Hello chrisdelz,
The answer to your question:
?Here is what I would like from an answer: To my satisfaction, based
on above criteria: Can I use the cannon SD10 which is a 4 mega pixel
camera with no optical zoom? (digital only)
is ?NO?
Here?s why:
When you were a kid, did you ever write on an un-inflated balloon
with a ball point pen? If you did, let?s suppose you made the letter
?O?. The ?O? is made of a measurable amount of ink on the balloon. If
you were then to inflate the balloon, the ?O? would be larger, but it
would not be as sharp as the original ?O?. You have enlarged the
letter, but not increased the amount of ink.
Simply put. this is what happens when you use digital zoom. With
digital zoom, your camera enlarges the pixels in the image, resulting
in a loss of resolution, similar to the ?O? on the balloon. It?s true
that some software and some cameras can interpolate extra pixels, in
an effort to improve the image. But interpolated images lose detail,
and don?t compare to images using optical zoom.
Optical zoom, on the other hand has more pixels to begin with. Optical
zoom allows an image to be enlarged to 8x10, 11x14 and larger,
depending on the camera?s megapixel size.
Digital Camera Buying Guide does a good job of clarifying my ?balloon? explanation:
http://www.digital-camera-buying-guide.com/digital_camera_pixels_resolution.php
Photoxels says ?For our purpose, digital zoom is not really zoom, in
the strictest definition of the term. What digital zoom does is
enlarge a portion of the image, thus 'simulating' optical zoom. In
other words, the camera crops a portion of the image and then enlarges
it back to size. In so doing, you lose image quality. If you've been
regularly using digital zoom and wondered why your pictures did not
look that great, now you know.? And ?Optical vs. digital zoom? There
is no contest. Only optical zoom matters when selecting a digital
camera.?
http://www.photoxels.com/article_zoom.html
This About site echoes my feeling to a tee: ?If your digital camera
offers a digital zoom option, go get your camera right now and turn
this option off! Don't use it... ever!?
http://graphicssoft.about.com/cs/digitalimaging/f/digitalzoom.htm
The Digital Camera Buying Guide concurs:?Optical zoom is what you
should be looking at as digital zoom is basically just a marketing
trick.?
http://www.digital-camera-buying-guide.com/best_digital_cameras.php
A few years ago, I made what I considered a large investment ($750, a
bargain price from an obscure site I found) to buy an Epson 850Z Photo
PC camera. It has only 2.1 megapixels, and 3x optical zoom. I have
never seen photos from any digital camera that equals the resolution
and clarity of this camera. Sadly Epson no longer makes these well-
designed and excellent quality cameras. I use mine several times a
week, and almost feel it is an appendage of mine! What makes this
camera so good are the lenses! Low end cameras may have lots of
megapixels and zoom, but if the lens of poor quality, you will get
poor quality prints.
This site pertains to Video cameras, but it emphasizes my opinion of
digital zoom. Scroll down the page to the paragraph below the hot pink
text, just above the middle of the page. (Internet Video magazine)
http://www.internetvideomag.com/articles2002/zoomwars.htm
Camera Recommendations:
Here are three cameras with over 3 megapixels and good optical zoom
lenses. I would prefer one of the first two. Even though the Olympus
has 3.2 megapixels, it has a great lens. The HP 850 has a nice
?chunky? feel, which is important to some. (My Epson is similar in
shape and size, and it fits nicely in your hand, allowing a steady
grasp for less ?shake? in the picture). Sony cameras use a proprietary
memory stick- works fine, but disallows memory sharing between
cameras. If you have more than one camera, having a compact flash size
that all share is very handy! For this reason, I have left Sony?s out
for this question.
Olympus C-730 Ultra Zoom
3.2 megapixels, 10x Optical zoom, just slightly more expensive than
the Canon you asked about. This Olympus can produce photos even larger
than 8X10. Plus, Olympus is known for its quality lenses (They also
make microscopes!) This is the smallest of this quality camera on the
market, per this web site:
http://www.steves-digicams.com/2002_reviews/c730uz.html
More information:
http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/olympus/c730uz-review/
HP 850 4.1 megapixels, 8x optical zoom, produces photos as large as
20x30. Weighs 0.85 pounds. $300-$500
http://www.steves-digicams.com/2002_reviews/hp850.html
More specifications:
http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/us/en/ho/WF06b/15179-64213-64342-12117-f30-75970-75972-75973.html
Nikon Coolpix 4300
4.0 megapixels, 3x optical zoom, Hexanon zoom lens. Around $400
http://www.steves-digicams.com/2002_reviews/nikon4300.html
More information:
http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/CP4300/C43A.HTM
Steve?s Digicam is a great digital camera review source.
4 megapixel cameras
http://www.steves-digicams.com/cameras_dig4.html
3 megapixel cameras
http://www.steves-digicams.com/cameras_dig3.html
Sample Photos from various cameras:
http://www.steves-digicams.com/closeups.html
A good ?pixel/resolution chart:
http://www.digital-camera-buying-guide.com/digital_camera_pixels_resolution.php
A bit about resolution:
http://graphicssoft.about.com/cs/digitalimaging/qt/camerares.htm
A series of pictures taken with digital zoom:
http://www.cplab.com/digital_zoom_sample.htm
A comparison of digital vs. optical zoom in pictures:
http://catcode.com/comments/kbpics.html
To summarize, chrisdelz,
A: I travel a lot, and want the smallest camera possible. (e.g Canon
Powershot SD10)
The Olympus C-730 is the smallest of the good quality cameras I found,
weighing only 11.1 ounces. The Canon Powershot SD10 IS smaller, at 3.5
ounces however. For quality, I would opt for the extra 7.6 ounces.
B: 95% of the time, the only thing I do is post pictures on my web
site. While I only need low resolution 800 x 600/ 1024 x 768 I want
excellent quality at these resolutions. I rarely print, but if I
need to I would like decent quality.
You will NOT get excellent photo prints with the Canon Powershot, nor
any camera at low resolution. What is good enough for the web, is
considered very poor for printing. 72DPI is all that is needed for web
publishing. You can use the lower resolution setting for your web
pictures, on any of the recommended cameras above. You can also do
what I do, and what I recommend: I use the highest resolution camera
setting for all my pictures. Using photo-editing software such as
Paint Shop Pro and/or JASC Photo Album, the image can easily be
optimized for the web.
By doing this, you preserve the original high resolution image for
possible printing later. Make a copy to optimize for the web, and you
have the best of both worlds. Software like JASC Photo Album will
allow batch photo optimization, saving a great deal of time. Photo
Album retails for about $28 for the downloadable version , and Paint
Shop Pro sells for under $80 for the download version. Both can be
downloaded for a free 30 day trial version at www.jasc.com .
C: I do zoom a lot, nothing telephoto. I want to get peoples faces
better, zoom on a 2nd story of a building, etc. It is very important
to me to be able to do my normal zooming without noticeable
degradation in quality of picture.
Using an optical zoom, you will be able to zoom as much as the camera
you chose allows, with NO degredation of the image. Using digital zoom
will cause visible degredation of the image. These cameras also have
"Macro" modes which allow good closeup shots.
Again compact size, and quality at low to average resolutions w/zoom
is what I am interested in.
The above cameras are compact in size, have plenty of optical zoom
power and will produce quality prints. Using the lower resolution
setting for web photos, and the highest settings for photo printing is
one way to solve your dilemma. The second way is using the software I
described above.
I hope this information makes your decision easier! If any part of my
answer is unclear, please request an Answer Clarification, before
rating. This will allow me to assist you further, if possible.
Regards,
crabcakes-ga
Search Terms
optical zoom vs. digital zoom
Steve's digicam reviews
digital zoom photo examples |
