Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: history of topographic map drawing from 1984 to 2004 ( Answered,   2 Comments )
Question  
Subject: history of topographic map drawing from 1984 to 2004
Category: Reference, Education and News > Homework Help
Asked by: mamamary-ga
List Price: $25.00
Posted: 11 Jan 2004 12:24 PST
Expires: 10 Feb 2004 12:24 PST
Question ID: 295343
How were topograhic maps drawn 20 years ago and how are they drawn
today?  I know what topographical maps are but I need to know for a
project what the difference in them was 20 years ago and how are they
drawn differently now.  Answer should aim for understanding level of
10-13 years of age.  Any general history of topographic map drawing. 
My son needs to do a report on topographic maps and he has lots of
info and understands them pretty well but one part of the project asks
this  question and we both have no idea what is new in the last twenty
years.  I thought it might have to do with computers but how have they
influenced how "topographic maps were drawn 20 years ago"--that is the
question:  "find out how topographic maps were drawn 20 years ago and
how they are drawn today".
could be useful as well.

Clarification of Question by mamamary-ga on 11 Jan 2004 17:09 PST
My soon is in the fifth grade and they are studying maps in science. 
For an end of the quarter project, he must give a paper and talk in
front of the class on a topic chosen from a list the teacher handed
out.  He chose one on topographic maps but one of the main questions
was the one I quoted.  "How were topographic maps drawn 20 years ago
and how are they drawn today"?  We can't find the answer to this. 
Even when we look at two maps, we can't find the differences.  Exactly
20 years ago ofcourse would be 1984 but we are not sure if she means
exactly 20 years ago to the day or about 20 years ago.  It would also
be helpful if you could find us anything at all on the history of
topographic maps as most history of maps is about other kinds of maps.
 We need this answer pretty quickly...its sunday now and we must have
it by Tuesday.

Request for Question Clarification by pafalafa-ga on 11 Jan 2004 18:09 PST
I don't know your son's teacher, of course, but I can't imagine any
teacher expecting to know what technologies were in use EXACTLY 20
years ago -- a general overview of recent changes in mapmaking should
do.

For that, you might want to start at the USGS description of how they
make topo maps:

http://mac.usgs.gov/mac/isb/pubs/booklets/topo/topo.html#toc

You might also want to take a look at this education page:

http://rockyweb.cr.usgs.gov/public/outreach/classroomtours.html

and consider having your son give a call to the contact person at the
top of the page, and ask him the very question you're trying to
answer.

Best of luck.

pafalafa-ga

Request for Question Clarification by maniac-ga on 11 Jan 2004 19:50 PST
Hello Mamamary,

It appears there are two major differences in the production of
topographic maps, but I am unsure how to describe it for a 10-13 year
old child. The differences appear to be:

 - A change in scale and delivery. According to
      http://topomaps.usgs.gov/revision.html
the National Mapping Program produced 1:24,000 scale, 7.5 minute
topographic quadrangles. You can still purhcase these "traditional"
maps, but the current information is delivered as part of the
"National Map" described at
      http://nationalmap.usgs.gov/nmreports.html
which is an on line service allowing the user to view the information
interactively on line.

 - A change in technology used 'behind the scenes" to produce the
maps. This is described in part at the first reference where it
describes the Raster Image Warping for Geometric Correction of
Cartographic Bases. Basically, older maps had a number of inaccuracies
and were often manipulated on the computer as vectors. The revision
performed was to digitize the old maps and "warp" (distort the digital
image) to fit the correct points. The revised maps are delivered as
part of the National Map system described above or as digital raster
files.

If this type of information appears to meet your needs, I can go
through the references in more detail and see if I can extract
information that might be understandable to your child. Also, if you
have an urgent time limit - please let us know. I may be unable to
answer your question fully for a few days and would prefer another
researcher to answer it if necessary.

  --Maniac
Answer  
Subject: Re: history of topographic map drawing from 1984 to 2004
Answered By: eiffel-ga on 12 Jan 2004 07:18 PST
 
Hi mamamary,

When your son's teacher asks "How were topographic maps drawn 20 years
ago and how are they drawn today", I don't believe the teacher is
referring to the appearance of the finished map. Instead, the teacher
is likely to be referring to a profound change in the way that the
master copy of the map is produced by the mapmaker.

Let's first look at how topographic maps were made twenty years ago.

First, the area is surveyed to gather the information that will make
up the map. Aerial photographs are taken of the area to be mapped.
Each part of the land is photographed at least twice, from different
points on the flight path. Adjoining pairs of aerial photographs can
be placed into a stereoscopic viewer which produces a 3-dimensional
effect that enables the mapmaker to see the height of the ground at
each point.

Aerial photography for mapmaking was itself a revolutionary change,
but it was first introduced in the 1930s and was solidly established
twenty years ago.

The mapmaker will also need survey data gathered from the ground.
Selected points that fall within the map area are visited, and angles
are carefully measured from those points to other points whose height
and position are accurately known. From these measurements,
co-ordinates can be calculated that provide a precise framework onto
which the aerial photography can be projected.

Next, the 1984 mapmaker creates the master copy of the map from which
all others will be reproduced. The stereo aerial photos are mounted in
a projector, adjusted so that the ground-survey points are projected
onto the right position on the map manuscript. The mapmaker then
traces the position of the map features, creating the master map.

As the mapmaker looks through the 3-D glasses, the projection can be
adjusted to identify land that is at a certain altitude. The mapmaker
then traces these points as a contour line, before adjusting the
projection to trace the next contour line, and so on.

Next, the basic map data is duplicated onto layers of film - one for
each color in the final printed map. Again, the aerial photographs are
projected. For each piece of film, the mapmaker traces the location of
features that are to be printed in that color. For example, areas of
forest will be marked onto the film that will be printed in green;
roads onto the film for the black print; rivers onto the film for the
blue print, and so on. Text and gridlines are also applied to the film
for the relevant color.

Printing plates are then made from the individual films, and a
multi-colour map is produced by printing each of the colors in turn
onto a sheet of paper.

Now we fast-forward to 2004. Aerial photography is still used, as are
ground surveys although the position of ground features is now
obtained from satellite measurements rather than by measuring angles
to visible features.

The biggest difference, though, is that instead of scratching map
details onto sheets of film, an operator examines the aerial photos
and enters the information into a computer file. For example, a river
would be recorded as a list of co-ordinates joining all the points
along which the river flows, a forest would be recorded as a list of
co-ordinates joining all the points along its boundary, and so on.

When it is time to make the map, a computer program reads the data and
generates a file that can be used on a phototypesetting machine to
produce the printing masters. Not all of the data is used for every
map. For example, one map may exclude minor features because of its
small scale, whilst a larger-scale map may include more features. Maps
produced for use in mining might include geological information that
would be undesirable on a road map.

Once the survey data is held on a computer file, the software can
select and assemble whatever is required for the map that has been
specified. The software can even decide where to position names and
other text to provide optimum readability in the finished product.

The task of manually drawing the master copy of the map has been
eliminated. If an error is discovered, it is straightforward to
correct the computer data and run off another print master, whereas 20
years ago it would have been necessary to carefully scratch out the
old data and paste the new data onto the film, or even to redraw the
map entirely for major changes.

Mapmaking is a fascinating subject, and there is much more that can be
said, but I'm not sure how much detail you need.

There is an excellent webpage from the USGS that provides more
information about the old and new methods of mapmaking, and should be
quite readable for a fifth-grade child:

"Topographic Mapping"
http://erg.usgs.gov/isb/pubs/booklets/topo/topo.html

For a broad overview of maps and mapmaking, there is a good article
from the online Encarta encyclopedia:

MSN Encarta - MAP
http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761577953_2/Map.html

I trust this provides the information you require, but if you need any
further specific information feel free to request clarification.


Google search strategy:

mapmaking traditional topographic
://www.google.com/search?q=mapmaking+traditional+topographic


Regards,
eiffel-ga

Request for Answer Clarification by mamamary-ga on 12 Jan 2004 11:00 PST
I am not sure who I am writing to--how many researchers anwer the
question?  How many get paid  ....is the $25. dollars split among
everyone?  I only had budgeted $25. for the answer, I hope I haven't
mistakenly agreed to pay for all the answers.  The answer by eiffel-ga
is good and seems complete but is awfully technical and complex even
for me...let alone my son.  But I do not blame google researchers...I
think the topics are a little too complex for fifth grade and my son!!
 We will struggle through but next writer suggests breaking down the
info for a fifth grader....that would be GREAT and we have to have
that by Tuesday night.  Thanks.

Clarification of Answer by eiffel-ga on 12 Jan 2004 13:07 PST
Hi mamamary,

Firstly, please be reassured that you will only be charged one fee (of
$25 plus the 50-cent listing charge) which is for the main answer. Any
material that researchers or the general public post to the "Comments"
section is not charged for.

Secondly, I do recommend that you and your son read the USGS page on
Topographic Mapping that I listed in the main answer. Even if some of
the text on that page is too complex, you may still gain some benefit
from the general overview that it offers.

In addition, I am rewriting my answer in a simpler form, in the hope
that this will make it more useful to you and your son. Good luck with
the project, and if you have any more questions please feel free to
request further clarification.

TOPOGRAPHIC MAPS - 20 YEARS AGO

A plane flies over the area to be mapped, taking a series of photos.
These photos can be loaded into a 3-D viewer to show the height of the
land at each point.

Also, some points on the ground are visited, and a surveyor measures
the angle and distance from those points to other points whose
location is known, such as distant hills. These points provide the
"framework" to which the aerial photos can be matched.

To make the "master copy" of the map, the mapmaker looks through the
3-D viewer and traces lines that join every point of the land that is
at the same height - these become the contour lines on the finished
map.

The mapmaker will then trace additional master sheets, one for each
other color on the finished map. The "blue" sheet would include the
rivers, and you can imagine a mapmaker tracing the paths of rivers
from the aerial photo onto this sheet. The mapmaker would draw areas
of forest onto the "green" sheet, and would add lettering and grid
lines onto the "black" sheet.

From these master sheets a printer will print each color in turn onto
a sheet of paper, which becomes the finished map.

HOW TOPOGRAPHIC MAPS ARE MADE TODAY

Aerial photography is still used, and a surveyor still visits selected
points on the ground. But it is no longer necessary to measure angles
to distant hills. Instead, a radio signal from an orbiting satellite
can tell the surveyor his exact location.

There's no longer any need to draw the map details onto the master
maps. In fact, there's no traditional "drawing" any more.

The mapmaker uses a device that works like a computer mouse with a
pointer attached. The mapmaker simply traces out the paths of rivers,
forests and so on, and the computer stores this information in a data
file.

From this data file, the computer can assemble and print out a map at
any time. What's more, the same data can be used to produce different
kinds of map, such as maps at different scales or maps that include or
exclude certain kinds of information. For example, a road map may not
need to include the height contours.

SUMMARY

20 years ago, the mapmaker had to carefully draw the master copy of
each map. Nowadays, the mapmaker traces the information into the
computer, and the computer can print the map on demand.


Regards,
eiffel-ga
Comments  
Subject: Re: history of topographic map drawing from 1984 to 2004
From: aht-ga on 11 Jan 2004 21:42 PST
 
mamamary-ga:

Here's something that your son may want to mention in his report. The
Global Positioning System did not become fully operational until the
late 1980's. After the system became fully operational, maps of all
types (but especially topo maps) became a lot more accurate, as GPS
could be used to verify and correct for errors in surveying
activities. Previous technologies depended on several relationships
between air pressure, temperature, geometry and time in order to
calculate elevation. After GPS became a reality, elevations could be
calculated to a much higher degree of accuracy. Naturally, this
accuracy was only available to the military at first, but eventually
it made its way into maps available for the public after the
intentional degradation of the GPS system was removed by the
Department of Defense in 2000.

Regards,

aht-ga
Google Answers Researcher
Subject: Re: history of topographic map drawing from 1984 to 2004
From: mamamary-ga on 12 Jan 2004 11:02 PST
 
This is great and I do not think we need more info but if anyone can
rephrase it smore simply for both of us...it is so technical (I
realize the whole field is....not sure why they are undertaking this
in the fifth grade but nevertheless
my son and I need help to simplify some o f this if anyone can.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy