![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Linguistic, Phonetics
Category: Relationships and Society > Cultures Asked by: hava-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
14 Oct 2005 03:30 PDT
Expires: 13 Nov 2005 02:30 PST Question ID: 580156 |
A question to linguists: All languages I know contain sounds made by exhaling air. Are there languages with sounds made by inhaling air? What languages are they? (My reason for asking the question: My 2 months old grand daughter emits both exhaled tones (like goo, coo, arrrr) and inhaled tones.) |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
Answered By: tlspiegel-ga on 16 Oct 2005 23:44 PDT Rated: ![]() |
Hi hava, Thank you for a very interesting question. Project ADEPT Introduction to Speech and Hearing - Dr. Pamela Broadston http://www.ualr.edu/adept/videoscript.htm "Speech is either produced on the inhalation of air which is the ingressive or the exhalation which is the egressive air. Most English sounds are produced on the exhalation of sound. Many other languages actually have sounds that are done on the inhalation. [edit] "Other languages such as African languages have a sound that is produced on the inhalation." ========= Languages of the World - Xhosa http://www.nvtc.gov/lotw/months/september/xhosa.html "Consonants Xhosa has a complex system of consonants, including consonants that occur only in southern Bantu languages, including the following:" [edit] "implosive /b/ produced by inhaling rather than exhaling the air" ========= Languages of the World - Swahili http://www.nvtc.gov/lotw/months/september/swahili.html "Sound system The phonology of Swahili is characterized by a relatively small number of vowels and consonants. Among the unusual sounds are implosives, i.e., sounds that are produced by inhaling rather than exhaling the air." ========= Wikipedia - Implosive consonant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ejective Implosive affricates and fricatives are extremely unusual. Imploded affricates occur in Kung-Ekoka and Hendo (a Bantu language). Several Central Sudanic languages, such as Mangbetu, have implosive labiodental fricatives, which are "strongly imploded, the lower lip briefly pulled back into the mouth". Voiceless implosives are found in languages as varied as the Owere dialect of Igbo in Nigeria, Krongo in Sudan, and some dialects of the Quiche language in Guatemala, but they are quite rare. The IPA has removed its earlier dedicated symbols for them, so now the bilabial voiceless implosive is transcribed as [??]. (Owere Igbo has a seven-way contrast among bilabial stops: [p p? ?? b b? ? m].) Implosives are commonplace among the Sub-Saharan African languages, are widespread in Southeast Asia, and are found in a few languages of the Amazon Basin. They are rare elsewhere, but do occur in scattered languages such as Maidu and the Mayan languages in North America, and Sindhi in the Indian subcontinent. They appear to be entirely absent from Europe and Australia, even from the exotic Damin, which uses every other possible airstream mechanism." ========= PEOPLES AND LANGUAGES IN PRE-ISLAMIC INDUS VALLEY http://asnic.utexas.edu/asnic/subject/peoplesandlanguages.html "John Bordie, using linguistic evidence of loss of certain words per thousand years, suggests that Sindhi and Punjabi separated between A.D.750 to 1400 and that the implosives of the Sindhi language 'came into existence prior to A.D. 1400 and subsequent to the separation of Sindhi from the mass of related languages.'95 Since Siraiki too has implosive sounds, it too may have become a separate language around this period. But Siraiki shares its vocabulary, or at least a major part of the core vocabulary, with Punjabi so that the present writer is unsure whether Siraiki is a sister of Punjabi which picked up some features of the Sindhi sound-system (phonology) or a sister of Sindhi which picked up Punjabi words as Grierson suggests." ========= Hausa consonant sounds (Northern Nigeria) http://www.humnet.ucla.edu/humnet/aflang/Hausa/Pronunciation/consonants.html "Hausa has 23 to 25 consonant sounds, depending on the speaker. Click on the Hausa words written in red in the table below to hear words illustrating each sound. Click on the blue comments for further information. [turn on your speakers] click on the red word babewa for 'quarreling'. click on the red daidai word for 'one at a time' ========= search: personal knowledge (my brother is consulting with me on hundreds of languages around the world) keywords: african languages inhale air language speech inhale air implosive speech languages implosive consonant ========= Best regards, tlspiegel |
hava-ga
rated this answer:![]() Dear tlspiegel, Thank you for the interesting and enlighting answer. I appreciate the scolarly style, the references to websites helped a lot. your answer supported my guess, that there must be such languages, but added facsinating facts to my knowledge. |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
From: senatus-ga on 16 Oct 2005 21:46 PDT |
The phonetic reference chart that is the standard is the IPA (International Phonetic Alphabet) which contains a symbol for every known sound in world language. Babies are known to make all the sounds on the chart at random during their early development, they then lose those as they find the ones they actually need. The IPA can be viewed at http://www2.arts.gla.ac.uk/IPA/images/ipachart.gif -- The sounds you are looking for are bottom left of the top chart and are labeled, "Consonants (Non-Pulmonic)" The sub category you want is "Voiced Implosives" You can find them in a number of languages, the most well known being Swahili, Thai and the Kru family of languages. A number of exstinct or nearly extinct American languages have it as well. Mayan and some of the others in the Amazon basin for example. The only continents it is entirely absent from are Europe and Australia (Thus European languages like English/Spanish/etc do not have this sound regardless of their geographic location). Hope this helps -- --SENATUS |
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
From: myoarin-ga on 17 Oct 2005 15:31 PDT |
Hava-ga, Let me point out to you as a first time user, that was an "overprice" answer for a two dollar question! As the search explanation indicates, Tlspiegel just happens to be very familiar with your interesting subject. Lucky you! And, TL, thank you from me for such an interest answer. In European languages we do have two implosive sounds that are commonly used, but in words: the kiss - contradictly described as "blowing a kiss - and the actual sound that is described in writing as "tut tut", an implosive T. In Turkish and perhaps in some related languages, a negative reply is expressed with an implosive with the tongue touching the palate while one raises one's chin, the gesture that gives rise to the saying that in the Orient people nod their head instead of shaking it when they mean "no". Who knows, maybe our "tut tut" is entymologically related. Myoarin |
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
From: hava-ga on 18 Oct 2005 02:32 PDT |
Thank you senatus for your comment and the phonetic reference chart. Thank you myoarin for the addition about European languages. Middle east languages (Arabic and Hebrew) also have an implosive "tsu" with the tongue touching the front teeth or front palate, for a negative answer (sometimes with a nod of the head, depending on nuances of the meaning of the answer). May be it is a Turkish influence from the period of the Turkish Empire, which this area was part of until world war I. In Israel an implosive "h" is used for expressing alarm or surprise, like discovering you forgot something important, etc. Do other languages or cultures have it too? I think that in French, the word "oui" (meaning "yes") is sometimes uttered by inhaling in certain contexts. May be someone familiar with French can elaborate on this. Best regards Hava |
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
From: tlspiegel-ga on 18 Oct 2005 10:15 PDT |
Hi hava, Thank you for the 5 star rating, comments and very generous tip! Best regards, tlspiegel |
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
From: myoarin-ga on 18 Oct 2005 18:45 PDT |
Hava, Or maybe the "tsu" is Arabic, picked up by the Turks. Of course, not just in Hebrew do people gasp with an implosive H in those situations - and a few others - but to me that seems more a reflex, but there are words that can be voiced both ways, a common four letter explative that can also be gasped if one is inclined to use it. In English (other European languages?), the "cluck" to encourage a horse is also an implosive "tch" or some variant, sometimes also used to immitate chipmunks or squirrels. Very interesting. We can do it, use implosives, but it is not a part of our formal language. Regards, Myoarin |
Subject:
Re: Linguistic, Phonetics
From: senatus-ga on 18 Oct 2005 21:13 PDT |
I actually spent some time in college doing French Phonetics, so I'll add a comment on that one -- "Standard French" (that is, the French spoken in the French Academy) does not contain any implosive sounds. Standard French has fewer sounds than English and is very regular with them. That isn't to say that there are not non-standard dialects out there, like with English there are many. I've been to France, Canada and spoken with a number of French speakers in Africa and have never actually heard anyone use an implosive in their speech. If you wanted to find that, you'd probably have the best luck searching in the Southern part of French speaking Africa. That region might have preserved the sound from its native languages and transferred it into French after the colonization. Just a guess... |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |