|
|
Subject:
Does a prism refract all electromagnetic waves?
Category: Science > Physics Asked by: rambler-ga List Price: $10.00 |
Posted:
12 Mar 2005 10:53 PST
Expires: 11 Apr 2005 11:53 PDT Question ID: 493299 |
Does a prism refract ALL electromagnetic waves (including x-rays and gamma rays, etc), or just visible light? |
|
Subject:
Re: Does a prism refract all electromagnetic waves?
Answered By: siliconsamurai-ga on 12 Mar 2005 14:12 PST Rated: |
Hi, thank you for submitting your question to Google Answers, I hope I can provide the information you are seeking. The short answer is no, a glass prism is essentially transparent to most forms of electro-magnetic radiation. The visible light spectrum is a very narrow band out of a very large spectrum. Visible light ranges from about 700 nanometers (.00000007) meters to 400 nm. At the two extreme ends of the spectrum lie radio waves (you know they pass right through glass) and, at the other end, gamma radiation (which passes through almost anything for some distance but, along with ultraviolet is absorbed by ozone, luckily for us). http://www.glenbrook.k12.il.us/gbssci/phys/Class/light/u12l2a.html or for a more advanced look http://astronomy.nju.edu.cn/astron/AT3/AT30303.HTM Refraction and even reflection take place according to the exact frequency of the radiation which explains why a prism can spread light into the spectrum. I?m not certain how much detail you want so for a very detailed explanation, see http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/physics/Prism.html For historical interest, this was all discovered and explained by (who else?) Issac Newton in his book Opticks (not a misspelling). I know a reproduction used to be available from Dover Publications. http://www.metaweb.com/wiki/wiki.phtml?title=Isaac_Newton It may still be available on CD from www.octavio.com Here?s an interesting tutorial on the whole spectrum http://astronomy.nju.edu.cn/astron/AT3/AT303EOC.HTM Although other wavelengths can?t be refracted or reflected by a glass prism, they can be by other things such as a strong magnetic field. They can also be diffracted, which is similar, by reflecting them from a glass-like sodium chloride (table salt) crystal. http://www.plus2physics.com/electrons_and_photons/study_material.asp?chapter=4&page=2 This and other substances which can reflect X-rays do so from the surface and depend on the spacing of atoms in the crystal matrix. You can learn more about how X-rays react at http://www.cxro.lbl.gov/optical_constants/ and calculate the index of refraction at http://www.cxro.lbl.gov/optical_constants/getdb2.html I did find a specific report on your precise question taken from Dr. W. C. Roentgen who discovered X-rays. http://www.emory.edu/X-RAYS/century_05.htm It says in part, Dec. 1895, ?After I had recognized the transparency of various substances of relatively considerable thickness, I hastened to see how the X-rays behaved on passing through a prism and to find whether they were thereby deviated or not. Experiments with water and with carbon disulphide enclosed in mica prisms of about 30 degrees refracting angle showed no deviation, either with the fluorescent screen or on the photographic plate. For purposes of comparison the deviation of rays of ordinary light under the same conditions was observed; and it was noted that in this case the deviated images fell on the plate about 10 or 20 mm distant from the direct image. By means of prisms made of hard rubbers and of aluminum, also of about 30 degree refracting angle, I have obtained images on the photographic plate in which some deviation may perhaps be recognized. However, the fact is quite uncertain; the deviation, if it does exist, being so small that in any case the refractive index of X-rays in the substances named cannot be more than 1.05 at the most. With a fluorescent screen I was unable to observe any deviation.? Thank you again for turning to Google Answers for your research needs. |
rambler-ga
rated this answer:
and gave an additional tip of:
$2.00
Thanks for the quick answer, and for providing all the links. |
|
Subject:
Re: Does a prism refract all electromagnetic waves?
From: puffin88-ga on 12 Mar 2005 12:49 PST |
The first thing I'll say is that since glass doesn't conduct electricity (and since they use glass windows on microwave ovens) I'm inclined to guess that there are some frequencies of electromagnetic waves that not only don't get refracted, they don't even get into the glass at all. The glass reflects them, just like a brick wall reflects the beam from a flashlight. But anyway, it might be worth remembering two things: 1) The refraction happens because the speed of light in glass is different than the speed of light in air. 2) The prism's refraction creates a rainbow because the change of the light's speed in the glass depends on the light's wavelength. That means that the blue in the light refracts differently than the red does, which has the effect of separating the colors from each other. (I have the feeling that you are asking about that rainbow effect, instead of just the refraction phenomenon. That's because you asked about a prism instead of, say, a fishtank, which also refracts light...but isn't shaped right to give a dramatic separation of colors) So, keeping those two things in mind, we can now see that your question can be restated as: "Give the formula for the speed of light in glass as a function of wavelength. Does it give different speeds no matter what wavelength you put in?" If the speed continues to change for values of the wavelength that very very large or very very small, that would predict that the prism does continue to act "prisimatically", over that very large range of electromagnetic waves. However, if the speed stops changing much when the wave lengths get very long or very short, then that would mean that the degree of refraction gets to be about constant and the prism acts more and more like a fishtank -- bending the light, but not separating out its frequencies. (caveat: now that I have written this, it occurs to me that I don't *really* know if it's right. I think it's right, but I'd be happy to have someone correct it.) |
Subject:
Re: Does a prism refract all electromagnetic waves?
From: xarqi-ga on 12 Mar 2005 15:05 PST |
Just some comments on some comments. Microwaves do not escape from a microwave oven because glass is opaque to them, it is the presence of the wire mesh in or on the glass that forms part of a Faraday cage that is responsible. From memory, electromagnetic radiation is not bent in an magnetic field. This applies to electrically charged particles only (Correct me please if I am wrong, but a cursory web search didn't produce anything to refute my memory). |
Subject:
Re: Does a prism refract all electromagnetic waves?
From: guzzi-ga on 12 Mar 2005 19:43 PST |
Yea you?re right xarqi. Well, there is actually certain interaction between magnetic fields and electromagnetic waves but not relevant to the question. And though puffin88 you were not completely correct, it was with such grace :-) Regarding the question though, prisms do affect other wavelengths -- if the material is appropriate. Transparency of a material above a certain frequency is determined by a quantum definition, ?the plasma frequency?. There are other factors which prevent transparency at various frequencies but it?s quite a big subject. Germanium, a black opaque element, is used for infra red lenses. In theory it could be used as a prism but the chromatic dispersion is low so it?s not very good. Certain plastics are used for microwave lenses, often in the form of fresnel (aka incorrectly frenel) and look like miniature lighthouse lenses. There are better ways to split microwave frequencies though. Best |
Subject:
Re: Does a prism refract all electromagnetic waves?
From: siliconsamurai-ga on 12 Mar 2005 22:25 PST |
Thank you for the nice rating and the tip. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |