Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Study on college students ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   1 Comment )
Question  
Subject: Study on college students
Category: Arts and Entertainment > Books and Literature
Asked by: qanda4me-ga
List Price: $12.50
Posted: 06 Oct 2004 19:34 PDT
Expires: 05 Nov 2004 18:34 PST
Question ID: 411355
I found a study last week and have not been unable to locate it again.
I need to find it again. Here is a summation of the study.
  Students were divided into two groups, One group was qualified for
the course of study and another was not qualified for the course of
study. The unqualified goupe took a test and were told that they were
qualified. Because of their belief that they were qualified, they did
much better than expected.
   If you are unable to locate this study, I will accept any
verifiable legitimate study you can find that demonstrates the power
of belief, i.e. belief over accepted reality.

Request for Question Clarification by rainbow-ga on 07 Oct 2004 07:23 PDT
Hi qanda4me,

Do you remember if the study had anything to do with races or
ethnicity? I ask this because I located one article which describes a
study done on black and white students. Here's an excerpt:

"...In the main study in this area, done by Claude Steele and Joshua
Aronson in 1995, black and white Stanford undergraduates were given a
difficult test of verbal ability. The students of both races were
divided into two groups. Half of both black and white students were
told the test would be used to assess their groups' intellectual
ability--the "stereotype threat condition." The black students who
were tested under threat did worse than the black students who were
not told this. White students performed the same, whether or not they
were threatened.

The key to this study, and to its misuse, can be found in how the
results were reported. The average incoming verbal SAT scores of the
black Stanford students lagged about 40 points behind the white
students in the experiment. In order to control for those academic
disparities, the authors adjusted scores on the experimental tests to
account for any background SAT score differences. Since the adjustment
allowed them to compare students as if they were equally qualified,
it's no surprise that black and white students were reported as
achieving the same scores when the stereotype threat was removed."

Best regards,
Rainbow

Request for Question Clarification by rainbow-ga on 07 Oct 2004 10:52 PDT
Hi qanda4me,

Is there anything else you can remember about this study? Was it taken
from a journal or maybe a university website? Any specific words or
phrases come to mind? Anything at all you can remember can help in
this search. Thanks.

Best regards,
Rainbow

Request for Question Clarification by rainbow-ga on 07 Oct 2004 13:24 PDT
Hi qanda4me,

Could this be the study:

"...Defense is not a matter of disavowing the facts of a situation; it
is a matter of attending selectively to plausible, but arguably less
reasonable, interpretations of events because those interpretations
serve to preserve (or even enhance) one's self-esteem and are
consistent with one's sense of personal identity (i.e., with who one
thinks one is). Self-deception in this study involved participants'
ability to minimize the significance of their lack of confidence that
they were qualified for graduate admission by focusing their attention
on their confidence that they will be able to become qualified by
enacting the behavioral strategies presented in the workshop.

    Self-deception is characterized by individuals' willingness to
maintain their belief in a particular, self-serving interpretation of
an event in spite of very limited evidence in support of that
interpretation (what Sartre [1943/1956] called "non-persuasive
evidence") and, based on their avowal of those interpretations, to
minimize the importance of other possible accounts of the event. In
other words, because it is conceivable that even Low GPA group
participants could become viable candidates for graduate admission,
they believe they probably will be viable candidates..."

Waiting to here your views.

Rainbow

Clarification of Question by qanda4me-ga on 08 Oct 2004 17:36 PDT
I was researching the power of belief. I have heard of stories where
belief alone is the reason why something happened. I am trying to find
examples that show that when it comes to belief verses reality, belief
usually wins. I only made a mental note of the story and thought I had
bookmarked it but have not been able to find it again. I will accept
any study you can find that demonstrates the power of belief over an
outcome as opposed to what one would expect the outcome should be. The
study does not have to be about college students. I am writing a book
and would like to make this point and back it up with a study, any
study that makes the point of how powerful belief is in life.
Answer  
Subject: Re: Study on college students
Answered By: rainbow-ga on 09 Oct 2004 08:06 PDT
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Hi Hi qanda4me,

The following are examples of the power of belief. These are all
excerpts for your convenience, so I suggest you read the articles in
their entirety. Some of these articles are in pdf format so you will
Adobe Acrobat to access them.


"Bandura has an excellent treatment of the importance of self-efficacy
in organizational decision-making. Essentially, he cites studies
supporting the vital roleof leaders? personal efficacy in the
processes of decision-making in organizations. He laments the
methodological difficulties of the studies that have been done. He,
and others, devised an experiment that permitted the assessment of the
importance of belief in the performance of all members of an
organization. One group of individuals was told that the skills
involved in the successful performance of carrying out the decisions
in the study were inherent, while another group was told that the
outcome of their efforts was essentially under their control. The
latter group performed significantly better than the former, thus
demonstrating the power of belief transmitted through a highly
efficacious manager to other members of the organization, who in turn
behaved in an efficacious manner."

The Pacific Institute: Self-Efficacy-The Exercise of Control By Dr. Albert Bandura
http://www.pac-inst.com/Library/letter/98-01.pdf.

===================================

"The power of beliefs in the classroom is well illustrated by the
story of a group of children who were tested and found to be average
learners. The group was then subdivided into two random subgroups. One
subgroup had a teacher who was told that the pupils he was taking were
?gifted?. The teacher of the other subgroup was told that his pupils
were ?slow learners?. The assessment of the two groups at the end of
the year showed that the majority of the group which had been
arbitrarily named as ?gifted? obtained higher scores than they had
previously, while the majority of the supposed ?slow learners? scored
lower then they had before. One conclusion we can draw from this
experiment is that the majority of children in the two subgroups
conformed to the beliefs their teachers had about them, not to their
real capabilities. This is a startling example of the power of the
educator?s beliefs to enable or disable their students because the
educator?s belief became the student?s reality."

Education and Beliefs By Maite Galan and Tom Maguire 
http://www.xtec.es/~jmaguire/articles/Education%20and%20Beliefs.pdf.

===================================

"...The second study to be reviewed was performed in the United States
in 1950, about ten years prior to the Japanese study. In this study a
bold experiment was performed, one that might not be allowed today
because it involved lying to the participants. The author of the
study, Dr Wolf, gave a group of women a toxic substance called syrup
of ipecac that causes nausea and vomiting. He lied to the women,
however, telling them it was actually a drug that would cure nausea
and vomiting. The women in the study were already suffering from
chronic nausea and vomiting of pregnancy, and so they gladly took the
syrup of ipecac. In most cases their symptoms ceased entirely.
Objective evidence of their improvement was also measured by Dr. Wolf,
who had the patients swallow small tubes to measure the amount of
muscle contractions in the stomach, contractions that occur with the
heaving which occure when one vomits. After taking the toxin, the
contractions subsided. This second study shows that, at least in the
short term, a drug that is highly toxic can actually cure the very
subjective and objective symptoms that it normally causes - if the
power of belief is working in it's favor."

Virus Myth: Aids and the Voodoo By Matt Irwin
http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/data/mivoodoo.htm

===================================

"In the study, all students at an elementary school were given an
intelligence test. Then 20 percent of the students were chosen at
random, without respect to their grades on the test. These students
were reported to their teachers as showing ?unusual potential for
intellectual growth,? and about to ?bloom? in academic performance.

At the end of the school year, all students were again tested. Those
who had been labeled as ?intelligent? showed significantly better
performance on the second test than the rest of the children. In the
authors? words, ?the change in the teachers? expectations...had led to
an actual change in the intellectual performance of these randomly
selected children.?

The study met with a great deal of disbelief, especially among
teachers, but the experiment was repeated many times with similar
results. Later studies done with college students ? and then even with
rodents ? showed the same effect.

In the animal experiment, a group of psychology students were given
rats to train in running mazes. Half of the students were told that
their rats were genetically ?maze-bright? and could learn to run a
maze quickly, while the other half were told that their rats were
?maze-dull.? Actually, all of the rats were quite ordinary, neither
bright nor dull. However, those rats believed by the students to be
unusually bright learned to run the maze significantly faster than the
rats believed to be dull."

We are All Pygmalions By Cora Scott
http://www.saskworld.com/bodymindspirit/edition16/20_article_cora.htm

===================================

"What follows is recent research additionally supporting the power of
"belief." Jane Ogden, Ph.D., a health psychologist at Guys Kings and
St. Thomas' School of Medicine in London, studied groups of women,
those who successfully lost weight and kept it off and those who
didn't. She found two interesting points. First, the women who
believed their weight problem was a function of their behavior, as in
their eating and exercise habits, and not a result of external factors
such as genes or metabolism, were "more successful at losing pounds
because they believed that they were in control of their weight ? and,
therefore, believed they could lose weight." So, if you first take
responsibility and believe that your behavior has led you to be
overweight, then, if you believe that it is in your power to change
that behavior, you can succeed."

Google's cache of ABC News:
http://abcnews.go.com/sections/GMA/HealthyWoman/GMAWeight_FlipTheSwitchExcerpt040414.html

===================================

"A recent study reported in JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association) 
showed that over 7 in 10 people with asthma given an inhaler filled
with water had their asthma attacks stopped. The people with asthma
didn?t know that the inhaler had water of course. They were certain it
was the same medicine they had been using for years. The certainty is
the element in the mind/body response that we need to utilize for
maximum results in all forms of healing."

Meet My Good Friend, Placebo By Kevin Hogan
http://www.hollys.com/success-dynamics/placebo.htm

===================================

This may be of interest to you:

ABC News: The Power Of Belief 
http://p2.hostingprod.com/@worldwidescam.com/abcbeliefs.htm

===================================
===================================

Search strategy using Google:
I used many different keywords but these are the ones that worked the best.

"power of belief" study students -prayer
"power of belief" "two groups" study students -prayer
study "two groups" "power of belief" students OR participants  -prayer


I hope the information provided is helpful. If you have any questions
regarding my answer please don't hesitate to ask before rating it.

Best regards,
Rainbow
qanda4me-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars
thanks very much. I appreciate your help. I hope I can ask for your
help in the future.

Comments  
Subject: Re: Study on college students
From: rainbow-ga on 19 Oct 2004 07:30 PDT
 
Hi qanda4me,

Thank you for your comment. I would be happy to help you again in the future.

Best wishes,
Rainbow

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy