Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: How to Measure Consulting Services (Utilization, Backlog, etc.) ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   0 Comments )
Question  
Subject: How to Measure Consulting Services (Utilization, Backlog, etc.)
Category: Computers > Software
Asked by: softwareinseattle-ga
List Price: $15.00
Posted: 02 Jul 2003 16:21 PDT
Expires: 01 Aug 2003 16:21 PDT
Question ID: 224469
I work for an enterprise software company in the Seattle area.  We had
a very experienced VP of Professional Services (VP of Consulting), who
recently left the company.  There’s a good chance I’ll be asked to
take over the department, which I am very excited about.  But I need
help identifying and understanding the “standard metrics” used in
consulting organizations.  This will help me have the confidence
needed to get the promotion, and it will help me avoid serious fumbles
in the first week on the job.

Bonus for a good tip:  what are the most likely optimizations to be
made in a medium sized consulting team?  What metrics and reports can
be used to identify areas that should be adjusted, or that require
special attention?


Additional Info:

I’m talking about metrics such as utilization, average billing rate,
and backlog.  What are the other metrics, and which ones are the most
critical?  Where possible, please tell me what the “norms” are for
enterprise software consulting (or similar field).  What is a popular
tool used for collecting and reporting on these metrics?

Please let me know if you (the answerer) have worked in this field or
if you have relied solely on your research skills to find your
answers.

Thank you!
Answer  
Subject: Re: How to Measure Consulting Services (Utilization, Backlog, etc.)
Answered By: wonko-ga on 02 Jul 2003 18:13 PDT
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Hi software in Seattle,

I used to work in the consulting group of a large enterprise software
company.  The consulting organization was organized in a hierarchical
structure comprising a VP of consulting, group leaders, project
managers, and application engineers.  The following is a list of the
key metrics tracked for each position reporting ultimately to the VP
of consulting.

Group Leader (responsible for a particular geography and/or type of
customer):
-willingness of customers to act as a reference for prospective
customers
-customer satisfaction index score of customer from annual customer
satisfaction survey
-employee satisfaction from employee satisfaction survey of group
members
-coordination with other teams (sharing of key personnel resources)
-development of group members (training and promotions to higher
levels of responsibility)
-revenue
-margin (basically another way of looking at utilization)
-follow on business obtained from the customers
-administrative/implementation methodology compliance of group members
-new product ideas specified

Project Manager (responsible for a particular customer):
-willingness of customer to act as a reference for prospective
customers
-customer satisfaction index score of customer from annual customer
satisfaction survey
-employee satisfaction from employee satisfaction survey of group
members (direct reports and manager)
-development of group members (training and promotions to higher
levels of responsibility)
-revenue
-follow on business obtained from the customers
-leverage of customer resources (success in obtaining personnel
resources from customer when needed)
-meeting of project milestones
-administrative/implementation methodology compliance of group members
-new product ideas specified
-contribution to implementation methodology
-documented beneficial results to the customer from the project

Application Engineer (actually installs the software):
-customer satisfaction index score of customer from annual customer
satisfaction survey
-employee satisfaction of project manager
-teamwork with other group members
-revenue
-leverage of customer resources (success in obtaining personnel
resources from customer when needed)
-meeting of project milestones
-new product ideas specified
-creative use of the software product when required to meet customer
needs
-documented beneficial results to the customer from the project

We used Oracle Financials to track the quantifiable metrics.

The key issues for us, beside from utilization, were personnel
development and coordination of resources across teams.  We were
growing extremely rapidly, so it was extremely important for the group
leaders and VP of consulting to have reasonably accurate forecast of
the types of people who would be needed three to six months in the
future so that they could be hired or promoted and trained in time. 
Because certain skills were in short supply in the company,
coordinating key bottleneck resources across multiple projects to keep
them all on track was also critical.  Since I was one such critical
resource, I frequently had to work at one client during the day for
one group leader, fly all night, and then work at a different client
the next day for a different group leader to keep projects from
falling behind schedule.

One other important issue, aside from meeting project milestones, is
ensuring that the right resources are being employed at the right time
according to the initial project plan.  Typically, a customer is given
an estimate of the resources to be employed or a fixed price is agreed
to for the project.  Making sure that the actual resources employed do
not deviate substantially from the original plan, at least in dollar
terms, while simultaneously keeping the project on schedule is
critical to high levels of customer satisfaction and your firm's
profitability.

Many of the above metrics are more strategic in nature than tactical,
but they are still important over the long-term.  For example, poor
customer satisfaction results can be costly and disruptive if they
become public.  Siebel systems is one recent example.  "Siebel
squelches rumors about customer satisfaction" by Ann Bednarz, Network
World Fusion, April 10, 2003. 
http://www.networkworldfusion.com/news/2003/0410siebel.html.  And,
having customers willing to act as references for prospective
customers is extremely valuable.

I hope this was what you were looking for.  Please request
clarification if needed.

Sincerely,

Wonko

Request for Answer Clarification by softwareinseattle-ga on 02 Jul 2003 18:39 PDT
Hi Wonko,

Thanks for the answer so far.  This is helpful.  I certainly
appreciate the higher level "customers need to be happy" information,
but I am looking for a list of the standard metrics, such as
utilization, and what they typically look like. For example, how is
utilization typically expressed, what does a utilization report look
like?  What is a typical hourly rate for a consultant (junior,
average, senior)?  What are the other day-to-day numbers used by
management to understand how their consulting practice is running? 
Can you make a guess as to what the most likely optimizations would be
in a typical medium sized consulting team?  What metrics and reports
can be used to identify areas that should be adjusted, or that require
special attention?

Thanks!

Clarification of Answer by wonko-ga on 03 Jul 2003 22:34 PDT
OK.  I appreciate the direction.  Let me try to further assist you.

Utilization is typically expressed as a percentage of the hours billed
to a customer versus the hours available.  So, if I bill 30 hours in a
week to a customer, and my standard workweek is 40 hours, then I could
be said to be 75% utilized.  A variation on this theme would be to
include a standard billing rate so that if I am billing at a
discounted rate, my utilization is lower.  One may also have to adjust
the denominator for travel time if one is allowed to bill travel time
and travels frequently to avoid having utilization in excess of 100%.

As far as a typical hourly rate for a consultant goes, I would need to
know a great deal more about your particular niche and what types of
services you are providing to even be able to hazard a guess.  In
order to obtain a benchmarking of your consulting rates, you might
consider posing a new question on Google Answers with specific details
about the type of consulting your firm does.  I will offer an overview
of my former employer's rates as of 2000, although this, of course,
was during the boom in IT, so I would be skeptical that they have been
able to maintain these rates at these levels.  Also, they had a
well-known product that was in high demand at the time that few people
could implement, which increased consulting rates.

Application Engineers, who install the software, were billed out at
anywhere from $150-$250 per hour depending upon experience.  Project
Managers, who oversaw the project and worked with the customer to
develop their business process using the software, were billed out at
anywhere from $200-$275 per hour depending on experience and the scope
of the project.  Group Leaders and Industry Experts were billed out at
from $300-$500 per hour.  Of course, large customers with complex
projects frequently were able to negotiate 25 to 40% discounts on
these rates as part of a large software license purchase.

Another number to look at is expenses incurred by the consultants,
particularly if these are not being billed back to the customer.  Even
if they are billed back to customers, it is a good idea to keep an eye
on them so that customers don't reject your invoices.  There can be an
enormous amount of waste here.  Expensive meals that don't involve
entertaining clients, expensive hotels, and inefficient use of air
travel and rental cars can significantly damage profitability. 
Cellular telephones can also add up, particularly if people have
unnecessarily large allocations of minutes.  If your firm uses a lot
of these services, have you negotiated bulk discounts from the
providers?  My firm had a sizable discount on airfare, rental cars,
and cellular telephones since we concentrated our business with a
single provider of each as much as possible.

In general, the key numbers to be focused on are revenue per
consultant, margin per consultant, consultant utilization, and
ensuring that sufficient consulting resources are available for
current and anticipated near-term projects.

One would want to look at revenue per consultant to see if it is
comparable with what other firms are able to get for similar services.
 Margin per consultant can identify either poorly utilized consultants
(when compared with the consultant utilization figure) or consultants
potentially incurring more expenses than they should.  Of course,
allowance needs to be made for the cost of living in various locations
since they can differ widely.  Having resource plans developed for
near-term projects and having resources assigned to them in advance is
also critical to both ensuring that the right resources are available
and that they can get to the project as efficiently as possible
(purchasing advanced airfare versus a walk-up fare, for example).

Finally, to ensure a healthy consulting practice, one wants to look at
personnel development.  Is there a high level of turnover in the
organization?  If so, why?  Are people getting the training that they
need in order to serve customers well and to advance in the company? 
How successful is the company at developing application engineers into
project managers and group leaders?  If it isn't successful, why not? 
Are there particular individuals who have critical technical skills
that the company really needs to retain and pay extra attention to in
order to keep them happy and in place?

I hope this discussion of tactical and strategic areas to examine was
helpful.  If you require further clarification, please ask.

Sincerely,

Wonko
softwareinseattle-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars and gave an additional tip of: $5.00
Thanks Wonko - that's what I needed!  (And armchair answerers, feel
free to chime in with your thoughts, too!)

Comments  
There are no comments at this time.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy