Ok, I can probably spend hours researching this for myself, but I'm
hoping you guys have a quicker way of doing it.

I'm looking to buy a new fridge, which must meet the following
criteria:

1) Have a stainless steel finish (black sides are ok)
2) Be a side-by-side type with a water and ice dispenser on the
outside
3) Fit in a 37" wide and 70" high space
4) Not be more than 25" deep (not including handles) - counter depth
5) Be EnergyStar compliant  (preferably)

I'm not looking for any super expensive brands like SubZero, but
something under $2500US.

I would like brand and model numbers, links to manufacturer's website
info, and reviews on the selected models.

Thanks!

Check out this Jenn-Air refrigerator. I immediately wanted to
recommend a Kitchen Aid, since that is what I have, but realized that
it didn't meet your height requirements. This particular one below
seems to meet all of your requirements.

In case the link doesn't work, you want to go to www.jennair.com and
search for item JCD2389G; the Jenn-AirŪ 23 Cu. Ft. Counter Depth
Side-By-Side $2,269.00.

http://www.jennair.com/ja/products/prod_detail.jsp?model=JCD2389GES&cs=1&BV_UseBVCookie=No&BV_SessionID=@@@@0151954154.1046665503@@@@&BV_EngineID=ccccadchjimfdfecekhcfffdflfdfmi.0

Good luck!

Note that the Jenn-Air JCD2389G refrigerator mentioned by lstein0-ga
has a depth of 26 5/8 inches, including the doors but excluding the
handles. Only if the doors are not included would it meet your depth
guideline of 25 inches or less.

http://www.jennair.com/products/images/djcd22.pdf