Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Debt Consolidation Options ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   3 Comments )
Question  
Subject: Debt Consolidation Options
Category: Business and Money
Asked by: march5th00-ga
List Price: $25.00
Posted: 03 Feb 2004 09:05 PST
Expires: 04 Mar 2004 09:05 PST
Question ID: 303153
Hello to all the talented researchers at Google answers, and thank you
for your interst!
My question today is aimed at getting me to a state of financial
freedom!  Just think you could be the one that rescues another from a
miserable state of existence.
Here's the background of my question
I'm a 24 year old Child Care Worker in Cleveland Ohio through a social
service agency
and earn about 25k.  I've graduated from a College with a bachelors
degree in Psychology and truly hope to return to school and get my
Masters and eventually my Doctorate in Clinical Psychology. 
Unfortunately my College degree has left me with a substantial amount
of debt and halted further education.

Currently I owe 
-$20,000 in School Loans (Stafford Subsidized)(this is not an issue) and

-$15,000 in Credit card debt (from 3 credit card sources - A Citibank
Card, A Unionplus card (www.upcard.com) and an A T and T Universal
Card (The first 2 providing the most significant source of debt))

I'm at the point now where I'm not making any headway into the
Principal of these balances because I can only afford to pay the
minimum monthly payments, which goes completely to finance charges.
Otherwise I DO make all of my payments on Time, my credit standing is
good (except for my credit to income ratio which stops me from being
able to consolidate all of these onto one credit card with a low APR)

My question is one of financial options.  How can I consolidate these 3
credit cards into one manageable monthly payment that works on
eliminating my debt while maintaining a "decent" credit rating (if
possible consolidating with the Stafford loans - but i doubt this is
possible).  If the best answer is just to go through a consolidation
service, please give examples of reputable services that charge
minimum to no fees.  Please keep in mind that I do not own my own home
and am still making payments on an automobile through my fathers
credit union ($4000)

I have seen and understand the disclaimer "Important Disclaimer:
Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general
information, and are not intended to substitute for informed
professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal,
investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not
endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product,
manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or
any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully
the Google Answers Terms of Service. "

I'm not necessarily asking for professional advice as much as an
informed researchers opinion as to the options available.



Thanks in advance for your help, good luck!
march5th00
Dan
Answer  
Subject: Re: Debt Consolidation Options
Answered By: darrel-ga on 27 Feb 2004 14:52 PST
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Hello March--

I have a great deal of experience assisting people with this kind of
situation and have some options for you that can work for you.

First, I recommend that you become incredibly serious about reducing
your debt. If you don't make it a priority, it can get out of hand
quickly. This is especially important if you have significant debt, as
it appears you do.

The good news, as you mentioned, is that you have favorable credit. It
is important that we keep your credit rating as high as possible, so
you apply for credit down the road.

Next, stop making purchases on credit cards. As long as you're serious
about getting out of debt, tear up those credit cards and start
spending only with cash you have in hand. You may always return to
credit card use in a year or so when you have paid off your debt and
when your financial situation is more stable.

Whatever you do, do not pay money to someone who says they'll help fix
your credit. Advance-fee loans are illegal in your state. There are
many companies - and even "non-profit organizations" that say they can
fix your credit and will do so by consolidating your payments. These
companies take your first payment to them as their fee. So many
consumers complain about this process, as these companies are a dime a
dozen. The main complaint I hear is that these companies take your
money but they don't pay off your debt at all. They only find out this
fact when three or four months after they sign up with them, their
creditors are calling wanting their money. Then, typically, it's only
a matter of time before these companies go out of business.

There is one reputable non-profit group that I can recommend in your
area. The Consumer Credit Counseling Service of Northeast Ohio in
Cleveland and Beachwood.

Consumer Credit Counseling Service
7519 Mentor Ave
Cleveland, OH 44102 Phone:  (216) 781-8624  

Consumer Credit Counseling Services
21403 Chagrin Blvd
Beachwood, OH 44122-5322 Phone:  (216) 295-9152  

You may visit their website online. The link is http://www.cccservices.com
 
This is the one debt consolidation organization I can trust and have
recommended to many people. That's because this organization isn't one
of those groups that popped up within the past 10 years as part of the
latest debt-consolidation craze. This organization has been around for
about 50 years. I have never heard a complaint about them.

How it works is this: You go in, they analyze your debt. Because you
have student loans and credit card debt, I think they can drastically
help you. What they'll do is help you look realistically at your debt.
You'll create a plan to get out of debt with them, and they don't
charge you. They'll make agreements with each of your creditors to
lower the interest rates that you pay (some as low as 0%), as long as
you agree to pay off the debt. Everybody wins: your creditors get
their money (which not everybody pays off their debts- instead they
head toward bankruptcy), and you get lower interest rates to pay your
debt.

You will then make payments to the Consumer Credit Counseling Service
every week or every-other-week instead of paying your creditors
individually. They will then in turn pay your creditors. But the catch
is that you need to stay on track with your payments: Don't be late!
Or the whole deal can be ruined! Again, you have to be serious about
getting out of debt for this to work.

Two other realistic options for you without signing with the CCCS:

1) Seek a debt consolidation loan. This is a quick and easy way to put
all your debts: car, student loan, credit card, etc., into one place,
one bill, that you pay on each month. Yes, this will be a sizable
loan. But you likely can get a good interest rate. If you have good
enough credit, you may be able to obtain a line-of-credit account like
this without equity (i.e. a piece of property, which you indicated you
don't have anyway). You should contact some of the banks in your area
to discuss this possibility.

If you don't qualify for a line of credit without equity, you may wish
to ask your parents, grandparents, any siblings, or friends to co-sign
such a loan for you against property they own. Since you have good
credit, this likely wouldn't be a problem. Again, obtaining a debt
consolidation loan can give you a great interest rate (much lower than
your credit cards) and help you make a single, lower monthly payment
to pay off your debt.

2) Make cuts in your life. If paying off your debt is truly a priority
of yours, you will find a way to make it happen. Find a less expensive
place to live, sell your car and buy a less expensive car, lower your
entertainment and other areas in your budget.

3) Contact each of your creditors individually. Have a heart-to-heart
with them. Tell the you seriously want to pay off what you owe them
and ask if they could settle a lower amount than you owe and set up a
payment plan to have those amounts divvied up to be taken directly out
of your checking account each month. For example. Let's say you have a
credit card on which you owe $2,000. If you call that credit card
company and tell them you want to talk about reaching a settlement
agreement with them, they'll likely close your account, and may agree
to let you pay an amount as low as 60 or 70 % of what you owe. So on
that $2,000 credit card balance, you may be able to talk them into a
settlement of only $1,200. Then from this amount, you may be able to
break this up into 10 monthly payments of $120 each. So each month for
the next 10 months, they'd deduct $120 from your checking account
until the settlement amount is paid off. Just be sure none of the
payments bounce! If you don't have enough money in your account to
make these payments, your settlement may be voided completely. Also,
understand that when you make a settlement, the fact that you made a
settlement with the company will appear on your credit report for at
least 12 months.

I also conducted some research to find more information for you. You
may view the results of my search online. The link is
://www.google.com/search?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=%22how+to%22+%22eliminate+debt%22&spell=1

http://www.stresstips.com/credit_card_debt/how_to_eliminate_credit_card_debt.htm

http://www.simplejoe.com/debteraser/index2.htm

http://www.planetloan.com/library/bankruptcy_avoiding.html

If you need any clarification, please don't hesitate to click the "clarify" button.

Thanks,

darrel-ga

Request for Answer Clarification by march5th00-ga on 28 Feb 2004 16:38 PST
Good Answer!  quick question.  Could you elaborate a little further on
option number 3 - settling the debts with the credit card companies. 
I've been told if I simply tell the credit card company that I refuse
to pay that they'll settle with me for like 40 percent of the debt as
long as it can be payed quickly.  Is this true?  How bad does settling
look on a credit report?
Otherwise I plan on looking into Consumer Credit Counselling.  What
makes this particular Counselling program that much different than
others?
Thanks again for your interest in this question.

Clarification of Answer by darrel-ga on 28 Feb 2004 18:46 PST
Hello--

Thanks for your clarification request.

I'll answer your questions.

"Could you elaborate a little further on option number 3 - settling
the debts with the credit card companies. I've been told if I simply
tell the credit card company that I refuse to pay that they'll settle
with me for like 40 percent of the debt as long as it can be payed
quickly.  Is this true?  How bad does settling look on a credit
report?"

40 percent might be a bit low for a settlement, but i've heard of
settlements of 60 or 70 percent. Keep in mind that each credit card
company is different, and there's no hard-and-fast rule when it comes
to negotiations. It all depends on how badly they want to settle with
you. If you have a history of falling behind in your payments or not
paying at all, they may be quite willing to go lower than 60 or 70
percent. This would be because getting SOME money from you is better
than NOTHING at all. Each creditor will have different rules for
handling these situations. The only way you could find out is to call
and ask. It doesn't hurt anything to inquire about settlement options.
You aren't penalized on your credit report until you actually agree to
the settlement. And in many cases making a settlement is better for
your credit than continuing to be 90 days behind in payments.

Regarding how it hurts your credit: A settlement like this will only
hurt your credit if someone looking at your credit cares that you made
a settlement. Many might look at a settlement as a way you corrected a
past mistake. It will appear on your credit report for several years
after the time you make the final settlement payment. The exact time
frame depends on the type of loan.

"Otherwise I plan on looking into Consumer Credit Counselling.  What
makes this particular Counselling program that much different than
others?"

I don't have any self-interest in promoting the CCCS. And there are
other legitimate ones out there. The CCCS is simply the organization
that has been around the longest and the one I have particular
knowledge of its reputation. I talk with a lot of consumers about debt
issues - among many other issues - and I have never heard a complaint
about the CCCS.

If you need further clarification, I'm here to help.

darrel-ga
march5th00-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars
Great Answer!  Just the type I was looking for.  I have a long road
ahead of me and many options to choose.  Thanks for narrowing that
field down for me though.

Comments  
Subject: Re: Debt Consolidation Options
From: michaelsanswers-ga on 04 Feb 2004 07:52 PST
 
Dan, any available equity in the car?
Subject: Re: Debt Consolidation Options
From: march5th00-ga on 04 Feb 2004 09:20 PST
 
I'm not sure what you mean by available equity.  I currently have a
lien on the car through a credit union until the balance is payed off.
 I owe 4k but the car is worth about 8
Subject: Re: Debt Consolidation Options
From: peggy_bill-ga on 04 Feb 2004 14:28 PST
 
Dear march5th00,

Financial instablity is a frightening place to be.  I feel for you.

I have a couple of suggestions.  Are you a member of a credit union
through your work?  If so, they are often very good at giving low
interest consolidation loans.

If that isn't an option, perhaps your father (or someone else) is
comfortable enough with your responsible nature to co-sign a loan for
you with which you can consolidate your debt.  If he co-signs, he will
be completely responsible for the loan were you to default.  So, it is
important you both understand that from the beginning.  You will be
able to get a lower interest loan if there is collateral.  Once, years
ago, when I was in a similar situation to yours, my mother took out a
home equity loan on her house (the loan was miniscule compared to the
equity in her house).  I cosigned with her, and I paid the entire loan
back.  It was a large amount of trust on her part, but it didn't cost
her anything at all financially.

I hope these ideas help.  And, good luck.
Peggy bill
-google researcher-

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy