Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: History:World War II-reciprocal Brazil/U.S. combat agreements: ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   2 Comments )
Question  
Subject: History:World War II-reciprocal Brazil/U.S. combat agreements:
Category: Reference, Education and News > General Reference
Asked by: cariocajoe-ga
List Price: $20.00
Posted: 28 Jul 2002 21:18 PDT
Expires: 27 Aug 2002 21:18 PDT
Question ID: 46318
Durng World War II Brazilian troops were fighting in Italy under
Allied Command. I was informed that a reciprocal Agreement was signed
beteen Brazil and the U.S. granting reciprocal rights to both troops.
Thus, under this agreement in terms of today Brazilian ex-combat
veterans can avail themselves of  U.S. Veteran rights and benefits as
well as American  combat Veterans being entitled to Brazilian veteran
rights and benefits. I am informed that this may have been an exchange
of letters rather than a formal treaty or accord.
Answer  
Subject: Re: History:World War II-reciprocal Brazil/U.S. combat agreements:
Answered By: brad-ga on 29 Jul 2002 01:15 PDT
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
As you mentioned, the "groundwork" of the "Rio Treaty" occurred as
WWII approached our hemisphere. I have read the treaty articles as
listed below.
They were adopted in 1947.

It called for mutual defense rather than the creation of a combined
military under the United States of all the military forces in our
hemisphere.
Brazilians fought alongside Americans, Englishmen, Russians and the
soldiers of many other Allied countries as representatives of their
own countries in the battle against Axis subjugation.  It was a
"World" war and Brazilians were members of that group of brave heroes
who saved future generations from Nazi enslavement.

The Rio treaty has no provision for entitlement of U.S. Veterans
benefits to Brazilian veterans.  Likewise, it has no provision for
entitlement of Brazilian Veterans benefits to the veterans of the
United States who fought alongside Brazil in defense of freedom.


"The Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance ("TIAR" or "Rio
Treaty") grew out of the perceived need to provide a collective
security mechanism for the hemisphere during the run-up to the Second
World War. Although the groundwork for the treaty was laid during the
war, the treaty was not adopted until the Third Meeting of
Consultation of the Ministers of Foreign Affairs held in Rio de
Janeiro, Brazil in 1947. The treaty entered into force in 1948. Since
then, it has served as one of the pillars of the collective
hemispheric defense architecture.

The Rio Treaty is a "special treaty" within the meaning of Article 29
of the OAS Charter. Among other things, it defines the measures and
procedures governing a collective response by the other states party
when a state party suffers an armed attack or an aggression that is
not an armed attack. The Treaty has been invoked on 19 occasions since
its inception, the most recent being 1982.

The Rio Treaty provides for a collective security mechanism. Under its
terms, an armed attack on one member is to be considered an attack on
all. The treaty also provides for measures to address aggressions that
are not armed attacks, as well as for extracontinental or
intracontinental conflicts, or "any other fact or situation that might
endanger the peace of America."
http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/sept_11/state_001.htm

Article 3 of the Rio Treaty.
1. The High Contracting Parties agree that an armed attack by any
State against an American State shall be considered as an attack
against all the American States and, consequently, each one of the
said Contracting Parties undertakes to assist in meeting the attack in
the exercise of the inherent right of individual or collective
self-defense

http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/decade/decad061.htm

Digested to simple words, the Rio Treaty mandates that any attack by a
foreign power against the people of Brazil is an attack against the
people of the United States. We have agreed that we are a family that
will protect the countries of this hemisphere against aggression from
elsewhere.

I have scoured the Library of Congress and Department of Veteran
Affairs and searched for any possibility of US Veterans benefits being
allowable to members of the Brazilian military forces during WWII or
after.  There is no indication that such benefits were ever considered
in developing this treaty of mutual defense.

Please remember that you are entitled to reject my answer if it does
not satisfy your query.

Brad-ga
cariocajoe-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars
Excellent-what took brad-ga a short time, took me several weeks just
to get halfway down the road. Thank you.
cariocajoe-ga.

Comments  
Subject: Re: History:World War II-reciprocal Brazil/U.S. combat agreements:
From: historybuff-ga on 29 Jul 2002 00:21 PDT
 
I found only vague allusions to veterans benefits for Brazilians,
which led to outdated (missing) pages.

Here are some sites you may wish to follow leads from:

A detailed account of the Brazilian efforts in Europe
http://www.geocities.com/Pentagon/Bunker/3351/campaigns/brzedit.html

The WWII treaty between Brazil and the US was INTER-AMERICAN TREATY OF
RECIPROCAL ASSISTANCE, informally known as the Rio Treaty.  The full
text of the treaty can be read at the link below, by the Organization
of American States.

http://www.oas.org/juridico/english/Treaties/b-29.html

I read it and found no mention or even vague reference to veterans
benefits.

Some of the other information I found, such as presidential notes
around the time of the Treaty and Presidential visit to Brazil are in
the archives listed here:

http://archiveseleanor.nara.gov/index.html

I hope that points you to more information!
Subject: Re: History:World War II-reciprocal Brazil/U.S. combat agreements:
From: cariocajoe-ga on 29 Jul 2002 18:00 PDT
 
The information is most helpfull. Some U.S. WW II combat veterans now
live permanently in Brazil. Some have dual citizenship. Most Brazilian
cities allow Brazilian combat (Italy based)veterans exemmption from
the paying of the municipal real estate taxes. Clauses in the treaties
cited may just be accepted by some municipalities to allow exemption
of these taxes to some Americans in the above category.
Thank you again.
As an additional comment, some Brazilians (non American citizens)
fought in WW II in the U.S. armed forces. After the war, this service
allowed them to gain U.S. citizenship under a perferred status. Those
that did were considered U.S. veterans and entitled to full benefits.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy