|
|
Subject:
suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
Category: Family and Home > Relationships Asked by: joedimaggio-ga List Price: $15.00 |
Posted:
26 Feb 2005 05:36 PST
Expires: 28 Mar 2005 05:36 PST Question ID: 481232 |
my mother is a very caring and affectionate person. however she does have a tendency to go into these 'rages' or 'sulks' two or three times a week where she lashes out verbally at one of the family. the things that trigger off these events are sometimes very small, but sometimes large as well.during this time she is extremely abusive and insulting (sometimes profane) which is completely at odds with her general character. the result of this is that she appears to be under tremendous stress and often that one of the family gets very hurt. now this has been going on for a while, but recently it has stepped up both in frequency and intensity, and we are all really worried for her health. in our culture, the stereotype is that one visits a psychologist only when one is 'nuts' and there is a strong taboo in general against visiting one. my question is how do we as a family discuss this with her, without giving her the feeling that we are all siding 'against' her. we feel that a visit to a therapist would be hugely helpful, but with the taboo attached she is likely to be insulted that someone suggest that she see one. please help |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: siliconsamurai-ga on 26 Feb 2005 06:10 PST |
How about if you tell her you are having anger management issues and ask her to accompany you to a session? You would need to clear that with the therapist first. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: frde-ga on 26 Feb 2005 07:40 PST |
Tape her next rage - then play it back to her when she is Ok I would not suggest an overt video camera, but a covert one will help. It might be really interesting to uncover the source (underlying reason) for these rages. You might discover curious things about her background. As for what triggers it - it could well be dietary - I shall never eat another Pringles crisp/chip again - it could be the brand of soy sauce |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: siliconsamurai-ga on 26 Feb 2005 07:49 PST |
I would STRONGLY (VERY STRONGLY) suggest you check with a professional before following any of frde's suggestions. You might also want to check with an atty. about whether planting a bug in someone's house is a felony or misdemeanor in your area. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: pinkfreud-ga on 26 Feb 2005 09:38 PST |
Sometimes a change in terminology can make a visit to a psychotherapist seem more acceptable. Perhaps if you described the therapist as a "counselor," your mom might be more willing to consider the idea. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: frde-ga on 26 Feb 2005 10:16 PST |
Yes well, I disagree with Silicon Getting the law involved with minor domestic problems is a bad, bad idea. Since, it sounds as if your mother is rational most of the time, then by proving to her that she is having 'tantrums', perhaps 'flashbacks' - it is very possible that she will understand, and accept some sort of role reversal - or even better get what is bugging her off her mind Personally I would covertly record one of her tantrums and later play it back to her, but if you want to take the risky path (and strictly legal), then overtly do it - it will drive her mad. The real point is, if she is Ok 90% of the time, then you have a chance of getting things sorted out *quietly* between you. If she is nuts for 90% of the time then head for the hills |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: frde-ga on 26 Feb 2005 10:26 PST |
Yes I agree with the terminoligy suggestion. Perhaps 'taking tea with an aunt' would help I have a ghastly suspicion that she is cut off from her own cultural background and feeding and washing for a bunch of Americans. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: joedimaggio-ga on 26 Feb 2005 11:46 PST |
thank you all for your helpful coments. siliconsamurai - unfortunately i am not able to do as i will be away from home for a while frde - i did try something similar once, but these rages are so out of character that when she heard it she was genuinely confused and finally decided that, at the time, whatever was bugging her must have waranted such a response because normally she would never do that. also she is within her culture, i think a large amount of her stress comes from being recently retired with not much to keep her occcupied. pinkfreud - thanks for the idea about the counselor, i think that may be the first step. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: siliconsamurai-ga on 27 Feb 2005 05:15 PST |
FRDE ? I agree completely that the law shouldn?t be involved if possible. That is why I don?t think you should be recommending to the client that he/she commit what in my state would be a felony. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: frde-ga on 27 Feb 2005 06:01 PST |
As usual, garnering the facts is like extracting teeth - often I think people post here to get /themselves/ to 'marshal the facts' - not a bad idea - it seems to work @Silicon, I would seldom recommend committing a crime with 'malign intent' I understand your concern. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: pilgrimintx-ga on 06 Mar 2005 00:06 PST |
You would benefit by reading some family systems theory. By no means should you suggest to your loved one that she go to visit a therapist. Her issues are not happening in a vacuum. You need to suggest that there are some dynamics going on that the whole family needs help with and you go first, inviting her to accompany you or to come to a later session. Any psychologist or therapist will agree with this. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: cynthia-ga on 06 Mar 2005 18:28 PST |
I agree with pilgrimintx. Excellent idea. You and/or another family member can talk to a professional about this real problem in YOUR life, and when you ask your Mom to accompany you to a session (or more, later), it will be to "help" YOU. She will be much less resistant to the idea. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: joedimaggio-ga on 06 Mar 2005 19:30 PST |
Thanks for your suggestion. I will try this the next time i am home. there are very real reasons (as suggested by pilgrim) for my mothers frustration, unfortunately most are impossible to fix (ageing for example) and are difficult to help with from a distance. |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: mercuryminer-ga on 29 Jun 2005 08:47 PDT |
You might have a Borderline Personality Disorder on your hands. This is a very, very difficult situation. Talk to a professional about how to get help for your loved one. If BPD is confirmed, you should read "Stop Walking on Eggshells" by Mason and Kreger. Amazon.com has used copies at low cost. regards, Mike |
Subject:
Re: suggest a visit to a psychologist tactfully
From: jago8-ga on 02 Sep 2005 15:40 PDT |
I know you asked this question some time ago, but I just saw it and wondered if you have considered the possibility of brain disease (eg cancer). You make it sound as though these rages are not something you mother has displayed for most of her adult life. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |