|
|
Subject:
What is an historical model for the GWT?
Category: Reference, Education and News > Current Events Asked by: grthumongous-ga List Price: $15.00 |
Posted:
03 Aug 2004 18:08 PDT
Expires: 02 Sep 2004 18:08 PDT Question ID: 383173 |
Is there an historical model for the Global War on Terror (GWT) such that any lessons learned can be applied to the GWT? Does the strategy and the tactics for dealing with the GWT resemble any other past or present conflicts or contests? Some *possible* examples: the Cold War the War on Drugs Nineteenth Century Piracy on the high seas Cattle rustling in the Olde West the "Troubles" in Northern Ireland Palestinian-Israeli issue AIDS pandemic Polio pandemic |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: What is an historical model for the GWT?
From: pinkfreud-ga on 03 Aug 2004 18:18 PDT |
This is interesting: "[Niall] Ferguson turns to the nineteenth-century British Empire to find a more apposite historical model for today's crisis. He describes the spectacular rise and fall of Muhammad Ahmed al-Mahdi, a messianic Sudanese Islamic fundamentalist whose soldiers stormed Khartoum in 1885, killing British General Charles Gordon along with the city's other defenders. This attack, as Ferguson observes, was the 'September 11' of the era. And the British Empire hardly collapsed as a result. Instead, the outraged British responded decisively to al-Mahdi's provocation, and at the battle of Omdurman in 1898, ten thousand of the rebels were wiped out by British Maxim machine guns. Meanwhile, only a handful of British soldiers were killed. Sound familiar? Building on this parallel, Ferguson argues that the United States should now take a forceful leadership role in the world -- a role similar to that played by the British Empire -- in order to counter the growing forces of disorder." http://www.foreignaffairs.org/20020301faessay8054-p30/peter-l-bergen/picking-up-the-pieces.html |
Subject:
Re: What is an historical model for the GWT?
From: pinkfreud-ga on 03 Aug 2004 18:23 PDT |
This entire article is worth reading: "Ernest May eventually wrote, with Richard Neustadt, a prescriptive book called Thinking in Time, about ways in which people can learn from history more successfully. The essential point was that no episode in history is identical to any other, although they may share certain patterns or be linked by one's leading to another. It is important in every case to draw up a list of the resemblances to events in the past?and also a list of the differences. Ho Chi Minh resembled Hitler in being a tyrant; he differed in not seeking world domination. This reasoning led May to wonder about the implications of the Pearl Harbor metaphor for the recent terrorist attacks. 'I was interested in the extent to which the Pearl Harbor analogy popped into everyone's mind right away,' he told me. 'I'm not really sure it's just because of the similar element of surprise. It may also reflect the idea that this, too, would be an experience that united us. I think people were reaching for that. And in a way the most potent part of the analogy was the one behind that?the immediate definition of the event as war. That empowers a President to do things he might not do otherwise. But it is also confining, because it conjures up the image of victory?an image [Secretary of Defense] Donald Rumsfeld, in particular, cautioned against.' ...Ernest May's latest book, Strange Victory, is about the Nazis' lightning conquest of France in 1940. May told me he thinks of that, too, as a useful analogy: 'The Germans thought very hard about what were the procedural vulnerabilities on the other side. How the way they did things made them vulnerable. Obviously, that's been done to us in this case.' May started running through other precedents and parallels?for instance, the way Tom Ridge's new Office of Homeland Security resembles efforts by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to straighten out bureaucratic snarls during World War II. But then he cautioned against spending too much time in this pursuit." http://www.theatlantic.com/issues/2001/12/fallows.htm |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |