT
organizations are facing an increase of between 22 percent and 40
percent at the highest discount level.

Organisations that would happily budget for a new version of Office
every three to four years are not happy about being asked to pay as if
they upgraded every two years. As they plan desktop strategies for the
next five years, more organisations are considering whether Office on
the desktop is what they really need.

That is not to say that they would replace Office for all users, but
the price increase is forcing organisations to ask new questions: What
is it their users do; what are their productivity processes, and what
do they really need? Is there a better application to do their core
task? Is there a better approach than one-size-fits-all?

[end excerpt]

+------------------------------------------------------+

[begin excerpt]

8023 StarOffice[TM] Software Offers Alternative to Microsoft Office
Suite
http://gmi.systemnews.com/system-news/jobdir/submitted/2002.12/8023/8023.html

17.Oct.02--Feeling a bit disgruntled about Microsoft's new Volume
Licensing 6.0 Program, particularly that dreaded Software Assurance
component? You know, the part that requires you to pay in advance for
an upgrade you may or may not need, whether you're ready or not. Well,
you're not alone as many CIOs and IT managers grapple with how to
handle Microsoft's latest "the more money we can extract from our
customers the better" sales scheme. In a recent survey by Microsoft
Windows consulting company Sunbelt Software, Inc. and Information
Technology Intelligence Corp., of the 1500 technology managers polled,
36 percent reported they don't have the necessary funds to upgrade to
the Microsoft Volume Licensing 6.0 Program; separately, 38 percent
said
they are actively seeking alternatives to Microsoft products. (1) In
another survey of corporate technology buyers, conducted by a well
known financial firm in September 2002, only 7 percent of customers
are
pleased with the licensing changes, and 37 percent signed up

Furthermore, industry analysts estimate that 60 percent or more of
eligible customers chose not to sign up for the Software Assurance
program before its July 31, 2002 deadline. (3) If you're one of these
60 percent and are looking for a lower-cost alternative, now may be a
good time to make the switch to a new office productivity suite, such
as Sun's StarOfficeTM software. Sun has made a concerted effort to
provide a desktop package that virtually eliminates vendor lock-in and
proprietary formats and puts you, the customer, in control.

True to its philosophy, Sun makes it simple. The StarOffice software
has no confusing or complex licensing or software assurance programs
that dictate upgrade cycles. Whereas Sun offers the flexibility to
skip
versions of the StarOffice software, or to upgrade when you've
determined you're ready, Microsoft's Software Assurance program
ignores
customers'--your--needs by requiring you to pay up-front for rights to
future upgrades that may offer little in the way of compelling,
productivity-enhancing functionality. Yes, that's right. You must make
a financial commitment to a product that is not yet deployed in your
environment.

Sun believes that customers want and need a choice. The StarOffice 6.0
Office Suite--SunTM Open Net Environment (Sun ONE) software offering
(StarOffice Office Suite) delivers the increased freedom that helps
enable customers to make smart, cost-effective decisions that will
protect their employees' productivity and lower their total cost of
ownership. Featuring rich functionality, open source foundation and
interoperability with Microsoft Windows, and most importantly cost
sensitivity, the StarOffice Office Suite proves it is the right
alternative to Microsoft Office. The StarOffice Office Suite has
growing momentum, both in the corporate world and elsewhere. In fact,
as a signal of Sun's commitment to the StarOffice Office Suite
software
and of its support of students and educators worldwide, Sun has
donated
more than $6 billion worth of the StarOffice 6.0 Office Suite
software--reaching 240 million students worldwide--to academic
institutions throughout the world. (4)

[end excerpt]

+------------------------------------------------------+


Google search terms :

microsoft office raise OR raising OR increase OR increasing prices
microsoft office staroffice raise OR raising OR increase OR increasing
prices


I hope this is sufficient information to make an informed decision.
Let me know if you still need further clarification. Thanks!


Regards,

kyrie26-ga

Request for Answer Clarification by aryaone-ga on 29 Jan 2003 08:03 PST
have rated and closed.

am impressed. would like you to contact helix consulting and send in
your resume. i don't know how this may work out, but one role is that
of a researcher or problem solver. helix consults with small to medium
companies in IT issues.

regards

dr k

Clarification of Answer by kyrie26-ga on 29 Jan 2003 09:48 PST
aryaone-ga,

Thank you for the 5 stars! I'm very honored that you are satisfied
with my work. I did a search for Helix Consulting and the only one I
found in the consulting business is The Helix Group, who specializes
in Management Consulting. Is this the right one? I have sent in my
resume to the email address provided on the contact page. I am
definitely open to opportunities. Please provide your URL if I went to
the wrong page. Thank you, it was a pleasure researching for you.


Sincerely,

kyrie26-ga

Request for Answer Clarification by aryaone-ga on 29 Jan 2003 11:22 PST
my business partner's name is carol. her email is
uranus1@mindspring.net.
(that is a numeric "1" after uranus).

her cell phone in th US is 602-330-6767 and the office line is
480-481-0009. fax 480-481-0017.

regards.

Dr. Kaikobad.
602-332-1646

Clarification of Answer by kyrie26-ga on 29 Jan 2003 13:23 PST
Dr. Kaikobad,

Thanks! I have sent my resume to her. I guess it wouldn't hurt to
check out what you have in store, if anything. I'm currently in
Toronto, ON, though, and considering you seem to be in Phoenix, AZ,
some Google-Answers-style "telework" may be called for. In any case, I
wish you all the best.


Regards,

kyrie26-ga
aryaone-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars and gave an additional tip of: $5.00
top quality very detailed research.

Comments  
There are no comments at this time.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy