|
|
Subject:
Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
Category: Health Asked by: atrax-ga List Price: $15.00 |
Posted:
20 May 2005 07:28 PDT
Expires: 19 Jun 2005 07:28 PDT Question ID: 523690 |
A family member is convinced that she suffers from mercury poisoning, specifically in the area of brain function. Several years ago she lived in a small apartment (one large room plus bathroom) for about nine months. When she moved in, a standard household thermometer broke and she never found the mercury. My Question: Can that type of exposure to the amount of mercury in a household thermometer affect a person's brain function or cause any other health problems? Yes or No. If Yes, I'd like evidence to support that answer and information about possible treatments. If No, I'd like evidence to support that answer so I can put her mind at ease. If there are differing opinions on this issue, I'd like to see real evidence from both sides. Thank you. |
|
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
Answered By: websearcher-ga on 20 May 2005 08:43 PDT Rated: |
Hi atrax: [Please bear in mind that Google Answers Researchers are not doctors and do not give out medical advice.] My research on this question has lead me to the answer "yes - your family member could possibly have contracted mercury poisoning from this broken thermometer". Now, that doesn't necessarily mean that any brain disfunction of which she complains *was* caused by mercury poisoning - only that under the circumstances you list, mercury exposure could have occured - *and* that such exposure *could* lead to brain disfunction. In looking for your answer, I stuck with the most authoritative sources. I found the following at the Environment Protection Agency (EPA) of the U.S. government: Mercury Poisoning - How to Protect Your Family URL: http://www.mitoxic.org/pcc/mercurypoison.html Quote: "When products containing mercury break, the mercury can evaporate, creating a risk of dangerous exposures to mercury vapor in indoor air. Moreover, exposed mercury in the home or in the waste disposal system enters the environment and can be deposited in lakes and rivers, where it can be transformed into a highly toxic version of mercury called methylmercury. ... However, if the consumer fails to clean up mercury either because he or she is unaware that it has broken or because it is difficult to gain access to the mercury (for instance because it has seeped through a carpet), then the mercury will eventually volatilize and might reach dangerous levels in indoor air. The risks increase if the consumer attempts to clean up a mercury spill with a vacuum cleaner, or if the mercury is heated for some reason. The danger of significant mercury exposure is greatest in a small, poorly-ventilated room." Your relative couldn't find the spilled mercury, probably tried to clean it up incorrectly and thereby evaporated even more of it, and was in a small space with the mercury over a period of time when it might have evaporated. The same site also lists this valuable information: Is any exposure to mercury harmful to people? URL: http://www.epa.gov/mercury/faq.htm#5 Quote: "The factors that determine how severe the health effects are from mercury exposure include: * the chemical form of mercury - elemental (metallic), inorganic compounds, or organic compounds * the dose -- how much * the duration of exposure -- how long * the route of exposure -- eating, breathing, injecting, touching * other chemical exposures * the specific characteristics of the person - age, health" Another page has this to say: Mercury Exposures in Nevada URL: http://www.epa.gov/region09/cross_pr/childhealth/mercury-nevada04.htm Quote: "All mercury spills, regardless of quantity, should be treated seriously. Metallic mercury slowly evaporates when exposed to the air. The air in a room can reach contamination levels just from the mercury in a broken thermometer - just a few drops. When liquid mercury is spilled, it forms droplets that can accumulate in the tiniest of spaces and then emit vapors. Health problems caused by mercury depend on how much has entered your body, how it entered your body, how long you have been exposed to it, and how your body responds to it. The symptoms of mercury poisoning can include: * impairment of peripheral vision * disturbances in sensations - that "pins and needles" feeling as well as numbness - usually in the hands feet and sometimes around the mouth * lack of coordination of movements, such as writing * impairment of speech, hearing, walking * muscle weakness * skin rashes * mood swing, memory loss, and mental disturbances" Given that your relative is no longer in the apartment where the exposure might have took place, there is no point getting into methods for safely cleaning up such a spill. However, I found some not-so-promising information about testing and treatment for mercury poisoning: Medical Encyclopedia - Mercury URL: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/002476.htm Quote: "Severity of symptoms and long-term effects are dependent on the amount of exposure and the time to treatment. It is important to be evaluated by a physician for any suspected mercury exposure. Mercury causes neurologic effects, including irritability, developmental delay, or psychosis." Medical Management Guidelines (MMGs) for Mercury (Hg) URL: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/MHMI/mmg46.html Quote: "What tests can be done if a person has been exposed to elemental mercury? Specific tests for the presence of mercury in blood and urine can be useful to assess the level of exposure. If a severe exposure has occurred, x-rays and blood and urine tests might show whether or not the lungs and kidneys have been damaged. Testing is not needed in every case." Given that the exposure was years ago, there are fewer treatment options avialable. Please have your relative tested for mercury poisoning - that is the only real way to rule out (or rule in) whether mercury poisoning occurred. If it did, then their doctor can give you a list of treatment options that are appropriate to the case. Search Strategy (on Google): * "mercury poisoning" thermometer * "mercury poisoning" thermometer site:.gov OR site:.edu * "mercury poisoning" treatment * "mercury poisoning" treatment site:.gov * "elemental mercury" treatment site:.gov I hope this helps! If you have any further questions after your relative is tested, please let me know. Keeping my fingers crossed for you. websearcher |
atrax-ga
rated this answer:
and gave an additional tip of:
$5.00
Websearcher, Thanks for your prompt and thorough response. While I was hoping for a negative answer, it's good to know the facts from reliable sources. In this case the exposure occured about 7 years ago. The apartment was not carpeted; but I see that mercury can scatter widely when dropped on hard surfaces. She discovered the broken thermometer in a laundry basket. So it probably contaminated her clothing as well. She just recently associated her symptoms with the event. Unfortunately, she doesn't have health insurance. So if anyone knows of free or low cost programs to test or treat people for mercury poisoning, I would appreciate any comments. The exposure in this case was |
|
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: websearcher-ga on 20 May 2005 11:04 PDT |
Hi atrax: Thanks for the kind rating, comments, and tip. I really hope that your relative doesn't have mercury poisoning - it sounds very nasty. As for free or low-cost testing, it would help if we knew what city/state/country you were in so we can search for solutions near to you. websearcher |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: pinkfreud-ga on 20 May 2005 11:14 PDT |
If it will put your family member's mind at ease, most fever thermometers no longer contain mercury. If the thermometer was broken as recently as 7 years ago, the likelihood is that it was not a mercury thermometer. |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: atrax-ga on 20 May 2005 12:17 PDT |
Websearcher: She is in Ann Arbor, Michigan, home of the University of Michigan hospital. Pinkfreud: Thanks for the commment. Unfortunately, the thermometer had belonged to her grandmother and could have been decades old. |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: myoarin-ga on 20 May 2005 18:03 PDT |
Okay, that has to be the information that any responsible source gives, and the answer to the situation is proper testing for mercury poisoning. But, when I was a kid (dad had made a barometer), I played with mercury, rubbing it on dimes (then silver), making them shine - real physical contact, and no one has suggested that I am not normal mentally. Furthermore: the rotating lenses in lighthouses (big circular glass constructions) were - or still are - supported by mercury in a U-shaped circlar ring, the smaller ring bearing the lenses floating in the mercury. Lighthouse keepers would have all been "mad as hatters" if the risk had been as great as the sites suggest. The "mad hatter" in "Alice in Wonderland" was indeed a subject of mercury poisoning, since it was used in the felting process, but at temperatures that really created vapors. Here is another site on the subject: http://www.cdc.gov/nip/vacsafe/concerns/thimerosal/faqs-mercury.htm#2 Has your family member had symtoms of mercury poisoning since that time? Is there any information on symptoms occurring much later? |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: atrax-ga on 21 May 2005 05:51 PDT |
myoarin: I did the same things you did with mercury as a child, rolling it around, coating coins with it etc. It was fun stuff. And I never felt worse for it. That's why I was initially skeptical about mercury poisoning. But some of the links provided here show that elemental mercury is not generally harmful to the skin. You can even swallow it and the stuff is so slick that it just passes through your body without damage. The real danger, it seems, is from breathing in the vapors over a long period of time. You and I didn't even know there were vapors and, fortunately, our exposure was brief. Maybe lighthouse keepers WERE affected by mercury. They lived very isolated lives and no one ever brought them together to study. In my relative's case, I think the exposure may have intensified some personality characteristics that were already present as well as adding new ones. But things developed slowly and I don't think there was a specific point in time that anyone noticed a sudden change. I'm still hopeful that someone can find leads on free or low-cost testing and possible treatment. Thanks to all. |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: linezolid-ga on 26 May 2005 11:49 PDT |
It is unlikely that this family member is suffering from the effects of mercury poisoning. Essentially, one can have either acute toxicity (from a large one-time exposure, as is the potential in this case), or chronic toxicity (from prolonged, low-level exposure, such as hatters in Victorian England, as mentioned above). Also, mercury can be in one of three forms, elemental (as in batteries or thermometers), inorganic (i.e. fixatives and processing agents), and organic (i.e. insecticides). Elemental mercury must be inhaled to be absorbed. In this case, since your family member did not get sick, she did not have a significant acute mercury exposure. Since she did not break a thermometer weekly for the last 7 years, she does not have chronic mercury poisoning. In any case, she does not appear to have symptoms of mercury poisoning (although you do not specify what her symptoms are, mercury poisoning is, as the researcher mentioned, very nasty, and would affect more than one body system, i.e. more than just a few memory problems). Following are the symptoms of acute and chronic elemental mercury toxicity: "Elemental Mercury "The two organs most vulnerable to elemental mercury inhalation are the lungs and the brain; the blood-brain barrier is readily penetrated. Elemental mercury ingestion is considered benign because systemic absorption is unlikely.[15] The exceptions are in patients with intestinal problems such as diverticulosis, fistula formation, or obstruction, where mercury may be trapped or retained in the gastrointestinal tract for a prolonged period of time. This allows bacteria to convert the elemental form into organic mercury which can be systemically absorbed.[11] [31] Aspiration of elemental mercury, however, may cause a severe pneumonitis and even result in respiratory failure.[18] Subcutaneous injections of elementary mercury may also allow continuous absorption leading to chronic toxicity.[48] Similarly, intravenous injection can lead to sequestrations in the lungs causing both acute and chronic toxicity. "Acute Toxicity "Acute toxicity from elementary mercury vapor may be quite consequential. Concentrated elemental mercury vapor exposure can cause acute bronchitis, bronchiolitis, and pneumonitis. Clinical manifestations may include cough, fever and chills, dyspnea, metallic taste, and headaches. Severe cases may progress into hypoxia and respiratory failure.[24] Acute encephalopathy and seizures may develop from concentrated exposures. Elementary mercury aspiration[18] and intravenous injections can lead to a severe pneumonitis and embolization of the pulmonary vasculature,[17] respectively; both conditions may lead to hypoxia. With sufficient systemic absorption, acute renal toxicity manifested by proteinuria, nephrotic syndrome, and acute renal failure may occur.[15] "Chronic Toxicity "With prolonged or chronic exposure, the classic features of mercury toxicity are frequently encountered: tremors (intentional fine tremors with coarse shakes), oral cavity lesions (gingivitis, stomatitis, cheilitis), rash, salivation, headaches, diaphoresis, and erethism. Erethism is a constellation of signs and symptoms, including shyness, emotional lability, nervousness, insomnia, memory problems, and inability to concentrate. Peripheral sensorimotor neuropathy, dysarthria, and parkinsonian symptoms are frequently associated with chronic elementary mercury toxicity.[15]" Source: Ford, MD et al., Clinical Toxicology, 1st ed, W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, 2001. |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: myoarin-ga on 26 May 2005 17:25 PDT |
Linezolid, That is what I was hoping someone could provide. Thanks. |
Subject:
Re: Mercury Poisoning from a Broken Thermometer?
From: ts4u-ga on 10 Jul 2005 12:03 PDT |
You can find a simple home test kit and possible attempt to cleanse your body go to evenbetternow.com also you may look into HBT chamber after the cleansing. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |