![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Earths rotation if people in China took one step in the same direction/time
Category: Science > Physics Asked by: hoges-ga List Price: $4.50 |
Posted:
30 Oct 2004 21:08 PDT
Expires: 29 Nov 2004 20:08 PST Question ID: 422362 |
If every person in china faced exactly the same direction and took a step at exactly the same time would it make a change to the earths rotational speed and/or orbit |
![]() | ||
|
There is no answer at this time. |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Earths rotation if people in China took one step in the same direction/time
From: probonopublico-ga on 31 Oct 2004 00:51 PDT |
It would depend on the direction, the size and the heaviness of their step. The Chinese are noted for their lightness of foot and so they could be relied upon not to disturb the Earth's equilibrium. Please don't ask about the people in the United States. |
Subject:
Re: Earths rotation if people in China took one step in the same direction/time
From: silver777-ga on 31 Oct 2004 02:01 PST |
Hi Hoges, Probonopublico beat me to it. Anyway .. the answer is NO. Stepping is simply a transfer of weight distribution. The causality of Earth's revolutions are not dependant upon human footsteps. Should the entire population of Earth attempt an experiment of residing on the island of say Zanzibar, then your weight distribution test may have some credence. The forecast calculation of impact upon the Earth would be arguable. At least the remainder of the Earth may silently express a sigh of relief as we anihalate one another upon Zanzibar. Then again, if the Chinese chose to step in the right direction, I'm sure that we would find a positive outcome for all. On the other hand, if the physical steps taken were vertical, of sufficient height and suspended for a duration, the landing area may differ from the take-off point. Gravity does not begin from the Earth's surface, it is well above head height of the average Chinese. Phil |
Subject:
Re: Earths rotation if people in China took one step in the same direction/time
From: racecar-ga on 31 Oct 2004 10:49 PST |
The rotational speed would change by a very small amount. Let's say there are a billion Chinese people (there might be a few more), and that they weigh 100 kg each (this is an overestimate, but I do hear that obesity is a growing problem in China). They all begin to walk east at the relaxed pace of 1 m/s. Ignoring silly factors like the cosine of the latitude and taking the earth's radius as 6 million meters, they represent a change in angular momentum about the earth's axis of about 6e17 kgm^2/s. Approximating the earth as a homogenous sphere with mass 6e24 kg, the angular momentum of the earth (rotational inertia = 2/5 mr^2, and angular velocity = 2pi/86400s) is about 6e33 kgm^2/s. Total angular momentum is conserved, so the spinning of the earth slows down by about 1 part in 1e16. If they were all to continue their hike for a year, that year would be lengthened by a few nanoseconds (a few billionths of a second). Not measureable. |
Subject:
Re: Earths rotation if people in China took one step in the same direction/time
From: guzzi-ga on 31 Oct 2004 17:54 PST |
The world would slow down (or speed up) as they all took their step, then be restored when they stopped. As racecar said, the effect would be unmeasurable but that matters not to the principle. In fact, you don?t need the entire population of China do the sums -- move your hand, deflect an electron, any mass movement, even shining a torch. One may consider that such diminishingly small effects are inconsequential. Not so. Extrapolation to limiting conditions is an invaluable tool for qualitative analysis and furnishes perspective on physical phenomenon. On this basis, by General Relativity, the movement of mass will have a permanent effect because it will have altered time. An example of the insight from such extreme thinking. Roll a coin across a table. The momentum of that coin (on best current theory) is infinitely greater than the momentum of the whole universe. I find such revelation majestic and profoundly spiritual -- so far beyond religion, and simplistic philosophies so redolent in, for example, presidential elections. Best |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |