![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Forming Religious Beliefs
Category: Relationships and Society > Religion Asked by: webhosting-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
10 Jul 2002 16:22 PDT
Expires: 09 Aug 2002 16:22 PDT Question ID: 38326 |
I have heard that a Christian convert usually adopts the religious belief sets of the denomination or group in which he or she has the conversion experience. Where can I see this study documented? I want to know who performed the study, what were the survey questions and what were the statistical results. |
![]() | ||
|
There is no answer at this time. |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Forming Religious Beliefs
From: tehuti-ga on 11 Jul 2002 02:04 PDT |
I found something in an Australian study that argues against that statement: "People were more likely to go to where they were comfortable and felt catered for, rather than their denomination of birth/conversion. Denominational affiliation had in large part been replaced by a Protestant Supermarket.This was particularly true for those under 40, with only 15% viewing loyalty to one denomination for life to be important compared to 38% for those over 60. This leads Kaldor to suggest that many people with active commitments have no great sense that a nominal membership of a particular denomination should have an overriding claim on their affections and loyalties." The work cited in this respect is Peter Kaldor, John Bellamy, Merilyn Correy and Ruth Powell, First Look in the mirror: Initial findings of the 1991 National Church Life Survey, Lancer, Homebush West, 1992. The study is at http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Oracle/3499/asr494b.htm |
Subject:
Re: Forming Religious Beliefs
From: mvguy-ga on 11 Jul 2002 11:47 PDT |
I'm not sure that the Australian study necessarily contradicts the thesis of the questioner. I think what's changed over the past generation or so in American Protestantism is that the distinctions among demoninations are less than the distinctions among individual churches. When people move or otherwise decide to look for a new church, they still look for the same type of church as where they had a good experience. These days, though, that church very well could be in a different denomination (or no demonination at all). At least that has been my observation. |
Subject:
Re: Forming Religious Beliefs
From: worldoffernsy-ga on 02 Aug 2002 10:43 PDT |
We are all searching for eternal happiness, and we are all searching for the Source of all Happiness. When people who have been labouring under a delusion have their minds strongly opened to happiness where before there was only sadness, they are faced with a choice about what to conclude. Do they conclude that the happiness comes because of external circumstances, i.e. the group that they are in at the time of the conversion, or do they conclude that the new happiness is the product of a growth in their own ability to react well to their surroundings? This, I feel, is the basis of your query. For instance, if I eat oranges, and I only ever eat oranges, and my life is not very good, and then one day I see you walking along, happily eating an apple, I might suddenly be led to think, "How come he's so happy?" I stop you and ask you "Why are you so happy?" and you reply, "Because I'm eating an apple." At this moment, I have a choice of logic to make. I can look at the sensory data in front of me, what I hear and what I see, and conclude that "Eating apples makes one happier than eating oranges." At that point, I vow to devote my life to eating apples, and spreading the apple-eating gospel. On the other hand, if I choose to distrust your explanation; if I conclude, "well, his being happy is a product of more than just eating an apple; it's just that we have to use the imperfect phenomena of communication," I can conclude, "eating apples does not necessarily make one happier than eating oranges. Maybe I need to concentrate on the good things in my life more. Then I might become happier." At that point, I will not then become an apple-eating guru, but I might lose the psychological chains which have kept me bound to my orange-eating habit. I would direct you to the works of Paramahansa Yogananda for an inspiring discussion of religious beliefs, their formation and a discussion of habit and the external trappings of religion. Especially relevant would be Autobiography of a Yogi, or 'The Need for Universal Religious Principles' in "Journey to Self-Realization", his collection of essays and talks. Alternatively, you could visit www.yogananda-srf.org for more information. As a final thought, you do not need specialist studies to see how people, converted or otherwise, cling to the external habits of a particular group because they think that in it lies the key to their happiness. Looking at the world around you, talking to those around you, and examining your own principles and habits will inform you much more. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |