Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: uk copyright ( Answered,   2 Comments )
Question  
Subject: uk copyright
Category: Business and Money
Asked by: frankauf-ga
List Price: $15.00
Posted: 19 Jun 2003 04:50 PDT
Expires: 19 Jul 2003 04:50 PDT
Question ID: 219154
In copyright law in the UK, if a license agreement states that the
author shall not write a competing work during the "life of the
agreement" and the license is for the legal term of copyright, does
this mean that no competing works shall be allowed for 50 years beyond
the daeth of the author?

Clarification of Question by frankauf-ga on 19 Jun 2003 15:52 PDT
This licence agreement states"...the author for the legal term of
copyright...grants to the Publishers the sole and exclusive right and
licence to produce and publish the Work...

Later in the agreement it further states "during the life of this
agreement, the author agrees not to write or contribute to any work
liable in the Publisher's opinion to affect adversely sales of the
work, without the prior consent of the publishers.

What I would like to know is for how long may I not write a competing
work?  How do I construe "the life of the agreement?"  Is the life of
the agreement synonymous with the legal term of copyright?  The
agreemnt does not specify term of years for the agreement.

Request for Question Clarification by jem-ga on 20 Jun 2003 09:57 PDT
Hi frankauf :)

Can you reconfirm for Researchers that your questions are as follows:

1. If you sign the agreement, what time period you are restricted to
NOT being able to write competing works?
2. Whether the "life of the agreement" is related in any way to the
"legal term of copyright" (by the way, probonopublico is correct in
that legal copyright in published works extends to 70 years after the
death of the author - thanks probono :) )

Kind regards
jem-ga

Clarification of Question by frankauf-ga on 20 Jun 2003 10:53 PDT
Hello Jem,
Thank you for your reply.  Yes, I can confirm that your understanding
of my questions is correct.  Thank you too, Probonopublico, for your
correction.
Frankauf
Answer  
Subject: Re: uk copyright
Answered By: jem-ga on 21 Jun 2003 10:17 PDT
 
Hi again frankauf :)

Thanks for your clarification - much appreciated.  I'm going to answer
your question on the basis that:

1. The agreement you're referring to is governed by UK law;
2. That your questions are as confirmed in the clarification which you
replied to on 20 June and;
3. That this answer will be provided on the basis of my experience in
this area (i.e. I see a lot of these types of agreements in my line of
work). I will also provide you with some general reference links at
the end of the answer regarding contract and copyright law but the
basis of my answer will be from personal knowledge and how I
understand the question in light of the information provided.

With respect to your first question, i.e. "If you sign the agreement,
what time period you are restricted to NOT being able to write
competing works?" it would seem that on first glance, you are
restricted to not being able to write competing works "during the life
of this agreement" (bear in mind that you MIGHT still be able to write
competing works during the life of the agreement provided you get
consent of the publishers).  You state, however, that the agreement
does not specify a term of years.

You should doublecheck the agreement to confirm that it definitely
does NOT have any term length specified (some agreements will, at the
very least, have what's known as an "initial term" which will usually
start at around 1 year, after which point either party can cancel the
agreement).

Following on from my paragraph above, you should also check to see if
there is any kind of termination clause - this is the type of clause
that will allow either or both parties to terminate the agreement upon
a certain amount of notice being given to the other party.

If you cannot find any term length specified in the agreement, then it
suggests (and I say suggest because I have not seen the entire
agreement, only the wording which you've supplied) that the agreement
is either meant to be, at the very least, perpetual OR that the
publishers have either forgotten or chosen not to include a term
length with respect to the agreement.  If this is the case, then this
means that you will not be entitled to write competing works for at
least the length of your natural life without the prior consent of the
publishers.  I say for "at least the length of your natural life"
because basic contract law suggests that when one party to a contract
is deceased, then the contract becomes invalid.  There may, however,
be other provisions in the agreement which state otherwise - again,
you will need to check.

If you can find a termination clause clause in the agreement which
allows you to terminate, then once you terminate the agreement, the
obligation to ask for permission with respect to writing competing
works also terminates (subject to any other restrictive clauses that
might be in the agreement).

With respect to your second question i.e. "Whether the "life of the
agreement" is related in any way to the "legal term of copyright":

1. There may be a clause in the agreement somewhere specifically
stating that both parties agree that the life of the agreement is
deemed to be equal to the legal term of copyright.  You need to check
for this.

2. By signing the agreement itself, "....the author for the legal term
of copyright...grants to the Publishers the sole and exclusive right
and licence to produce and publish the Work.." it appears irrelevant
whether there is an actual specified term of the agreement or not. 
What the clause is suggesting is that you are giving the Publishers an
exclusive licence for the Works during your lifetime plus 70 years
after your death, regardless of any length of the agreement. If there
is no actual specified term of the agreement, you should assume that
this is the case.  If there IS a specified term of the agreement, then
it still suggests that the legal term of copyright will still be the
life of the author plus 70 years UNLESS there is some mechanism, such
as a termination clause, which allows both parties to terminate their
obligations under the agreement OR unless it states something to
contrary elsewhere in the agreement.

I hope that the above proves useful to you.  Based on the limited
information to hand, I've tried to provide an answer which will give
you a good basis for doing some further investigations on your own. 
I've also had to limit my answers to "possibly's", "mights" and
"suggests" as its very difficult to construe a contract's meaning (and
certain clauses) without seeing the document in its entirety.  I've
also listed some links below which you may find useful in light of
your question.  Should you require any clarification, please do let me
know before hitting the rating button :)

Kind regards
jem-ga :)

1.Website of the UK Patent Office which has an EXCELLENT section on
copyright including defintions of copyright, basic copyright
information and guidance notes:

http://www.patent.gov.uk/copy/index.htm

2. For links to organisations who assist with protecting copyright,
including copyright in published materials visit:

http://www.intellectual-property.gov.uk/std/resources/copyright/published.htm

3. The British Copyright Council's website also has some very useful
guides for download (available in .pdf format) available at:

http://www.editor.net/bcc/publications.php

*You can download Adobe's .pdf reader (Adobe Acrobat) for free at:

http://www.adobe.com

4. Of particular interest, visit:

http://www.anweb.co.uk

a website billing itself as a "resource for artists".  Although
initially it looks like it relates only to print work artists (e.g.
for example, graphic designers or portrait painters) it has excellent
resources for artists of all kinds (e.g. writers, musicians, etc)
including;

"What is a Contract" found at:

http://www.anweb.co.uk/l_04_d3/d3a01.htm

"Standard Terms in Artists' UK Contracts":

http://www.anweb.co.uk/l_04_d3/d3a07.htm

"Ways Out of a Contract":

http://www.anweb.co.uk/l_04_d3/d3a13.htm

and an extensive section on copyright starting at:

http://www.anweb.co.uk/l_04_d3/d3b01.htm
Comments  
Subject: Re: uk copyright
From: bitmaven-ga on 19 Jun 2003 12:28 PDT
 
Frankauf-ga: 


    Warning:  There is no legal basis here, just some logical
reasoning.  If A drafts an agreement with B, the author, stipulating
that B will not write any competing work for the life of the
agreement, then it should really only be tied to B, dont'cha think?  
You don't usually have contracts carry-over.   That's what copyright
itself would be for.   You go after the folks who write derrivative
works through the copyright law.  You don't have any contract with
others.


    Just a guess.
Subject: Re: uk copyright
From: probonopublico-ga on 19 Jun 2003 13:09 PDT
 
It's 70 years after the death of the author ...

Or, at least, that's what the beneficiaries of my estate are counting on.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy