![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Hebrew - Right to Left
Category: Relationships and Society > Cultures Asked by: yuvalniv-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
14 Mar 2005 14:19 PST
Expires: 13 Apr 2005 15:19 PDT Question ID: 494626 |
Why Hebrew is written from right to left? |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Hebrew - Right to Left
Answered By: websearcher-ga on 14 Mar 2005 14:29 PST |
Hi yuvalniv: Thanks for the interesting question! The prevailing wisdom on why Hebrew (and Arabic) are written right to left has to do with the fact that they started out as languageg that were chiseled on stone tablets and the mechanics of holding the chisel in the left hand and hammering with the right lead to the right to left orientation. The best explanation of this I found was at: Welcome to the Question Bag! Question #29: Why Write from the Right? URL: http://www.questionbag.com/viewQuestion.asp?questionID=44 Quote: "Hebrew is an ancient language, at least 4,000 years old! We don?t know for sure, because none of us lived then, but we do know that long ago, people didn?t have the readily available pens and paper we have today. Anything that was written down was actually chiseled out of stone or written in clay... So what does this have to do with the way a language is written? Well, although I haven?t chiseled anything out of stone lately, my brief research indicates that if you are right handed (as the majority of us are), it is more natural and easier to be precise with the motion of chiseling a language from the right. A modern example would be hammering a nail into the wall. You (providing you are right handed) hold the nail with your left hand, and hammer with your right. This ends up giving you more accuracy." Other similar answers can be found at: Biblical Hebrew E-Magazine - October, 2004 URL: http://www.ancient-hebrew.org/emagazine/008.html The Jewish Agency for Israel: FROM RIGHT TO LEFT URL: http://www.jafi.org.il/education/jewish/right.html Search Strategy (on Google): * "right to left" hebrew reason * "right to left" "why is hebrew" I hope this helps. websearcher |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Hebrew - Right to Left
From: myoarin-ga on 14 Mar 2005 15:10 PST |
websearcher certainly answered the question from those sites, but I just don't believe people started written language by chiseling. They had to have a written language first, or one like the ancient Egyptians (which way does it read?) Before you go to the effort chiseling stone, you already have a system of symbols or letters and a full-blown writable language. Maybe they started on pads of clay, which was certainly used - cuniform (and which way do those texts read?). And then we know that the earliest Greek texts - chiseled ones - went like a snake, right to left on one line and left to right on the next, and so on. There is a word for it, as I remember, it's Greek for "the cow's path", but I won't trouble to find it. But that sort of demonstrates what I have said: they had a written language before they started chiseling, and they - right handers in the main - for a while managed to chisel in both directions, rather crudely, as I remember from pnotos. It would be interesting if one could recognize better work going one way. But, whatever, the Greeks settled on left to right for everything, and they are certainly more noted for leaving chiseled texts than the Hebrews or Arabs are. It is really a very interesting question, also relating to Chinese and Japanese, but I think (?) Tibetan is written left to right, and Sanskrit also (?). So, with all respect, I think the answer has not really gotten to the source. |
Subject:
Re: Hebrew - Right to Left
From: marcdrogin-ga on 14 Mar 2005 22:03 PST |
Most sources agree that scripts first manifested themselves on clay and papyrus written with brushes and rigid tools. Stone carving was the result of lettering brushed across stone in paint and then the shapes chiseled into the stone. In fact the purpose of carving was to be able to paint the letters in a recessed area that would protect the paint from the environment. Of course by now the elements have long-since removed any trace of the original painting. Commenter myoarin-ga is correct. The earliest alphabetical writing was done not left to right or right to left, but in a continuous stream first in one direction and then on the next line back the other way. It was a pattern any ancient farmer would recognize had he a field, a plow, and an ox. The paleographical term for this pattern is "boustrophedon" which in Greek means "as the ox turns." Not only did the lettering go in both directions but the shape of the letter was often turned around depending on which direction the scribe was writing. And in those early days there was neither space between words or punctuation because few could write and read -- and those who could didn't need the help of spaces or dots. Why Europe later chose to give the ox a rest and write only left to right isn't really known. From my studies which indicate that there was always a preference for time-saving and convenience, it seems odd that a scribe reaching the end of a line would choose to lift his pen and cross all the way back across the wax or clay tablet or sheet of papyrus before continuing his writing. Nor do I know why Semitic scripts, chose a reverse direction. But stone-carving was an end result of scribal choices and not the reason for the way, or the direction, in which we used to write. I rest my ox. |
Subject:
Re: Hebrew - Right to Left
From: myoarin-ga on 15 Mar 2005 02:48 PST |
Hey, thanks marcdrogin-ga, I was hoping someone tell me the word. Boustropheden, boustropheden, ... Maybe I can remember it now, maybe use it to describe soneone's meandering argument ... For me, it seems pretty logical for righthanders on clay or papyrus to quickly begin starting each line at the left so they can see what they are writing, especially as they wrote faster and their letters or cuniform symbols adapted and were symplified to facilitate faster writing. But that doesn't get us any closer to an answer to the question - unless the Hebrews and Arbas were all sinister ... pax xaq pax |
Subject:
Re: Hebrew - Right to Left
From: mr_me-ga on 16 Mar 2005 10:39 PST |
This doesn't help the questioner, but it is worthwhile knowing that according to Jewish tradition the Hebrew language is divine. Meaning it was created by G-d and was used in forming the world. I like the question anyway, but I thought it would be interesting to throw thatinto the pot. Mr_ME |
Subject:
Re: Hebrew - Right to Left
From: bozo99-ga on 05 Apr 2005 17:12 PDT |
Besides languages from that part of the world have more curvy letters as convenient for writing in sand as compared to scratching on rock. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |