Request for Question Clarification by
pafalafa-ga
on
24 May 2005 17:21 PDT
Hello Robin,
I've been looking into your question and I've managed to turn up some
information on Marjorie O'Shaughnessy. However, the information I
have poses a bit of a mystery, and I'm not sure what to make of it.
Perhaps you can shed some light on the situation.
The 1930 Census contains a record of an O'Shaughnessy family in the
Bronx, NY which is almost certainly the family you asked about. The
family members are listed as:
William O'Shaughnessy, father
Margaret A O'Shaughnessy, mother
Also in the house are two daughters, Dorothy and Marjorie, and one
Francis J. Clark, listed as the brother-in-law.
So far, things seem to fit the information you have already. The
parents are Meg (Margaret) and Will(iam). Sister 'Duggy' is Dorothy
and Francis J. Clark is the 'John Clarke' of your family history.
The Census also has other information, such as occupations, place of
parents' birth, marital status, age, etc.
And it's this other information that throws in a bit of a monkeywrench.
First off, are the ages given: Will - 45, Margaret - 43, Dorothy -
23, and Marjorie - 2. According to the Census, Marjorie was only two
years old in 1930, which makes it unlikely that she "attended the Arts
Students League" just a few years later, or ran a bookstore in the
early 1940's. There's also quite a gap between Marjorie's and
Dorothy's ages, which cry out for some sort of explanation.
Also, Francis J. is listed as a brother-in-law (rather than a
son-in-law) and is also listed as single, as is Dorothy. He's also
considerably older than Dorothy, as his age is given as 58 (perhaps
Francis J. has a son, John, who comes into the family picture later
on).
I also checked the rather grimly-named Social Security Death Index
that shows the following record:
==========
Name: Marjorie Oshaughnessy
SSN: 120-18-2868
Last Residence: 07042 Montclair, Essex, New Jersey, United States of America
Born: 7 Feb 1909
Last Benefit: 07042 Montclair, Essex, New Jersey, United States of America
Died: Oct 1979
State (Year) SSN issued: New York (Before 1951 )
==========
This also appears to be your Marjorie O'Shaughnessy, especially given
the Montclair, NJ connection for her residence, and the fact that her
SS number was issued in NY.
But note the birth date! February 7, 1909, which would make her about
20 years older than the Marjorie O'Shaughnessy identified from the
Census records (much closer to Dorothy's age, in fact).
There's no obvious explanation of this (although one possibility is
that the Census records made a simple error, and got the age wrong).
I just wanted to run by what I've found thus far, and get your feedback.
What do you think?
pafalafa-ga
P.S. Google Answers cannot provide personal information on private,
living individuals. Even if I could track down current descendants of
Marjorie, I don't think I'd be able to post the information here.
Please keep this limitation in mind.