Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: reactors ( Answered,   0 Comments )
Question  
Subject: reactors
Category: Science
Asked by: authority-ga
List Price: $20.00
Posted: 28 Oct 2003 15:36 PST
Expires: 27 Nov 2003 15:36 PST
Question ID: 270597
discuss the various types of reactors with respect to advantages and
disadvantages, characteristics, classification and application

Request for Question Clarification by omniscientbeing-ga on 28 Oct 2003 17:04 PST
Are you referring to nuclear reactors?

omniscientbeing-ga
Google Answers Researcher
Answer  
Subject: Re: reactors
Answered By: techtor-ga on 29 Oct 2003 02:57 PST
 
Greetings Authority,
I post this answer on the assumption that you mean nuclear reactors. I
think these are the three basic types:
Boiling Water reactor (light water)
Pressurized Water Reactor (light water)
Heavy Water Reactor (CANDU)

These types are identified I think by the cooling technology or
variations in design:
Gas-cooled graphite moderated reactor
Water-cooled graphite moderated reactor
Fast breeder reactor

I will list websites where you can find the answers to your question.
The third website listed below will give the advantages/disadvantages.

Sources:
Types of Nuclear Reactors
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/nucene/reactor.html
- Contains structural drawings of three types of reactors

IEER Reports: NPD: Types of Nuclear Reactors
http://www.ieer.org/reports/npd-tbl.html
- Good basic explanation on the types of reactors in table form. Also
gives the purposes of each.

Coolants for Nuclear Reactors
http://www.nuc.berkeley.edu/thyd/ne161/rahmed/coolants.html
- This actually also gives the advantages and disadvantages of the
types of reactors in a comprehensive form.

I will quote a good part of the page here:
ADVANTAGES OF PRESSURIZED WATER REACTOR:
    * Water technology well known.
    * Water is cheap.
    * Water is very effective moderator of neutron energy
    * core is compact.
    * Water has high heat capacity.
    * Negative temperature coefficient.
    * Ordinary leakage can be tolerated.
    * Fission products are contained, not circulated.
    * Radioactivity of coolant is short-lived if kept pure.
    * Conversion ratio may be high.
    * Superheating steam in separately fired superheater is possible.
    * Appreciable fast fission effect attainable.

DISADVANTAGES OF PRESSURIZED WATER REACTOR:
    * Water must be highly pressurized to achieve even reasonably high
temperature without boiling.
    * Fuel element fabrication expensive.
    * The temperature is limited in metallic fuel elements.
    * Fission product activity in the core builds up to high a level.
    * Pure hot water is highly corrosive, requires special materials
for the primary loop.
    * Fuel must be at least slightly enriched.
    * Heat exchanger and control rods required.
    * Large excess reactivity at operating temperature.
    * Heat transfer only moderately efficient.
    * Fuel reprocessing a difficult task.
    * Rector must be shut down to unload and reload core.
    * Water would flash to steam in case of rupture of primary loop.
    * Water reacts with uranium, thorium, and structural metals under
certain conditions.
    * Low thermal heads make heat exchanger, pumps and pipins large.
    * Hot-channel factors are significant.

ADVANTAGES OF BOILING WATER REACTOR:
    * Some intermediate heat exchange equipment eliminated.
    * Pressure is lower for given steam output conditions than in
pressurized water reactor.
    * Metal surface temperatures are lower for given steam output
conditions than in pressurized water reactor.
    * Power excursion quickly damped by formation of steam.
    * Overall thermal efficiency quite high.
    * Water is cheap.
    * Core is compact if void coefficient is low.
    * Negative temperature coefficient.
    * Ordinary leakage can be tolerated.
    * Fission products are contained, not circulated.
    * Radioactivity of coolant is short-lived if kept pure.
    * Conversion ratio may be high.
    * Heat may be taken from circulating water increasing power
output.

DISADVANTAGES OF BOILING WATER REACTOR:
    * Boiling limits power density.
    * Radioactivity builds up in turbine.
    * Changes in load on turbine reflected back to reactor as pressure
changes.
    * Separately fired superheater cannot conveniently be employed.
    * System must be designed to overcome tendency to react negatively
to load increases.
    * Fuel must be at least slightly enriched.
    * Fuel handling necessitates complex equipments.
    * Reactor must be shut down to unload and reload core.
    * Water flashes to steam in case of rupture of primary system.
    * Condenser leak may cause serious trouble.

ADVANTAGES OF HEAVY WATER REACTOR:
    * Any fuel including natural uranium can be used.
    * Heavy water is excellent moderator.
    * Heavy water has high heat capacity.
    * Specific power high.
    * Negative temperature coefficients.
    * Fission product are contained, not circulated.
    * Radioactivity of coolant is short lived if kept pure.

DISADVANTAGES OF HEAVY WATER REACTOR:
    * Heavy water expensive.
    * Special precautions must be taken to make primary loop leak
proof and to prevent loss of heavy water during refueling operations.
    * Primary loop must be highly pressurized to achieve even high
temperatures without boiling.
    * Pure hot heavy water is highly corrosive.
    * Fuel suffers radiation damage.
    * Heat exchanges and control rod required.
    * Heat transfer only moderately efficient.
    * Fuel reprocessing a difficult task.
    * Reactors must be shut down to unload and reload core.
    * Heavy water would flush to steam in case of rupture of primary
loop.
    * Heavy water reacts with uranium, thorium and structural metals.
    * Low thermal heads make heat exchangers, pumps, and piping large.
    * Hot channel factors are significant.

Table of Advantages of Various Reactor types
http://www.nucleartourist.com/type/benefits.htm
- Also leads to the previously mentioned website.

Types of Nuclear Reactors -VRM(Virtual Radiation Museum)
http://www.medphysics.wisc.edu/~vrm/nuclearenergy/reactors.htm
- Just a list.

NRC: Unit 3: Nuclear Reactors/Energy Generation
http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/teachers/unit3.html
- Article that explains some types of nuclear reactors for a student.

Chemcases.com - Nuclear Reactors by Dr. Frank Settle
http://chemcases.com/2003version/nuclear/nc-10.htm
- Explains some problems and mechanics of reactors. Also contains an
illustration.

Nuclear Reactor Types
http://www.nuce.boun.edu.tr/links/nucreac.html
- A list of all the knows types of reactors, with variations because
of new technologies mentioned, but the links to each type are dead.

Nuclear Energy File
http://www.energy.org.uk/EFNuclr.htm
- Another detailed article about nuclear power generation.

About.com page about the Types of Nuclear Reactors
http://power.about.com/cs/reactordesign/
- Leads you to various sites about nuclear reactors. I good place to
start fishing for more detailed information.

Nuclear - Advancing? or Destructive?
http://www.alumni.ca/~chiuw3w/tech.html
- Good explanation on the types of reactors based on Generation 1, 2,
etc..


Google search terms used:
types nuclear reactors
types nuclear reactors advantages
kinds nuclear reactors

I hope this has been a most helpful answer. If you need anything else,
or have a problem with the answer, do please post a Request for
Clarification and I shall respond as soon as I can. Thank you.

Request for Answer Clarification by authority-ga on 31 Oct 2003 04:05 PST
i do not mean nuclear reactors, i mean chemical reactors like batch
reactor, fluidized reactor, continous state tank reactors (CSTR) ETC.

Clarification of Answer by techtor-ga on 31 Oct 2003 08:25 PST
Hello Authority,
I'm sorry to have jumped the gun on your question. Give me some time
to find the right answer. In case I am unable to do so, I can have the
answer withdrawn.

Clarification of Answer by techtor-ga on 31 Oct 2003 09:46 PST
Hello again Authority,
It appears I don't need as much time as I initially thought. This time
I have found other references that may contain what you need. I will
list them below:

Multi-Phase And Catalytic Chemical Reactors Design Simulation Tool
http://www.epa.gov/ORD/NRMRL/std/mtb/Hopper.ppt 
- Powerpoint presentation that describes the different kinds of
chemical reactors and their advantages and disadvantages. Nine types
of reactors are described here. This document may have a good deal of
what you need.

Types of Gasifiers
http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/T0512E/T0512e0a.htm
- Gives explanations on types of gasifiers.

Air Pollution Control Technology Fact sheet - Catalytic Incinerator
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/catc/dir1/fcataly.pdf 
- Lists advantages and disadvantages of Catalytic Incinerators (also
called reactors)

Post-Combustion NOx Control Technologies: Selective Catalytic
Reduction Systems
http://www.siu.edu/~coalctr/postcomb.htm

Put More Punch into Catalytic Reactors (PDF article)
http://www.comsol.com/shared/downloads/articles/CEPMarch03.pdf

The Cocurrent Downflow Contactor Reactor (CDCR)
http://web.bham.ac.uk/cen3sxs7/rp1.html
- Gives advantages, though no disadvantages

Chemical Reactor Design and Optimization by Michael J. Rogers
http://fenske.che.psu.edu/Faculty/Fichthorn/che497C/597C_present/Rogers.pdf
- This is a PDF document containing formulas for reactor optimization.

Improved Performance of Technical Fluidized Bed Reactors Through the
Use of the Splash-Zone
http://dynamik.fb10.tu-berlin.de/~external/kilian/michael3-e.html
- Specific article about a type of reactor.

Multi-phase Catalysis in the Synthesis of Bulk & Intermediate
Chemicals - Opportunities for monolithic catalysts
http://www.dct.tudelft.nl/monoliet/publications/AbstNICE.PDF


Google search terms used:
fluidized reactor types advantages
catalytic reactor types advantages

I hope that even if I had jumped the gun the first time, this
information I give you now is correct. If you have any other problem
or concern, please post another request for clarification. Thank you.
Comments  
There are no comments at this time.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy