Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: rock climbing injury ( No Answer,   5 Comments )
Question  
Subject: rock climbing injury
Category: Health > Conditions and Diseases
Asked by: g_austin-ga
List Price: $10.00
Posted: 30 Jul 2002 21:04 PDT
Expires: 12 Aug 2002 14:44 PDT
Question ID: 47214
I am a rock climber and am experiencing pain in my forearm when I
release my grip on a hold. It does NOT hurt when I grab the hold just
when I release. The pain is not debilitating but it is pronouced
enough for concern. I would like to know what this means in terms of
prevention, treatment, and the medical description of what is occuring
internally to cause the pain.
Answer  
There is no answer at this time.

Comments  
Subject: Re: rock climbing injury
From: dexterpexter-ga on 30 Jul 2002 22:38 PDT
 
Hello, and thanks for a challenging question.  I suppose I may be of
some minor help, although your question is very delicate since it is
medically-inclined, and the shortcoming of cyberspace is the
incapacity to perform a proper examination.  First of all, I will
start by commenting that forearm injuries in rock climbing are common,
even among the most experienced climbers.  Soft tissue in our bodies
are not always up to the stress and strain a good rock climb requires.
  This is mostly caused by the repeated contractions in the forearm
muscles.  Tendonitis of the forearm is also often reported by
climbers.

Some common injuries in the hands and forearm are:
-soft-tissue damage
-flexor tendon strain
-tendonitis
-tenosynovitis
-joint contractures
-and carpal tunnel syndrome

Rock climbing grip techniques transmit extremely high forces through
the tissues of the forearm, resulting in a myriad of injuries.  I
suggest you check out
http://www.physsportsmed.com/issues/1997/05may/jebson.htm
which gives a very nice run-through of the muscles and tendons, and
their injuries and function in rock climbing.  It also gives common
treatments and preventative measures, as you requested.  Although
highly technical, it is a good reference.  According to this site,
“Most climbers' hand injuries are relatively minor and can be treated
with rest, anti-inflammatory medication, and splinting and taping.
Certain injuries, however, require referral and surgical intervention,
and others, if neglected or not recognized, may have serious
functional consequences. Among these more serious injuries are flexor
tendon strains, pulley strains, and ruptures.”
I personally have carpal tunnel syndrome…a problem previously thought
to reside only in the elderly, but I have been diagnosed with this
problem since I was barely 10.
 First timers to rock climbing experience tenderness and mistake this
muscle development for injury, but you sound as though you are an
experienced climber: therefore, your injury may be a wearing caused by
overuse.  You may have torn something, although I cannot be sure. 
When I tore a muscle in my leg during my track and field years, I
experienced no pain while bending my leg, but the pain I experienced
when returning my leg to its extended position felt like someone
lighting a match to my upper leg…

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  I will foremost advise that you consult a doctor and do not depend
on the internet to diagnose injuries, for they can be serious and can
only be diagnosed upon in-person examination.  Problems that seem
minor often go untreated.  They can be progressive injuries that may
seem to lack seriousness now, but could eventually spell out the end
of your rock climbing…or writing or hand usage, for that matter.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

However, I will attempt to give you a little background on these
injuries.  Many rock climbers use massage techniques to eliminate
tenderness.
http://www.altrec.com/published/climb/healthfitness/herestherub/ 
suggests this massage for forearms: “This massage works wonders to
reduce inflammation after a climb, but can also help to alleviate a
flash pump mid-route. Grasp your forearm palm up with your opposite
hand. Moving from wrist to elbow, massage your arm with your fingers
and thumb. Turn your palm down, and repeat the massage. Use your thumb
to exert deeper pressure on trigger points for several seconds at a
time.”

Again, treatment should be left to an experienced physician who can
personally examine you.  Hand and forearm injuries are controversial
in their treatment since often surgery is required and the hand or arm
never fully heals or gets worse.  Some people have successfully
treated serious injuries.  Prevention to rock climbing injuries could
include the following:
-	observing personal limitations
-	further ground conditioning before taking on a major climb
-	hand exercises
-	massages
-	taping of the hands and wearing proper equipment
-	allowing rest time between climbs
These are only a few.  I wish you luck and would love to go on, but as
you can see, my answer is becoming quite lengthy already.  Good luck
and I would be delighted to offer more if you so need.
Subject: Re: rock climbing injury
From: g_austin-ga on 31 Jul 2002 00:06 PDT
 
Thanks for your prompt help! That's a lot of good information. I'm
holding off on going to a Dr. because minor 'strains' are common and
go away with rest. If I went to the Dr. every time something 'sort of
hurt' I would be broke or be released from my insurance. Besides the
great info you gave (which I will print out and add to my climbing
folder) I am still wondering if the web mentions this particular
phenominon of pain after release. It feels as though the sheath of the
tenden is hurting, but who knows? Hopefully one of you guys/gals!

I am taking a 5 day rest period and treating myself to a sports
massage. If the condition isn't gone by then I will definitely see a
Dr. I'll be sure to post the results of that exam here. Did your
search provide no mention of this particular type of "release" pain?
If not maybe I can go on a sports medicine news group or something and
post it as a question there.

ADDITIONAL INFO- the problem does not occur on all holds; only the
small finger pinching holds called crimps or crimpers, especially when
the hold is desperate so that you are not pulling down on the hold but
rather pulling on a hold about shoulder high and pulling your body to
the wall. I can hang on a huge hold with no problem. It's just those
finger squeezing ones that do it. Sorry if I'm making it more
confusing.
Subject: Re: rock climbing injury
From: to0d-ga on 31 Jul 2002 00:06 PDT
 
I would suggest your injury more like "tennis-elbow". Symptoms are
continous pain in your elbow to wrist area after some hard workout.
This can be identified to tennis elbow by pressing certain nerve area
in outer side of your elbow. It's hard to explain but can be found
between elbows funny-bone and ligament. The one who feels pain after
small pressure most likely suffers from tennis-elbow.
There is no permanent cure but cortisone injection could remove pain
for years. Also some vitamines like calsium helps...

Yours, To0d
Subject: Re: rock climbing injury
From: g_austin-ga on 31 Jul 2002 00:17 PDT
 
Thanks toOd. Actually, the pain doesn't last after the release of the
crimper. I can do it right now by pinching the side of my desk. After
letting go it hurts for a second, as the tension is released, and then
it feels find. It is very localized along my forearm. If you drew a
line from your pinky to your elbow that would be the line of pain
(except that it starts and ends within the forearm region) with the
locus of the pain being three inches from the wrist.
Subject: Re: rock climbing injury
From: dexterpexter-ga on 31 Jul 2002 01:58 PDT
 
I will try to search further on a specific mention of the phenomenon
you describe.    It might take some time... hopefully one of the paid
experts will find something.  Until then, I will look.  Hope you feel
better... :)

-dexterpexter

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy