This agricultural extension site,
http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/guilford/newsarticles/root.html
gives an evaluation of two commonly used chemicals and another
evaluation of powder vs. liquid formulations (no quantitative
evaluation of how much more effective one might be than the other).
"There are many auxins that can be used to stimulate adventitious
rooting but the two that are used most often commercially are
indolebutyric acid (IBA) and naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA). In fact,
both these auxins, either alone or in combination, are the active
ingredients in most commercial rooting formulations although IBA is
more effective for a wider range of species.
Commercial rooting products are generally available in two major
formulations/preparations. The first of which consists of one or more
auxins dispersed in a talcum powder carrier (e.g., Hormodin,
Hormo-Root, Rootone, etc.) and the second consisting of one or more
auxins dissolved in a solvent (e.g., C-mone, Dip 'N Grow, Wood's
Rooting Compound, etc.)."
...
"Individuals will often ask which formulation (powder or solution) is
most effective for rooting cuttings of various species. Although both
formulations have advantages and disadvantages and can provide
satisfactory results if used properly, the solutions are generally
more effective for various reasons. The powders are best used on stem
cuttings of herbaceous (nonwoody) plants (e.g., coleus, chrysanthemum,
and geranium), woody species which are not difficult to root (e.g.,
boxwood, Japanese holly, and forsythia), and softwood cuttings of
woody species which are relatively easy to root (e.g., Atlantic white
cedar and 'Green Giant' arborvitae)."
This site below gives some general tips on rooting techniques:
http://www.oznet.ksu.edu/dp%5Fhfrr/hnewslet/2004/ksht0406.htm |