Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Web Site Link Guidelines ( Answered 4 out of 5 stars,   1 Comment )
Question  
Subject: Web Site Link Guidelines
Category: Computers > Internet
Asked by: skip9801-ga
List Price: $5.00
Posted: 23 Jul 2003 20:45 PDT
Expires: 22 Aug 2003 20:45 PDT
Question ID: 234453
When you're developing a web site, what are the guidelines for adding
links to other sites?  Do you need to, or should you, inform the
administrator of the other site that you wish your site to link to
their site?

Does it matter what kind of site you're linking to?
Answer  
Subject: Re: Web Site Link Guidelines
Answered By: slawek-ga on 23 Jul 2003 21:31 PDT
Rated:4 out of 5 stars
 
Good Day skip9801,


There are two types of links to other web sites:

1. You can link to a web site for the purpose of loading it into the
same or new browser window (i.e.: Your personal web site talks about
your newly purchased vehicle from a Toyota dealership. You are so
please with the service, in your web site article you provide a link
to the dealer's web site)

2. You can link to a web site for the purpose of using it's content on
your page (i.e.: You are so excited about your newly purchased
vehicle, you want the whole world to see it. You add an image of your
new vehicle to your web site, but rather than downloading it into your
web space from the dealers web site you create a link reference
instead. Every time the image is requested for loading on your web
site, the picture is fetched from the dealers web site.)

The first example is fully acceptable. The dealer will be pleased that
you are giving them free exposure and a means for potential new
clients to find their business. Ethically speaking, you do not need to
notify the dealership you have provided a link to their web site.
However, it can benefit everyone if you do notify the dealer of your
addition. Maybe the dealer will be so happy, they will add a link to
your page from their’s under customer testimonials: "Another happy
customer, skip9801. See his web page about his experience in
purchasing a vehicle from our dealership".

Also, the dealership would probably like to know where their customers
find them. Maybe all their TV advertising money is getting them less
business than making sure that each and every customer is 100%
satisfied.

In the example #2 listed above, you are stealing an image and
bandwidth. This is VERY unacceptable behaviour. If the copyright
allows it and you have acquired full permission, you may use the image
by downloading it into your web space, not directly linking to it in
someone else's web space.

In short, linking to pages is fine. Linking to images is frowned upon.

Before you go and add a link of another page to your web site, make
sure it rates well on the PageRank scale.  What is the PR scale?  Read
about it at Google:

URL: ://www.google.ca/technology/index.html

In short, page rank decides how valuable a web site is (the criteria
for this is described in the above link). Linking to pages with high
PR can improve your web site's PR. Even more important is having web
sites with high PR linking to your web site.

For quick access to a web site's PR value, head over to
http://toolbar.google.com/ and download Google's Internet Explorer
Toolbar addition. The toolbar will display a web site's PR in the
toolbar.

A high PR means your web site will be listed higher in the search
results when multiple matches are found. Your web site is considered
more valuable.

I hope you will find this information valuable and that it answers
your questions in full. If not, please do not hesitate to ask for a
clarification.

The above information is a quick summary of what I have learned on
this subject during my ongoing career as a web developer. No search
strategy was used.


Regards,
slawek-ga

Request for Answer Clarification by skip9801-ga on 23 Jul 2003 21:38 PDT
Slawek-ga,

Thanks for your quick and detailed response.  But, would like to get
clarification on your example #1 (where you link to a site for
purposes of loading it into the same or a new a browser window).

I can appreciate that if the target of the link is flattered with the
link, they would not object.

What I'm wondering is what happens if, for whatever reason, they don't
like being linked from your site.  Will you get into any trouble
without previously recieved an okay to link to their site?  Is there
any legal requirement?

Thanks.

Clarification of Answer by slawek-ga on 23 Jul 2003 22:08 PDT
Good Evening skip9801,


Taking into consideration the very slim possibility that a web site
does not wish to be linked to, you are still within the law if you DO
link anyway.

Unless there is a clear legal notice stating "Do not link to this page
for ANY REASON", you are safe. Even in the event that such a
disclaimer was posted, you could not be charged with anything. In that
sense, the web is public domain.

Linking with the purpose of doing harm is the only time you might get
into trouble, but on different grounds. For example, developing a
children's web site and placing a disguised link to hate content might
get you in trouble on moral grounds.  Still, unlikely.

In the case you are describing the worst that can happen is the web
site owner can send you a message asking that you remove their link
from your web site. There is no law that says you have to obey such a
request, and you have broken no law if you disregard the request.

If you are still unsure, and feel that maybe my answer does not apply
in your scenario, can you maybe post the web sites you wish to link
to, and in what context (what is your web site about, for what purpose
are you linking)?

Hope this eases your mind. :)


Regards,
slawek-ga
skip9801-ga rated this answer:4 out of 5 stars
Good answer.  Good detail, good examples.

Comments  
Subject: Re: Web Site Link Guidelines
From: owain-ga on 25 Jul 2003 14:04 PDT
 
It may be good practice to:

1. only link to the entry page of a website, or if essential to link
to a sub-page, do two links eg: More info about <A
HREF="widgetpage.html">the Widget</A> at <A
HREF="widgetsite.com">Widgets.com</A>
  That makes it clear whose site the content you are linking to
belongs to, and gives the reader a second chance if widgetsite.com
changes the URL of widgetpage.html. Not every web user is
knowledgeable enough about amending URLs if there is a 404 page not
found error.

2. only target the link in the _top or _blank of a frameset, so it is
clear the linked page is not part of your site. That also makes it
clear whose site the content you are linking to belongs to, and will
help prevent allegations of "framing". In the U.K., in the first case
on the subject, the Shetland Times newspaper sued The Shetland News
for its use of unsolicited deep links. The parties settled their case
by agreeing, among other terms, that The Shetland News will be
permitted to link to the Shetland Times site so long as the link is to
the Shetland Times online headline page only and includes specified
attribution, including the masthead logo. More info at:
http://www.viennapat.com/newsletter/vol2iss3/linkingarticle.htm

There is also useful info at:
http://elj.warwick.ac.uk/jilt/wip/98_2atha/athanase.htm
http://www.ku.edu/~cybermom/CLJ/gort.html

Owain

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy