|
|
Subject:
Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
Category: Relationships and Society > Politics Asked by: grandrascal-ga List Price: $5.00 |
Posted:
21 Sep 2003 00:29 PDT
Expires: 21 Oct 2003 00:29 PDT Question ID: 258741 |
Is there any place online (e.g., a URL?) where I can find the complete text (in English translation, of course!) to Nikita S. Khrushchev's United Nations "We will bury you" speech of October 12, 1960? Many thanks... |
|
Subject:
Re: Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
Answered By: juggler-ga on 21 Sep 2003 01:36 PDT Rated: |
Hello. The "we will bury you" line wasn't from a 1960 U.N. speech. It was from a remark that Khrushchev made in Moscow in November 1956. 'November 1956 During a diplomatic reception... Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev told Western diplomats: "About the capitalist states, it doesn't depend on you whether we (Soviet Union) exist. If you don't like us, don't accept our invitations, and don't invite us to come to see you. Whether you like it our not, history is on our side. We will bury you."' source: U.S. Department of Energy Timeline http://www.dpi.anl.gov/dpi2/timelines/1950s.htm#October 1956 Additional sources: 'Nikita Khrushchev told Western diplomats in November 1956, "History is on our side. We will bury you."' source: Foreign Affairs, 1990 http://www.foreignaffairs.org/19900901faessay6035/flora-lewis/bringing-in-the-east.html "He said "we will bury you" at a reception for Wladyslaw Gomulka at the Polish embassy in Moscow on November 18, 1956" source: Nevadalabor.com http://www.nevadalabor.com/barbwire/barb97/barb3-30-97.html --------------- Khrushchev's speech to the U.N. General Assembly actually took place on September 23, 1960. The complete text (in English) is available online: Nikita Krushchev: Address to the UN General Assembly, Sept. 23 1960, hosted by Fordham.edu: http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/1960khrushchev-un1.html Also available at: Cartage.org.lib http://www.cartage.org.lb/en/themes/GeogHist/histories/histdocts/Biblio20/A20/Krushchev/1960khrushchev-un1.html Also available at: Temple.edu http://isc.temple.edu/hist249/course/Documents/nikita_krushchev.htm --------------- Khrushchev did not make a formal speech to the U.N. on October 12, 1960. Rather, responding to a speech delivered by a delegate from the Philippines, Khrushchev took off his shoe off and reportedly banged it. sources: "On Oct. 12, 1960, there it was on the front page of all the newspapers in the United States... The head of the Philippine delegation to the United Nations, Lorenzo Sumulong, was surprised at the Soviet Union's concerns over Western imperialism, since the Soviets had swallowed the whole of Eastern Europe. Khrushchev's reply was angry. He called Sumulong "a jerk, a stooge and a lackey of imperialism," put his shoe on the desk and banged it." source: The Moscow Times, Wednesday, September 13, 2000 "Remembering Grandpa" By Nina Khrushcheva http://www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2000/09/13/040-print.html "In one famous incident at a United Nations conference in 1960, Lorenzo Sumulong, the Filipino delegate, asked Khrushchev how he could protest Western capitalist imperialism while the Soviet Union was at the same time rapidly assimilating Eastern Europe. Khrushchev became enraged and informed Sumulong that he was, "a jerk, a stooge and a lackey of imperialism," then removed one of his shoes and banged it on the table several times for emphasis." source: wikipedia.org http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikita_Khrushchev ----------- search strategy: Khrushchev, "we will bury you", speech Khrushchev, "we will bury you", november 1956 Khrushchev, 1960, speech Khrushchev, 1960, shoe, Sumulong I hope this helps. |
grandrascal-ga
rated this answer:
and gave an additional tip of:
$2.00
> The "we will bury you" line wasn't from a 1960 U.N. speech. > It was from a remark that Khrushchev made in Moscow in > November 1956. Apologies for that misunderstanding! (But then, that's why I needed YOU -- my own efforts yielded me only confusion.) Still wish I could find the WHOLE speech, but this is well-researched. Thank you! :) |
|
Subject:
Re: Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
From: trueparent-ga on 21 Sep 2003 13:20 PDT |
It looks to me, like some "American revisionism" has significantly altered the translation of what Khrushchev said. The way I heard it, he said that the USA will fall from within, because of immorality and other internal strife, and then, the USSR would bury (the already dead and defeated) USA. This meaning seems to be omitted and/or fluffed over, in the translation of Khrushchev's statement that "history is on our side". This "revision" of what Khrushchev said, obviously makes Khrushchev sound dangerous and arrogant, when, from his viewpoint, he was simply stating what he felt would be the normal progression of events, without any aggression assumed or necessary by the USSR. The same sort of "revision" seems to have taken place, concerning the Cuban Missile Crisis. It was made to appear that the USA had bravely faced down and defeated the Russians, when in fact, the USA simply agreed to remove every single USA ICBM from Turkey. This fact made that facedown a huge success for Russia, making one wonder if that was the only reason they ever placed their ICBMs in Cuba to begin with, knowing exactly what they wanted, from the get-go. |
Subject:
Re: Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
From: grandrascal-ga on 21 Sep 2003 14:34 PDT |
"trueparent-ga" commented on 21-Sep-2003: > ...It looks to me, like some "American revisionism" has > significantly altered the translation of what Khrushchev > said... Forgive me if I begin with a very old (and long!) cold-war joke; the relevance will become evident later. The Soviets had announced that they would experiment with Capitalist-style innovations, and had invited journalists to be present. A group of journalists, and their translator, accordingly went on a tour of a Soviet factory. It was explained to them that the factory managers now owned the factory but were expected to stay within stated production goals. "What happens if they fail to meet those goals?", on journalist asked. The translator presented this question to their guide, and then returned the guide's answer: "He says, 'They would be shot.'" The journalists were very troubled by this... and so was the translator! Much later, at the hotel room, as the journalists were preparing to depart back to the United States, their translator came racing down to the lobby bellowing at the very top of his lungs: "Stop! Stop! I have made a terrible mistake! I have been checking my dictionaries -- I did not mean to say that the foremen would be shot! I meant to say that they would be FIRED!" (You may laugh now.) :) The point is, I do not believe their is any "revisionism" going on here. I am told that Russian is very similar to English in many ways, sharing similar syntax and even similar idioms. One such overlap seems to have occured here. According to what I have read, the Russian idiom, "I will bury you", means something on the order of, "When you are dead and ready to be buried in your grave, I will be there to do the burying." Unfortunately, "trueparent-ga" has very conveniently overlooked, is that a similar idiom ("I will bury you") also exists in English: but here it is a much more hostile expression, with a much more literal meaning -- something like, "I will completely bury you in earth, I will overcome you utterly." In summary and in short, I see NO evidence of deliberate revisionism -- just an ordinary linguistic misunderstanding, as can easily happen whenever a "live", or "on-the-spot" translation takes place. ---End--- |
Subject:
Re: Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
From: juggler-ga on 21 Sep 2003 14:38 PDT |
grandrascal: Thank you for the tip. -juggler |
Subject:
Re: Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
From: grandrascal-ga on 21 Sep 2003 22:52 PDT |
> grandrascal: > Thank you for the tip. > -juggler Yer Welkum. :) ---End--- |
Subject:
Re: Complete (English) text of "We Will Bury You" speech by Khrushchev?
From: trueparent-ga on 12 Oct 2003 09:33 PDT |
Wow! Your knowledge of these idioms is impressive, grandrascal-ga, and I stand corrected, but not incorrect. Are you claiming, that there is not, and never was even one person in the media, who understands these idioms as well as you do, grandrascal-ga? Admittedly, initial translations are always subject to a lot of possible mistakes, but those with the "transcripts" have the opportunity to clear these mistakes up. The fact that no one ever did so, proves to me, at least, that intentional "revisionism"/"disinformation" was involved here, as it was in the Cuban Missile Crisis. Still, you have given me a deep and enjoyable education, in the unique nature of this particular case of translation, and I would like to return the favor. Perhaps there really never WAS anyone with your deep understanding of these idioms. But I do doubt it. Our "government", (i.e. the CIA, et al), has long hidden so much truth from the American people, as per: <http://www.ratical.org/ratville/JFK/ST/STpreface97.html> and the complete works of Fletcher Prouty, available at: <http://www.prouty.org> Of course, we created the "monster" called the CIA, because we had to, to fight the very real and ungodly monster of communism. However, many corrupt CIA individuals, drunk on power, subverted the original purpose of the CIA, et al, abusing the power that the CIA needed, to effectively fight communism. This included a whole lot of "disinformation", and "revisionism". Such corruption caused the Vietnam War, as Prouty reveals in all its ugly, deadly reality. Now, using "Terrorism" as its justification for power, the American government is once again gearing up to destroy the "American Dream". If something really new does not happen, such as the Second Advent of Christ, (found at: <familyfed.org> there is no way out of this predicament, for the American people. Love To All, trueparent-GA |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |