Google Answers Logo
View Question
Q: Replacement and repair of peroneal tendons of ankle ( Answered,   2 Comments )
Subject: Replacement and repair of peroneal tendons of ankle
Category: Health > Medicine
Asked by: nemo717-ga
List Price: $200.00
Posted: 09 Aug 2005 13:55 PDT
Expires: 08 Sep 2005 13:55 PDT
Question ID: 553717
I suffered a complete rupture of both the peroneus longus and peroneus
brevis tendons of my right ankle.  The surgeon spoke of replacing one
or both with tendons derived from a cadaver.  However, in the surgery,
he opted only to clean scar tissue from the peroneus longus, and to
attach the peroneus brevis, which had a gap of several inches, to both
ends of the peroneus longus.  The result has been unsatisfactory: I
have no "push-off" strength and the ankle is curling towards the
inside due to insufficient tension in the peroneus longus.  Who would
be the best surgeon(s) in the U.S. to re-do this surgery, hopefully
reconstructing both the peroneus longus and peroneus brevis?
Subject: Re: Replacement and repair of peroneal tendons of ankle
Answered By: welte-ga on 10 Aug 2005 20:41 PDT
Hi nemo717-ga, and thanks for your question.

Having recently badly sprained my own ankle, I feel your pain, so to
speak.  First, let me say that the following is no substitution for
medical advice or direct evaluation by a physician.

Complete rupture of both the peroneus longus and peroneus brevis
tendons is rare and likely resulted from a significant mechanism of
injury.  This would be categorized as a Grade III sprain - the most
severe type.  As you've learned, these types of injuries often require
surgical intervention for stabilization of the lateral ankle, as well
as casting or bracing initially.

First, let me give you a little more background:

There are several common surgical procedures that can be performed
when these tendons are completely disrupted.  The specific surgery
performed depends on the details of the injury, the anatomy, surgeon
preference and experience, and characteristics of the patient (e.g.
elite athlete, child, elderly, etc.).  From what you describe, it is
likely that your surgeon performed either the Watson-Jones or Evans
procedure, detaching the remainder of the peroneus tendon and suturing
(attaching) it to the body of the peroneus longus muscle.

A picture of the anatomy would probably be helpful at this point.  You
can find a very good labeled diagram from

As you can see, the peroneus longus and brevis run together around the
outside of the ankle and are often injured at the same time.  As an
aside, you can also see that they both attach to the lateral portion
of the 5th metatarsal in the mid-foot - one reason that this bone is
sometimes fractured in severe ankle sprains.

You can find a succinct description of the various surgeries employed
after disruption of the peroneus longus and brevis tendons here Curtin
University of Technology in Australia:

The four primary surgeries are Watson-Jones, Evans, Nilsonne, and Lee.
 The details can be found at the site above.

The Watson-Jones and Evans procedures don't recreate the normal
anatomy of the ankle, but are thought by some to increase the
stability of the ankle over the other procedures.  This may be why
your physician elected to go in this type of direction.  If your ankle
had a severe degree of instability, he/she may have thought it better
to increase the stability rather than strictly recreate the anatomic
relationships of an uninjured ankle.  In other words, recreating the
normal anatomy may actually cause a decrease in stability over what
you have now, depending on your precise injury and exactly what type
of procedure your physician performed.  The correct choice of
procedure would also depend, as I mentioned above, upon your activity
level, age, etc., as well as the amount of scar tissue that may have
formed due to both the injury itself and the surgery.  There are
numerous other procedures available to you at this point, including
harvesting other tendons for reconstruction of the peroneus tendons or
cadaveric repair, as you mention in your question.

As one eMedicine article states,
"Surgical therapy: According to a 1999 review by Safran, Zachazewski,
and Benedetti, more than 20 different delayed surgical procedures are
available for chronic ankle instability and sprains. Most of these
procedures are reconstructive in nature and frequently involve
tenodesis between the lateral malleolus and calcaneus, talar head,
and/or the fifth metatarsal. All of these procedures use the peroneus
brevis and/or longus, Achilles tendon, or fascia lata [a covering on a
muscle in the thigh]. None really restore true anatomy."

More details can be found in this review article by Drs. Baumhauer and O'Brien:

"Anatomic repair of the lateral-ligament complex supplemented with the
Gould modification has become the preferred method of surgical
treatment, with an 85% to 95% success rate. This approach provides
increased stability through the reinforcement of local host tissue;
preserves subtalar and talocrural motion; has fewer associated nerve
injuries and less morbidity associated with the harvest of tendon
grafts; and provides a quicker functional recovery.
Ankle-reconstruction procedures that sacrifice tendons to be used as
donor tissues are thought to provide a theoretically stronger
construct and, hence, more stability. This increased stability can
result in loss of talocrural and subtalar range of motion and lead to
prolonged recovery and decreased sports performance."

The free full text article is available here:
Baumhauer JF, O'Brien T.  Surgical Considerations in the Treatment of
Ankle Instability.  Journal of Athletic Training 2002;37(4):458?462.

All that being said, it is particularly important that you be
evaluated by a competent orthopedic surgeon before embarking on any
re-operation for either reconstructive, reparative, or other
procedure.  In that vein, I will turn to recommendations for surgeons.
 You do not state whether or not you have a geographical preference,
so I will stick to those orthopedic surgeons across the US who may
best be able to help you.


Although there are limitations in their rankings (primarily due to the
inclusion of some subjective factors such as reputation), US News and
World Report ranks several departments within hospitals around the
country every year, including orthopedic programs.  Their ranking
system includes such factors as facilities, staff expertise,
reputation, number of cases, etc.  Any program on this listing is a
top rated department and this may help you initially to find a
physician located geographically near you.  This may be important for
post-surgical follow-up, etc.

You can find their rankings for orthopedic surgery programs here:

Any of the programs on this list would be a very good start.  I have
also researched additional specific physicians who specialize in foot
and ankle surgery with some geographic spread so that you have some
choices for consultation.  These physicians are among the top in the
area of foot and ankle surgery, often serving on editorial boards of
major journals and holding academic appointments in recognition of
their accomplishments and abilities.  Contact information for each
physician may be found at the link that follows each.


One of the top-rated programs for orthopedic surgery is the
Massachusetts General Hospital at Harvard Medical School.  Their
department has an ankle injury program, which you can find here:

This program is run by the following three physicians:

James Donald Heckman, MD

Richard J. deAsla, MD

George Harry Theodore, MD

Contact information for these three physicians is available at the
links above.  All are listed as accepting new patients.

Another possibility in the Boston area is Dr. Michael Wilson at the
Faulkner Hospital / Brigham & Women's Hospital.  He also specializes
in foot and ankle surgery and actively participates in academic
medicine.  Here is his contact and bio information:,%20M.D.&D=Orthopedics&CI=ankle%20surgery,%20foot%20surgery&OP=5200&NP=Yes&L=No%20Data%20Available&PT=Specialist

Dr. Jeffrey E. Johnson, M.D., at Washington University in St. Louis,
is another accomplished specialist in the area of ankle
reconstruction.  You can find his contact and biographical information


Dr. Judith Baumhauer at the University of Rochester, a co-author of an
article I cited above, is a well known specialist in ankle surgery. 
She also serves on the Editorial Board of Techniques in Foot and Ankle
Surgery.  She is the Director of the University of Rochester Foot and
Ankle Surgery program.  You can find her contact information and
biographical information here:


In North Carolina, the Miller Orthopedic practice has been around for
over 75 years and has several well known orthopedic surgeons who
specialize in foot and ankle reconstructions, with some focus on
athletes.  Several of their surgeons are senior editors of major
journals in the area of foot and ankle surgery.  Their two most
experienced surgeons are:

Dr. W. Hodges Davis

Dr. Robert B. Anderson

Miller Othopaedic Clinic recently merged with Charlotte Orthopedic
Specialists, but the above contact information should remain valid. 
Here's a link to the merger site:

Here's a link to the original Miller Orthopedic site, with further
contact information:


At the Ohio State University Dept. of Orthopedic Surgery, Dr. Berlet
is well known and specializes in foot and ankle surgery.


At Duke, Dr. Mark Easley specializes in Foot, Ankle, and Knee surgery.


Todd Kile, MD, Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, Arizona.  Subspecializes in
trauma reconstruction.


Dr. William McGarvey at the University of Texas is an Associate
Professor and ankle/foot specialist.

Dr. Charles Saltzman, University of Iowa

Dr. Brian G. Conley, Cleveland Clinic.  Associate Editor of Foot and
Ankle International.  Specializes in sports injuries of the foot and

Dr. Anthony Watson, Drexel University, West Penn Allegheny Health
System, Pittsburgh, PA.

Dr. Lowell Wiel of the Weil Foot and Ankle Institute, Des Plaines, Illinois

Dr. Richard Ferkel of the Southern California Orthopedic Institute, UCLA

Dr. E. Greer Richardson, Campbell Clinic, Memphis, TN. 
Editor-in-Chief of one of the primary journals in the field, Foot &
Ankle International.


I hope this information is useful and I wish you the best in your
recovery.  Please feel free to request clarification or request
additional physicians for a more specific location.

Subject: Re: Replacement and repair of peroneal tendons of ankle
From: ed777-ga on 10 Aug 2005 13:57 PDT
Check for information about the prices and
quality of medical services in other countries which can cost 1/20 of
the U.S. price and the quality is equal, better, or worse depending of
the provider you pick in the U.S. or the other country. You can
consult with doctors in various countries while at home via
Telemedicine and get their expert opinion with little or no cost.
Subject: Re: Replacement and repair of peroneal tendons of ankle
From: ftbear-ga on 11 Aug 2005 18:36 PDT
A friend of mine asked me to comment on your question. 
My answer. 

Keith Wapner MD in Philadelphia. Office 215-829-3668

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  

Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy