|
|
Subject:
Sport’s Physics
Category: Science > Physics Asked by: fdelaflor-ga List Price: $30.00 |
Posted:
08 May 2005 07:13 PDT
Expires: 07 Jun 2005 07:13 PDT Question ID: 519149 |
I am interested in learning about the power producing capacity of athletes. What is the maximum power (watts) an athlete can produce/deliver? and for how long can he/she maintain that power output? I would greatly appreciate some examples. |
|
Subject:
Re: Sport’s Physics
Answered By: hedgie-ga on 06 Jun 2005 19:14 PDT Rated: |
Mammals, including humans, developed ability to expend burts of energy, and in the comment dialog it was placed to the range of few kilowats. Thinking of evolution, hitting, throwing, fencing and jumping may be the activity which would show what people had actually acomplished. Nomally sustained activities, we know range from 100 to several hundred watts. To consider theoretical limits for sustained we would have to turn to study of Bioenergetics and perhaps look at performance of animals, who after all are using same type of 'motor' - muscles fuled by APT and producing lactic acid. You will get into issues such as: ...Intense, sustained movements, such as running a 400 m race (in a young, healthy adult or youth) are dependent upon, not only the phophagen system, but largely upon a slower pathway of ATP production, glycolysis, and to a much smaller extent, the slowest pathway of producing ATP, oxidative phosphorylation. As the duration of maximal effort work is sustained, the absolute power output will decline as there is a shift in the energy system that is most dominant in resynthesizing ATP.. http://www.exercisephysiologists.com/Bioenergetics/ Please do note the references at the bottom. (Yes, I am giving reference to a book, ather then straight answer, and I am willing to withdraw the answer, if this is not useful). To estimate ehat acrually the muscels can sustain, we may turn to migrating birds. Migratory flighs can last daya and use 130kJ/d according to this http://www.princeton.edu/~wikelski/Publications/2003Nature.pdf That performance is apparently limited by amount of energy stored in fat: Diet selection and selective metabolism of lipids play important roles in determining the fatty acid composition of birds which, in turn, affects energetic performance during intense exercise. http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/links/doi/10.1111/j.0908-8857.2004.03378.x/abs/ I recall a lecture which put performance of migratory birds at the top of what animals can sustain. They had special type of muscles for that, lrcturer said. It would have to be scaled up by muscle mass of course. He also said that humans have these muscles only in the 'vocal cords' :-) As an example of peak power deliverable by muscles scientist studied grasshopper jumps: http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/~wjh/jumping/legsprng.htm Some numbers for humans (jumping, swimming ..) afre here: HUMAN PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE I. BASIC METABOLISM A. Energy Budget 1 ... ... a) total power expended by cyclist, P , 3 \Theta 10 ... ANAEROBIC EXERCISE A. Jumping 1) vertical leap and high jump. a) legs can support about 3 times ... www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/ sanjoy/oom/1997/lecture-notes/body.ps It also says, efficiency of human motor is about 25% - that gives you one limit you can rely on: energy expended per day cannot exceed energy of the foof intake What we can digest (particularly when running and jumping all the time) is also limited. Hereare few more books (not all good stuff is on internet yet) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/sim-explorer/explore-items/-/0781725445/0/101/1/none/purchase/ref=pd_sxp_r0/102-1914899-4442519 http://www.sciencedaily.com/cgi-bin/apf4/amazon_products_feed.cgi?Operation=ItemLookup&ItemId=0781725445 Hope this helps Hedgie | |
| |
| |
|
fdelaflor-ga
rated this answer:
and gave an additional tip of:
$5.00
Hedgie, the references you cited in your answer, opened a different and unexpected path to my research. Thank you very much. |
|
Subject:
Re: Sport’s Physics
From: dr_alexp-ga on 19 May 2005 16:59 PDT |
To Answere this Question you first need to difine power, and what Work is, and the relation ship between power and work. and i am presuming this Athleate is a Runner. Power= Work done / Time Taken Work Done = Force X Distance you can the define force as Mass X Acceleration (Newtons 2nd law) Now lets Consider a 100m Sprinter of mass 80kg. and asumes he runs in 10 seconds. The runners Speed, (speed = Distance / Time = 100m/10s = 10m/s )NOTE: THIS IS AVERAGE SPEED, THERE IS A PHASE AT THE START OF THE RACE WHERE THE RUNNER WILL BE ACCELERATING. In order to find the force wee need to know the acceleration. Using SUVAT equasions of motion we have. S=100m U=0m/s v=10m/s a=? t=10s using S=ut+(.5)at^2 = S= (.5) at^2 (we lose ut because 0 x 10 =0 ) therefore 100= (.5)a 10^2 Rearange to find a= 2 ms-2!! (Please note: ACCELERATION OF 2MS-2 IS THE AVERAGE ACCELERATION! TO FIND THE EXACT VALUSE OF THE ACCELERATION INTERGRATION WOULD HAVE TO BE USED. HOWEVER SINCE THIS IS JUST TO GET SOME FIGERS I WILL NOT BOTHER WITH THE COMPLEXITY) Force = Mass x Aceleration. (newtons 2nd law) = 80kg x 2ms-2 = 160N (remember average force = 160N, again intergration would be used to find exact maxima and minium values) Work done = Force x Distance = 160 x 100m = 16,000J Power = Work done / Time taken = 16,000J / 10s = 1,600 watts.!! So there you have it, please remember this answere is a roungh estimation, however it is faily accurate, If you are intrested to know how much power a 1500m runner can produce or the work done, somply follow the last method but entering the figers that are realtied specfically to the 1500m runner. If you keen to know the power of a swimmer, then this is a highly complex process takinging into consederation Fluid mechanics, Hydro dynamics and viscus drag effects. However it's more simple to work out power put out for Javlin throwere, or shott putters, or even long jumpers. Please contact me if you require such infomation, I hope this Helps you. Alex Peacock ( Mechanical Engineering Undergratuate BEng) |
Subject:
Re: Sport’s Physics
From: fdelaflor-ga on 21 May 2005 04:56 PDT |
Alex, thank you very much for your comment. Your approach is simple and produces a good approximation of power. I agree with the physics logic of your proposed solution. In your sprinter exercise, the power produced by the 80 kg athlete would be 1,600 watts or 20 watts per kilogram of mass for 10 seconds. I offer a couple of additional examples from a different sport (Reference: ?Toward an Understanding of Power? by Patrick O'Shea, EdD.) In power-lifting, muscle force is required, but power output, as measured in watts, is low in comparison to that generated in Olympic-style lifting. Lets compare the power generated by the world record lifts made by two former world champions, power-lifter Doyle Kenady and weightlifter Alex Pisarenko. Kenady, with a body weight of 140 kilograms, executed a 405-kilogram dead lift. Approximately two seconds was required for him to lift the bar and weight 0.40 meters off the floor and stand erect for a total of 794 watts. Pisarenko, with a body weight of 120 kilograms, executed a 265-kilogram clean. It took him 0.90 seconds to clean the weight and stand up. The bar and weight traveled 0.90 meters from the floor for a power of 2,597 watts. In comparing the power values of the world record lifts made by these former champions, we see that Pisarenko's 265-kilogram clean generated 21.64 watts per kilogram of body mass, and Kenady's 405-kilogram dead lift produced only 5.57 watts per kilogram of body mass. Yet the original question remains unanswered: What is the maximum power (watts) an athlete can produce/deliver? and for how long can he/she maintain that power output? My hypothesis is that the human body -as a machine- has certain power limit; And most probably, we can find this limit in the performance of world class athletes. It seems humans can transform larger amounts of energy in very short times as explosive power ? for a fractions of a second. What is that Peak Power? |
Subject:
Re: Sport’s Physics
From: dr_alexp-ga on 21 May 2005 14:38 PDT |
Ok, This is an Interesting concept you have here. I have studied A-level Physical Education and have a good understanding on what you are trying to achieve. However Please appriciate I am now Engineering and i will do the best of my physics knolege to help you. I am sory i will not be able to come up with an answer to your question, however i certainitng think there are points for you to think about. Initially looking at these results you have told me ( 21.64 W/kg and 5.57 W/kg) Initially it looks surprising That the Man who lifts the heviest weight has the lowest power output. HOWEVER: there are Three Factors affecting his total avereage power output. (Time period, Distance lifted, and mass lifted) Basic Conceps: Work Done against gravity: = Mass x Gravitatinial force x change in height. (m.g.h) By putting in the numbers for the txt you have given me. (Takeing gravity at 10ms^2) Kennedy :(m.g.h) 450 x 10 x .40 = 1,800J Pisarenko: (m.g.h) 265 x 10 x .9 = 2,385J So by doing this calculation elimiates the suspition on why a man who lifts a heiver weight has a lower power output. and the simple reason for that is there is a difference in height!! Pisarenko altho much lights is doing more WORK (against gravity) altho lifing a lighter weight he is lifing it much higher. And Remember Power = Work done / Time taken Kennedy : 1,800/ 2 = 900W Pisarenko: 2,385 / 0.9 = 2,650J Therefore, Kennedy is doing less work! and taking longer to do it. therfore his power rating is less. Pisarenko: Doing lots of work (against gravity) and also doing it in a shoter period of time. In my honest opinon i think it would be scientifically unfair to use these results to calculate the maximium power output!! both athleates are doing two different seperate events. This i know does not answer your question tho. I sorry i am no help there. however i hope my sujesstions are worth some thought. Also, to calculate the maximium power output would be a lenghtly process (i presume) you would need to correlate lots of data and then find an average and presume this is the maximium power a human can produce. it will most definitely will be in a POWER even and not long distance. I would be interesting to see Kennedy and Pisarenko to do the exact same event and see how their time, to lift the mass differs. Unfortunately i believe you need these varibles to be the same: ( Mass Lifted, Hight Lifted.) time will not be the same between the two atleates (maby it will), and the difference in time will be the deciding factor of the power. then once you know the power, you will be able to find the power to weight ratio. I hope this helps you. when you do fimd an answer please do let me know. i will be interested to here form you. Alex |
Subject:
Re: Sport’s Physics
From: myoarin-ga on 11 Jun 2005 18:31 PDT |
One way to get an idea of the answer would be to find results of athlete testing on ergometers, especially for rowing, which probably allows the use of the most muscles. Here is one site that I found: http://home.hia.no/~stephens/eliteerg.htm Since I don't know anything about it all, I cannot comment on the information. You can find many other sites that might also be of interest with a search: ergometer watts OR joules Myoarin |
Subject:
Re: Sport’s Physics
From: hedgie-ga on 30 Jun 2005 07:49 PDT |
fdelaflor-ga Thank you , for the tip and for the kind words Hedgie |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |