Can you find Parent/Consumer reviews of Perrine's Story and Structure.
 Specifically ones expressing concern with the mature and negative
content of the literary works, especially for high school students

Hello,

Not sure if this will help too much, but here are some brief reviews
of many of Perrine's works, though unfortunately not the one you are
looking for:
http://authors.booksunderreview.com/P/Perrine,_Laurence/

It might be a good place to start your search though...

Good luck!
Harvey