![]() |
|
|
| Subject:
advantages (or dis) of studying multiple foreign languages concurrently
Category: Miscellaneous Asked by: elisternh-ga List Price: $20.00 |
Posted:
08 Mar 2005 13:49 PST
Expires: 07 Apr 2005 14:49 PDT Question ID: 486942 |
Are there advantages or disadvantages to learning multiple, unrealted foreign languages concurrently. I am planning to study German, Spanish and possibly other languages. Should I do it one at a time or concurrently? |
|
| There is no answer at this time. |
|
| Subject:
Re: advantages (or dis) of studying multiple foreign languages concurrently
From: pinkfreud-ga on 08 Mar 2005 14:00 PST |
I studied Spanish and French at the same time. Often words and grammatical forms from one language would creep into my usage of the other language. It was as if my brain had concocted a hybrid, "Sprench" or "Fanish." I think it would be easier if the languages you're studying are rather dissimilar. Your example, German and Spanish, probably wouldn't have the "crossover" problem that I experienced. |
| Subject:
Re: advantages (or dis) of studying multiple foreign languages concurrently
From: gerdson-ga on 09 Mar 2005 00:54 PST |
Dear, languages are more than words. Behind expressions of every language there is always a cultural background that must be sensed as deeply as possible. The more you know about the people who speak a language, their environment, history and so, the more you will be able to interpret their expressions properly. I would advise you take one language at a time and try to taste it just like you were sipping cups of warm tea, feeling it. If you do so, you will be surprised with how more interesting learning a foreign language can be. And don't forget to have a software like MSN, Skype, or other, to contact native speakers of the target language, specially the ones who are reciprocally interested in learning your native language. This way, you both will probrably be more motivated to help each other, and the mutual interest may boost and feed your motivation to go on with your learning process. In other words, don't be a language collector, be a universal person. And enjoy living! Gerdson (Brazil) http://www.tradutor.us |
| Subject:
Re: advantages (or dis) of studying multiple foreign languages concurrently
From: alinaradu-ga on 16 Mar 2005 06:39 PST |
It's true that languages are more than just words and that we should take one language at a time in order to "taste it" but it's also true that we only live once and if you want to learn more than one foreign language this lifetime won't be enough. So, if you just want to be able to understand and make yourself understood in more than one language, I think you could study French, German and any other language you want at the same time. I studied English, French, Spanish, German and even a little Italian at the same time and the only problems I had were Spanish-Italian because I found these 2 very similar when it comes to vocabulary. When it comes to grammar, however, things are different. I wish you Good luck, Bonne chance, Gutes Glück, Buona fortuna and Buena suerte! Alina Radu www.akela.ro |
| Subject:
Re: advantages (or dis) of studying multiple foreign languages concurrently
From: trerric-ga on 25 Mar 2005 06:13 PST |
Hi Elisternh, this may be one of those questions to which there is no answer. You can in theory learn to speak ,write and read as many languages as you would like to . Obviously better one at a time ,but many secondary schools and colleges seem to think differently and have their students lerning two or three foreign languages at the same time. Four languages to be lernt at the same time is rare. You should tech yourself some linguistics ( using the search engine ) and in particular comparitive linguistics and phonetics (use these keywords). Interesting discussions are going on on other parts of the web on learning languages , I´d reccomend Usenet discussions and Forums ,as sson as you have decided which language you really want to learn. Usenet can be accessed and seached in th http://groups.google.com cache of this site. If you would just like to have a brainstorming session on how to get off the starting block with learning languages and have not got an answer here by April 7th then why not set the spark to a brainstorming fire at the Brainstormings Group in the Google Groups? Peter |
| Subject:
Re: advantages (or dis) of studying multiple foreign languages concurrently
From: omnivorous-ga on 25 Mar 2005 07:49 PST |
Elisternh -- It's generally considered that immersion is the best way to learn a language, as it results in thinking and automatic response in the language, rather than translating words. That would argue for learning one language at a time: University of Hawaii http://www.uatuahine.hawaii.edu/hana/si98/jar/vocab.html And Pinkfreud's correct about the confusion that happens with two languages. When I was trying to learn Spanish I'd even toss in Swahili words. There is some connection (both have words taken from Arabic) but THAT was a surprising outcome. Google search strategy: languages immersion benefits Best regards, Omnivorous-GA |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
| Search Google Answers for |
| Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |