|
|
Subject:
Where's the other dollar?
Category: Miscellaneous Asked by: rodie-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
04 Feb 2005 08:07 PST
Expires: 06 Mar 2005 08:07 PST Question ID: 468721 |
3 men stopped at motel to get a room for the night. The manager charged $30 for the room and each man paid $10. After they left, the manager realized that he charged them $5 too much and asked the bell boy to take the $5 to the men. The bell boy realized before he got to the men's room that he could not divide the $5 equally and decided to give them each a dollar and keep the other $2 for himself. After the men each received their dollar, they would now have paid $9 each (which equals $27) and $2 to the bell boy for a total of $29 for the room. Where's the other dollar? |
|
Subject:
Re: Where's the other dollar?
Answered By: jackburton-ga on 04 Feb 2005 08:42 PST |
The other dollar has gone nowhere... "This brainteaser is an example of a false problem. You cannot add the 27$ to the 2$ as the 2$ that is now with the bellboy is actually part of the 27$ they finally paid for the room! So there is no question of 1$ being "missing"! In fact you have to add the 27$ to the 3$ that the men got back. Although the 3 men paid 27$ they didn't give that money to the hotelkeeper. The fact is that the 2$ extra that they paid is with the bellboy. So the original 30$ is distributed as follows: hotelkeeper 25$, bellboy 2$, 3 men 3$. Beware of ostensible reasoning!" http://pgoh.free.fr/answers.html "The calculation of $27 + $2 contains two errors: the manager's $5 is ignored and the bellboy's $2 is counted in the wrong direction. The original payment of $30 is correctly accounted for as $27 finally paid by the three guests, plus $5 refunded by the manager, MINUS $2 kept by the bellboy (so that only $3 of refund was received)." http://rec-puzzles.org/new/sol.pl/logic/29 |
|
There are no comments at this time. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |