|
|
Subject:
English subtitles on DVDs - hearing impaired necessity
Category: Arts and Entertainment > Movies and Film Asked by: finler-ga List Price: $15.00 |
Posted:
29 Jul 2004 08:13 PDT
Expires: 28 Aug 2004 08:13 PDT Question ID: 380774 |
Because current amplification usage, and perhaps other things, filter out the high frequencies that I need to understand speech, and I cannot effectively follow conversation on DVDs (and of course TV). Accordingly I am dependant on subtitles and will not attempt to enjoy a film not providing them. I rent my DVDs through Netflix which provides, in its descriptive material for particular DVDs, availability of subtitles. Frequently I find the subtitles are not provided even though the Netflix description indicates they are. My complaint to Netflix - after I finally was able to convince them of the situation with respect to specific failures - developed that they simply (and carelessly) accept the representations of the providers without even test checking them. I have given up on the hassle. So far Netflix is the only real game in town - nothing I know in their competition cames near their coverage. Accordingly I need a resource that FROM KNOWLEDGE can readily provide me with reliable information respecting subtitle (etc) availability for each DVD I contemplate renting. Is there such a resource - preferably on the internet - that can provide such verified information? I am not interested in bugging Nerflix or anyone else - I just want/need the information to save myself frustration (and expense) caused by the occasional inaccurate or careless description. |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: English subtitles on DVDs - hearing impaired necessity
From: ipfan-ga on 29 Jul 2004 15:03 PDT |
You do know that most DVD's contain closed captioning in addition to or instead of subtitles, right? The closed captioning is a separate functionality completely. For example, if you go into the DVD menu and turn subtitles "off," you can still see closed captioning IF you have closed captioning turned on on your TV--it is separate from the DVD functionality. So assuming you have a newer TV, go into your TV menus and look for "closed captioning" or "CC" and turn it on. Then, when you play a DVD, even if it is not subtitled the closed captioning appears. Now not all films are closed captioned either, but in my experience even if a film has no actual SUBTITLES as part of the DVD, the closed captioning, a separate hidden code that your ~TV~ reads, will appear if you have it turned on on your TV. This is true for television programs as well, of course. I guess I should tell you that I am assuming you are watching newer DVD's. If we're talking about old classic B&W's, fewer of them are closed captioned. |
Subject:
Re: English subtitles on DVDs - hearing impaired necessity
From: finler-ga on 29 Jul 2004 18:03 PDT |
Thank you but I believe I have been through enough disappointment, and simply want to know definitely if there are indeed captions, however they are called. I am looking for a reliable reference source that will tell me whether or not the captions or subtitles are there. Up until now it has been hit and miss. Incidentally I use a program on the computer to view my DVD rentals - I find the controls, as well as the picture definition, a lot better than those using the "remote" on my TV. Thanks for your interest. - sdf |
Subject:
Re: English subtitles on DVDs - hearing impaired necessity
From: caedussaevire-ga on 29 Jul 2004 21:17 PDT |
Two sources that can help: http://www.dvdreview.com/ http://www.amazon.com/ (amazon.com, click on "more product details" and then on "Click here for more technical details about this edition..." Although I cannot assure you that these sources have 100% correct information. However, review sites usually have a high grade of precision. Amazon on the other hand, has a wide selection of DVD's. Greetings, CS |
Subject:
Re: English subtitles on DVDs - hearing impaired necessity
From: finler-ga on 30 Jul 2004 08:34 PDT |
Thank you for your response and suggestions. The Amazon idea was of little use - I already know Amazon presents formidable interference to anyone including (foolishly for them) buyers with specific authors or titles in mind. Further if you are intent on digging out full data it appears to be a mixture with my subtitle information way down toward the bottom. My immediate objective is locating, if it exists, a resource, if it exists, that provides READY access- with -say - a standard dictionary as a model of an effective reference source for specific information. As to your other suggestion - I located the site but have not really started to explore it. However, just for laughs, I fished one of their long listings and, spotting something familiar, I dragged up Sex in the City - Third Season. Guess what? They indicated "NO subtitles". Now - I know damn well there were indeed subtitles - because I actually saw them - offered right up front as subtitles, not closed caption. (I was looking to see what they had on their First season, which I know from bitter experience, had no subtitles.) The disinformation was very disheartening. However, I will continue my exploration of this particular resource - maybe they have a "help" facility that can give me some guidance. Thanks again - and if you have any further thoughts I would be more than pleased to give it a try. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |