![]() |
|
|
| Subject:
Responsibility and ignorance
Category: Miscellaneous Asked by: archae0pteryx-ga List Price: $2.02 |
Posted:
12 Mar 2005 15:35 PST
Expires: 11 Apr 2005 16:35 PDT Question ID: 493475 |
I found these lines in a notebook I was about to throw away: ====== With knowledge comes reponsibility. Yes, and without knowledge comes the responsiblity of ignorance. If you don't know, you should shut up. And if you do know, you should be careful what you say and how you say it. ====== These were followed by a quote attributed to Bohr: "You should never talk more clearly than you think." My question: is the remark about the responsibility of ignorance a known quotation by somebody? Who said that? Did I? I don't know if I copied it from somewhere or it came out of my own head. Did I write it down because I thought of it or because I agreed with someone else's thought? If it was mine, I can use it freely, but if it was someone else's, I should credit it. It's not like me to copy down quotes without credit (e.g., the Bohr remark), but stranger things have happened. Thank you, Archae0pteryx |
|
| There is no answer at this time. |
|
| Subject:
Re: Responsibility and ignorance
From: myoarin-ga on 12 Mar 2005 19:33 PST |
Hi Tryx, sounds like my kind of note taking in college: only made sense later if I could remember what happened. Could your note have been a quotation of what the Prof or whoever said? I like the one by Bohr, though it is hard to think that one could talk more clearly than one could think. Politicians seem to come pretty close, but then they're trained or experienced "say nothing experts". Best, Myoarin |
| Subject:
Re: Responsibility and ignorance
From: archae0pteryx-ga on 12 Mar 2005 20:14 PST |
Thanks, Myoarin, good guess, but not a college notebook. College is far, far behind me, but I am never without a notebook. I do a lot of jottings of story and article ideas, thoughts-for-thought's sake, curious questions (some of which wind up here), and all kinds of other stuff. And when I hear something or read something that I take down, I usually record the source and, if pertinent, the date. Otherwise the comments are usually my own. This, as it happens, sounds like something I might say, but not the way I'd say it, making me think that I copied it from somewhere--maybe even a waiting-room magazine or a line in a movie. The note about Bohr is unverified. I have certainly heard people whose clarity of expression made the fuzzy illogic of their thinking unmistakably obvious to anyone who was listening well. Tryx |
| Subject:
Re: Responsibility and ignorance
From: myoarin-ga on 13 Mar 2005 06:21 PST |
Tryx, And you throw away such notebooks?! You must be either absolutely desperate for space - or for something to burn. Since you keep notes all the time, you probably are pretty conscientious about noting the source of such a statement (eg, Bohr's, Oh, you said that too), so I would give you credit for have developed the statement about ignorance. But what are we commentors all going to do if we follow it?! Or ;-) ... is that what you are suggestiong? Reminds me of a cartoon 45+ years ago, "The Girls" (middle-aged ones), in which one of them remarks: "How do I know what I think until I have heard what I have to say?" UNfortunately, there is a great big kernel of truth in that: how often have I discovered the answer to something after I started to describe the problem to someone else! Sloppy thinking - not being able to formulate the problem in my own mind without using my mouth. It runs in the family (if not universal): my aunt told me that she had gone to my grandfather for help, and told him all about the matter, and then thanked him for his helping in solving it, to which he replied: "I didn't say anything. You came up with the solution yourself." To get back to the question: Sometimes we are not as ignorant as we assume, just haven't got our thoughts and the knowledge we do have properly sorted. (But you've got to me credit for that, if you use it! ;-D Happy Sunday. Myoarin |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
| Search Google Answers for |
| Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |