|
|
Subject:
Concrete RV Pad
Category: Family and Home > Home Asked by: mortleadz-ga List Price: $20.00 |
Posted:
03 Oct 2005 17:59 PDT
Expires: 02 Nov 2005 16:59 PST Question ID: 576008 |
I had a contractor pour me a concrete pad on the side of our house for parking an RV. He promissed a 4" pour with rebar. Instead of doing what he said he would he poured 3-1/2" with no rebar. Will this suffice or do I need to have it redone? |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: Concrete RV Pad
From: cynthia-ga on 03 Oct 2005 18:57 PDT |
I know you are asking if the 3 1/2" with no rebar will hold the RV, but contracturally speaking, I'd get a new one. What you have received is undoubtedly worth far less than what you paid for and did not get. |
Subject:
Re: Concrete RV Pad
From: mortleadz-ga on 03 Oct 2005 19:32 PDT |
Cynthia, I agree with you. The only other option I am considering is maybe getting a discount or having the contractor do other work pro bono in place of a discount. If the 3-1/2" concrete will hold (it has wire even though rebar was promised) a decent sized motorhome, I would be willing to work something out with the contractor. |
Subject:
Re: Concrete RV Pad
From: belron-ga on 04 Oct 2005 09:38 PDT |
Not really any hard facts but looking at these two sites, there are recommendations of 6 inches for the slab. If only four inches is used, you need rebar. http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:GdYjx6BG02MJ:www.rv.net/forum/index.cfm/fuseaction/thread/tid/16100604/gotomsg/16171069.cfm+concrete+slab+rv+%22requirements%22&hl=en http://www.absoluterv.com/concrete-foundation-requirements.htm |
Subject:
Re: Concrete RV Pad
From: myoarin-ga on 04 Oct 2005 15:28 PDT |
There is no question that you received unstisfactory work, hopefully with a contract that specified the 4" with rebar, but even if you only have a oral contract (just your word against his), he was offering the minimum allowable und the Uniform Building Code. Here is the Wisconsin UBC, but "uniform" means that the state code has been adapted to agree with a nationwide standard, so your state's code is probably very similar. http://www.biasew.org/WUBC-REGS-2005-R.pdf Scroll down to age 18 for garages, and you will find that 4" and wire mesh are required. He will probably argue that he meant wire mesh when he said "rebar" and might claim that the pad really is 4" everywhere except where you have checked. Your pad is probably going to crack. If you live in an area with ground frost, you will probably have more problems. The guy may have skimpt on the groundwork too. If you can live with the potential problems, you could get hold of the UBC and talk to a construction inspector, and then first argue that he has to redo the job or you will report him. After that, it depends on how good you are at bargaining with someone who may have experience with complaints. But if you know that the law is on your side, you can always go back to insisting on a proper job. Personally, I agree with Cynthia. Substandard work should not be condoned. Besides, one day you will probably want to sell the place, and a cracked pad with grass in the cracks will not only detract optically, it will suggest that other construction elements of the house could be substandard. |
Subject:
Re: Concrete RV Pad
From: perkins4108-ga on 17 Oct 2005 02:36 PDT |
Cynthia, You have some great comments here, especially myoarin. The loads of a motorhome may crack the pad, but if the soil is stable and the ground doesn't freeze, it may sit there for years. Some things might really make a mess, however. The soil preparation prior to casting the slab is important. The soil should be stripped of all organic material and some attention should be given to the flow of surface water on the site. The concrete may "heave" due to expansive soils, very common in North America, and this truly looks tacky. One may never get much action from a concrete contractor for a project like this, any replacement would be very expensive compared to the size of the original work. I suggest contacting the fellow, stating your concerns, emphasize the warranty aspect of most contractor's agreements, park the RV, watch the slab for a period of less than one year, but through a wet or freezing cycle. If there is a problem in the first year, contact the fellow to discuss the situation. Some slabs like you described would last until we were all long gone, if on the right soils and not subject to frost or soils heave. Some slabs would need to be 6 inches or greater with elaborate rebar inclusion to resist problematic soild behavior. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |