Dear Lilly-ga,
I have been reading the article of Dr. Nikolas K. Gvosdev with great
interest. He is signaling a trend of discrimination that seems to be
supported by an ongoing departure of the Russian minority in
Uzbekistan, at least according to the available figures on migration.
From my search at relevant sources I get the clear impression that
whenever massive departure of the Russion minority has been a problem
in the past, it does not occur at this stage in the news. I have been
looking at recent news articles on Uzbekistan: the Russian minority is
not even mentioned.
On a political level the relations between Russia and Uzbekistan are
discussed extensively (and after 9-11 that got an extra dimension) but
there is no attention for the Russian minority. Even Russian news
sources do not mention it as a current issue, while you would expect
them to do so when there would be larger problem.
The famous CIA handbook does not mention the issue.
Also organizations that have offered dr. Gvosdev older material to
support his article, do not mention the issue. I have looked at the
site of both the UNHCR, the UN organization for refugees and the
Helsinki Foundation, a rather critical group following the
developments in the former Sowjet Union rather intensively.
Can we be sure that the Uzbeki government is not encouraging the
Russion minority to leave at this stage? I do not think so. A few
speculations on why we cannot find that much on current events. The
article of dr. Gvosdev offers also a few general indications why we do
not hear too much about the issue.
First: Many of the Russian have left already, if we can believe the
figures on migration now about 5.5 of the Uzbeki citizens are from
Russion origine (writes the CIA handbook), down from 8 percent in
1989. Further: pressure has not been very violent, as also dr. Gvosdev
admits. The rule that Uzbeki government officials should speak fluent
Uzbeki might sound harsh for Russians who have never done so, but I
can see the logic here.
Also, the Russion orthodox minority has no tradition of really
resisting itself against unfair treatment, Gvosdev also mentions.
The sources I have looked through do not mention any pressure on the
Russian minority by islamic fundamentalists. Uzbeki internet resources
give also an url to a russian cultural center, as to many other
organization in the country. The link to this center does not work,
but that it has in common with many links on this site Freenet
Uzbekistan.
Hope this helps,
Regards,
Fons
Links:
the article of dr. Nikolas (downloaded through a google catch because
Chinese censors block geocities in China)
http://216.239.51.100/search?q=cache:9Gsgq7zXei0C:www.geocities.com/Athens/Olympus/5357/uzb.html+Turkey+and+Uzbekistan+Gvosdev&hl=en&ie=UTF-8
An overview of the English-language news on Uzbekistan
http://www.advancenet.net/~k_a/uzbekistan/news.htm#news1
The CIA-handbook on Uzbekistan:
http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/uz.html
The Helsinki Foundation
http://www.hfhrpol.waw.pl/En/
THe site of the UNHCR
http://www.unhcr.ch/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/home
Uzbeki Internet resources
http://www.freenet.uz/
Search strategy:
Google on:
Uzbekistan
Gvosdev
Helsinki Foundation |