|
|
Subject:
Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
Category: Science > Math Asked by: samirhc-ga List Price: $10.00 |
Posted:
10 Nov 2005 16:27 PST
Expires: 18 Nov 2005 12:23 PST Question ID: 591681 |
I need the solutions to two questions from the GRE Subject Test: Mathematics practice booklet. One relates to differential equations and the other analysis. They should be simple for anyone versed in math (and I know Google's got alot of Math Ph.Ds, something I'm hoping to start this coming year). This is word for word from the Math Subject Test Practice booklet available from the ETS website 54. The inside of a certain water tank is a cube measuring 10 feet on each edge and having verticle sides and no top. Let h(t) denote the water level in feet above the floor of the tank at time t seconds. Starting at time t=0, water pours into the tank at a constant rate of 1 cubic foot per second, and simultaneously, water is removed from the tank at a rate of 0.25*h(t) cubic feet per second. As t->infinity, what is the limit of the volume of the water in the tank? A. 400 cubic feet B. 600 cubic feet C. 1000 cubic feet D. The limit does not exist E. The limit exists but cannot be determined without knowing h(0). 63. At how many points in the xy plane do the graphs of y = x^(12) and y = 2^x intersect? A. None B. One C. Two D. Three E. Four Again...I have the answers, I need to know how they were determined. Any help would be very much appreciated. |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 11 Nov 2005 18:04 PST |
I'm not a mathematician, so there's probably an elegant way to do this. My method is partly visual and partly analytical. For #63, there should be two intersections. Here is how I solved #63: If you think of graphing the functions, the two curves meet when they have the same y value for a given x. So, it they meet, x^(12)=2^x at that point(s) It helped me to graph these roughly, but I can only describe that here. y=x^(12) is like y=x^2 but rises much more rapidly (parabola-like). Y values are positive for all x except x=0 where y=0 (the shape should be somewhat like a squished parabola). 2^x is always positive. For x=0, y=2^x=1; for x>0 y is greater than 1 and curves upward; for x<0 y is between 1 and 0, steadily decreasing in value. The curve is shaped somewhat like a hyperbola intersecting the y axis at y=1; it decreases steadily in value in going from x=0 to large negative x values and increases in value in going from x to positive infinity. Intersection point 1: Since y=x^(12) is shaped like a parabola with a y value of 0 at x=0 and steadily increases to positive infinity as x goes from 0 (y=0) to minus infinity and since y=2^x decreases from 1 to zero steadily in the same negative x range), the two curves must cross once. Intersection point 2: For positive values of x, y=x^(12) increases more rapidly than y=2^x and the curves cross once. You can see that this point is between x=1 and x=2 if you roughly plot the values of the two functions. x y=x^(12) y=2^x 0 0 1 1 1 2 2 4096 4 No lemmas, no theorems, but this reasoning should give the answer. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 11 Nov 2005 18:55 PST |
I initially shied away from looking at #54, but I think I have the solution to that one too. Suppose the tank is initially empty; then no water is draining out at that instant but it is coming in a 1 ft^3/s. At this point, the water will start rising in the tank. Suppose the tank is full initially; water is leaving at 10 (0.25) ft^3/s and water is coming in at 1 ft^3/s. Hence, the water level will fall. Equilibrium will be reached somewhere in between -- when the rate of water removal equals the rate of water addition, that is, when 1 ft^3/s = 0.25 h. Solving for h gives a level of 4 feet, or 400 cubic feet in the tank. There is probably a way to solve this with differential equations, but I'll quit with the above. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Boo
From: ticbol-ga on 12 Nov 2005 04:14 PST |
For water tank..... The question says at any time t seconds, the change in volume of the water in the tank is 1 CF minus 0.25h, so, dV/dt = 1 -0.25h -----*** If a maximum V can be attained, then dV/dt at that time is zero, hence, 0 = 1 -0.25h h = 1/0.25 = 4 ft. That means when h=4ft, there is no more change in volume of the water in the tank, so, at h=4ft, V is max. Now, V = 10*10*h, so, max V = 100*4 = 400 CF ------answer. That means also that Vo is immaterial. If there were a Vo, and it were less than 400CF, then the h will rise and settle at 4ft. If Vo were more than 400CF, then the h will fall down to the 4-ft level and settle there. -------------------- For the two graphs....... There will be two intersection points, one at the 1st quadrant, and another at the 2nd quadrant, as seen from their graphs on the same x,y plane. If you want to solve for the intersection points, you can use the Newton's Method of iteration. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 12 Nov 2005 07:11 PST |
samirhc-ga, I need to correct an English mistake. I should not have used the term, "equilibrium," as it implies too much. I should have used "steady-state" or "approaching a limit." ticbol-ga, Thanks for the differential equation solution. I am enlightened. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: rracecarr-ga on 14 Nov 2005 10:58 PST |
You guys are correct about problem 54, but not about problem 63. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:03 PST |
I just did #63 again, this time using Excel to plot a number of points rather than the few points hand-one points and the general reasoning that I used before. As far as I can tell, there can be no more than 1 crossover point in the negative x range (x between -1 and -.09) and it sure looks like there can't be more than one crossover point in the positive x range (x between 1.05 and 1.1). If #63 is supposed to be purely analytical, I could see how you might get only one crossover point. Analytically, I think you could go through logarithms, and since logarithms of negative x are undefined (I think), you will get only one crossover point that way (the one in the positive x region). If the instructions restrict you to using such an analytical method only, then I could see how they got an answer of one crossover point. Can you give me a hint about the answer, that is, is it supposed to be more or fewer than the number of crossover points that we got (two)? Thanks! |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: rracecarr-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:06 PST |
There are three. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:06 PST |
Oops! I just noticed that today's first comment was not from the original questioner. rracecarr-ga, How do you know we are wrong about #63? Do you have the book or do you have a different solution? If you have a different solution, please share it with us. Thanks! |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: rracecarr-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:11 PST |
Well, I'm sure there is an elegant analytical way to show that there are 3 points of intersection. I haven't thought of one though. The intersection you are missing is near x=75. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: rracecarr-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:27 PST |
On (-oo,0), x^12 is monotonically decreasing and 2^x is monotonically increasing. Both are continuous, so since they must cross somewhere on that interval, there is exactly one intersection for negative x. For the positive solutions, take the log of both functions. x^12 becomes 12 ln x, and 2^x becomes x ln 2. Plugging in a few points near x=1 shows that there is an intersection in that region. The end behavior of the linear function (x ln 2) is to grow faster than the logarithmic function (12 ln x), so there must be at least 1 additional intersection. As both functions are continuous and differentiable on (0,oo), one is linear and the other has a second derivative that is strictly negative, there must be exactly one additional point. So three total. As I said earlier, this is messy. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:31 PST |
OK, I see a possibility between 76 and 77. To do that, though, I had to compare logarithms since the numbers were so large. Before, I was estimating that the y=2^x curve wouldn't bend upwards more than the y=x^(12) curve. To get the third point, I had to switch to comparing (12 log x) and (x log 2) because the numbers are so large. The original request was for how we got the answers. How did you go about solving the problem? Thanks! |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 14 Nov 2005 12:35 PST |
Our comments keep crossing. Thanks! |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 14 Nov 2005 13:39 PST |
rracecarr-ga, After a break, I took a look at your solution - very nice! Especially for showing that there is exactly one more solution. I'll probably never use this line of reasoning again, but this problem taught me something about making estimations too hastily and inferring too much from previous experience. I hope that samirhc-ga enjoyed this as much as I have. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: emoll-ga on 15 Nov 2005 07:26 PST |
Re #63: rracecarr's analysis is correct and elegant. I will only add some somewhat more precise decimal approximations for x to the ones so far put forth: x = -0.94678 x = 1.06335 x = 74.6693256 I got the first two from graphing x^12 = 2^x on the graphing calculator on my Mac. The last I got from running a short iteration program, using x = 12logx/log(2), on an old programmable computer. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: hfshaw-ga on 15 Nov 2005 13:34 PST |
Problem 54. The correct answer is A (400 ft^3) The differential equation expressing the time rate of change in the height of the liquid is: dh(t)/dt + h(t) * (0.25 *ft^3)/(100 ft^2) - (1ft^3/s)/(100 ft^2) = 0 This equation simply says that the rate of change in the height is equal to the volumetric rate at which water is entering the tank minus the volumetric rate at which water is leaving the tank, all divided by the cross sectional area of the tank (to convert volumes to heights). This is a linear first-order inhomogeneous differential equation. See <http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/math/deinhom.html#c1> for the straightforward method of solution. The homogeneous equation: dh(t)/dt + 0.0025 * h(t) = 0 has solution: h(t) = h_0 * exp(-t/400) where h_0 is the height of the water at t = 0 The particular (aka nonhomogeneous) solution is given by: h_p(t) = 0.01/0.0025 = 4. The complete solution is given by the sum of the homogeneous and particular solutions: h(t) = h_0*exp(-t/400) + 4 As t -> infinity, the exponential term goes to zero, and we are left with h(t-> infinity)-> 4. The volume is simply the height times the area: 4*ft* (100 ft^2) = 400 ft^3 As ticbol and brix indicated in their comments, another way to solve this problem without having to find the complete solution to the differential equation is to recognize that *if* the the height ever reaches a steady-state value, then dh(t)/dt must be equal to zero. (If it never reaches steady state, then one will encounter an expression that can never be true, when dh(t)/dt is set to zero, indicating that the assumption of the existence of a steady state was incorrect.) This converts the differential equation into an algebraic equation that can be solved with some simply algebra: dh(t-> infinity)/dt = 0 = -h(t) * (0.25 *ft^3)/(100 ft^2) + (1ft^3/s)/(100 ft^2) h(t-> infinity) = [(1ft^3/s)/(100 ft^2)]/[(0.25 *ft^3)/(100 ft^2)] = 4 ft V(t-> infinity = h(t-> infinity) * 100ft^2 = 400 ft^3 Problem 63. The correct answer is D, (three) The problem can be solved using the "Lambert function", (see <http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LambertW-Function.html>). The Lambert function is the inverse function of f(w) = w*exp(w), and is usually written as W(z). For any complex number z, z = W(z)*exp(W(z)). For real arguments, W is two-valued in the interval [-1/e,0). One branch has W>= -1, and is called the principal branch denoted W_)(z), and the other branch has W(z)< -1, and is denoted W_-1(z). The trick solving the type of problem at hand in terms of the Lambert Function involves manupulating the equation (in this case, x^12 = 2^x) into a form that involves something that looks like w*exp(w). Starting with the equation: x^12 = 2^x, take the twelfth root of both sides yields two equations: x = 2^(x/12) and x = -2^(x/12) Now divide both sides by 2^(x/12), noting that this expression can be written as exp(x*ln(2)/12). This yields: x*exp(-x*ln(2)/12) = 1 and x*exp(-x*ln(2)/12) = -1 Now multiply both sides by -ln(2)/12 to get: -[x*ln(2)/12]*exp(-x*ln(2)/12) = -ln(2)/12 and -[x*ln(2)/12]*exp(-x*ln(2)/12) = +ln(2)/12 The left hand side of these equations are of the form z*exp(z), where z = -x*ln(2)/12, so the solutions are given by -x*ln(2)/12 = W(ln(2)/12) and -x*ln(2)/12 = W(-ln(2)/12) x = -[12/ln(2)]*W(ln(2)/12) and x = -[12/ln(2)]*W(-ln(2)/12) Now, remember that on the interval [-1/e,0), W(z) is multivalued. -ln(2)/12 ~= 0.058, and -1/e ~= -0.368, so -1/e < -ln(2)/12 < 0, and the second equation above actually has two solutions, corresponding to the two branches of the W function. Writing these in terms of the principal and second branch terminology, the real three solutions are: x = -[12/ln(2)]*W_0(ln(2)/12) x = -[12/ln(2)]*W_0(-ln(2)/12) x = -[12/ln(2)]*W_-1(-ln(2)/12) |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: hfshaw-ga on 15 Nov 2005 14:57 PST |
Oh, yeah, numerically, the coordinates of the intersections turn out to be at approximately: (1.06334683, 2.08977386) {x = -[12/ln(2)]*W_0(-ln(2)/12)} (-0.94678033, 0.51878895) {x = -[12/ln(2)]*W_-1(-ln(2)/12)} (74.669325535, 3.00404713*10^22) {x = -[12/ln(2)]*W_0(ln(2)/12)} If one considers complex values for x, then there are actually 10 additional solutions. |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Boo
From: samirhc-ga on 17 Nov 2005 00:45 PST |
First, thanks to all of you for all your help. These problems were getting really frustrating. I wish I'd posted on Google Answers a little before 2 days prior to the Math GRE, but oh well. The exam itself went decent, but there's still some ground I need to cover before I'm entirely comfortable with all the fundemental material. Similarly, I need to be much more intuitive when approached with a problem. On second thought I wonder if I should've posted the answers with the questions I asked, but then, if anyone went to the ETS website to find a print copy of this test, the answers are also available there. rracecar-ga had the correct answers for both questions first. However everyone here was able to answer the Diff. Eq. question. One that, now, seems so simple I can't believe I overlooked the fact that the rate should be zero at equilibrium. hfshaw provided a great answer for the intersection problem (#63). The Lambert equation seems to fit well, and I'm sure there are other methods. I think the exam, however, is looking for the application of rracecar's intuitive concepts regarding the monotonicity of the functions and the functional behavior past x=50. I'll post some more, and hopefully get this tips thing figured out in a short while. Thanks alot for all your help, I very much appreciate it. Sincerely, Samir |
Subject:
Re: Differential Equations and Analysis?s from the GRE Math Subject Practice Booklet
From: brix24-ga on 17 Nov 2005 06:23 PST |
After all comments except Samir's latest one, I decided to see if I could google these types of problems for methods of solution. I was not very successful; I was trying something general like "fill empty 'steady state level'." I may have gotten a generic answer, but it was fairly abstract for me and difficult to relate to the problem at hand. I got plenty of tank discussions, but, to me, at least, nothing with the specific issue at hand. After Samir's comment "if anyone went to the ETS website to find a print copy of this test, the answers are also available there," I googled the following exact phrases from the problems, "certain water tank is a cube" and "At how many points in the xy plane do the graphs of y." However, I didn't pick up the ETS material (even though it's on the web). I did, though, get links to sites where both of these specific problems were discussed. Overall, I prefer the discussion here. Google wants to make the world's information available, but sometimes it's much more fun to think about something than just to look up how someone else solved the problem. Of course, if my thinking gets stuck, then seeing someone else's answer is helpful - which, I hope, is part of Google's goal. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |