![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Lord Acton quotation
Category: Reference, Education and News > General Reference Asked by: sjoli-ga List Price: $10.00 |
Posted:
18 Aug 2005 08:56 PDT
Expires: 17 Sep 2005 08:56 PDT Question ID: 557265 |
Lord Acton, the famous 19th-century historian of liberty, is quoted as having written that liberty ?was that which *was not*, until the last quarter of the eighteenth century in Pennsylvania.? [Isabel Paterson, *The God of the Machine* (1943; Caldwell, Idaho: Caxton Printers, Ltd., 1964; 2nd prtg, 1968), 305] I have never been able to find where Acton wrote that. Could you provide me with a citation? Please provide enough information so that it would not only be findable but also "footnote-able." If you think he did *not* write that, please let me know why you think so (your credentials, your search methods, or whatever you think makes your answer definite). Thank you, Steve Jolivette |
![]() | ||
|
There is no answer at this time. |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Lord Acton quotation
From: raketemensch-ga on 24 Aug 2005 03:56 PDT |
The phrase doesn't seem to exist in any of Acton's writings or lectures; a search for the phrase (on the web, exact phrase in quotes) returns only one result, where it is given with no citation. This doesn't necessarily mean that he didn't SAY it, of course...there's always the possibility that it was a comment not written down but spoken, and recorded by someone else. However, the lack of any more contemporary reference rather leads one to suspect that the attribution was spurious; it's quite common for quotations to be falsely attributed to famous figures, especially when it SOUNDS like something the person would or "should" have said. It does, however, seem not too far from the following (from a lecture delivered in 1877, "On The History of Liberty in Antiquity": Liberty, next to religion has been the motive of good deeds and the common pretext of crime, from the sowing of the seed at Athens, 2,460 years ago, until the ripened harvest was gathered by men of our race. It is the delicate fruit of a mature civilization; and scarcely a century has passed since nations, that knew the meaning of the term, resolved to be free. In the above passage, the "nations that...resolved to be free" referred to are obviously the United States and France; this comes closest, in spirit, at least, to the quotation you're inquiring about. |
Subject:
Re: Lord Acton quotation
From: sjoli-ga on 24 Sep 2005 19:23 PDT |
Thank you for the comment, raketemensch-ga. Actually, I take it as an answer. If you are a Google Answers Researcher, please post it as as an answer and take my payment ($10, if I remember). |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |