|
|
Subject:
Ideas of god in a (distant) future
Category: Relationships and Society > Religion Asked by: nhsrikanth-ga List Price: $20.00 |
Posted:
18 Nov 2005 09:13 PST
Expires: 18 Dec 2005 09:13 PST Question ID: 594754 |
I am interested in web links that provide different theories on the status of "god" in a distant future (say 5000+ years later) when humans may have (will they?) achieved many of the abilities (like, say, every imaginable comfort, super human abilities, practical immortality) that we seek god's help in today's world. Though I have categorized this under religion for lack of a better category, I would prefer more of sites with objective imagination/analysis as against those that espouse a certain religious faith (however, not to exclude any extrapolation based on existing religious faiths). Thanks in advance. |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: boyo62-ga on 18 Nov 2005 10:28 PST |
A really brilliant question, I'll enjoy looking out for a possible answer. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 18 Nov 2005 10:33 PST |
Thanks for the compliment. I look forward to your answer. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 18 Nov 2005 10:43 PST |
Would prefer less than 10 (most relevant) links with a line of comment on what to expect in a given link. Thanks again. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: elids-ga on 18 Nov 2005 11:03 PST |
The belief in the supernatural, the concept of an afterlife, is a way for people to reconcile two distinctly contradictory facets of being human. First, being animals (albeit intelligent) we are in a very large part governed by our first instinct, that of self preservation. Second, since we are intelligent we realize that all animals die, so, we must too. The belief in an afterlife for us and all of it's ramifications, a god, a place for that god to live -heaven- a counter god and his dwelling etc (all together a religion) is simply a way to reconcile by explanation this two opposing traits of our humanity, you see, we die but not really. The concept of religion was the greatest leap forward for mankind ever. It was a valiant attempt at explaining our surroundings, ourselves and reconciling our intellect with our instincts, the best our primitive ancestors could came up with. It has an incredible mental leap for them, considering they were animals not too long before they started believing in an afterlife. Today we have explained most of our surroundings and we are educated, yet some of us choose to believe in an afterlife via their religion because it is something they are confortable with and most are simply not willing to face reality. However in time our society will be educated enough and most importantly mature enough to be willing to face reality and relegate the belief in the supernatural to that of their primitive ancestors (us). I imagine they will view us and our beliefs in an afterlife much in the same way we view our ancestors who believed the wind, fire and lightning were all manifestations of Gods, or the ones that were a little more educated and believed that the Sun and the planets were Gods, or the ones that were a little more educated and believed that God is an invisible Flying Spaghetti Monster... ohh no wait that is us... ;-) If we continue our technological pace forward religion will be history, if instead we move backwards and teach our children to believe in the supernatural then religions such as Voodoo, Christianity, Wican and many more will be around in one form or another. Just my opinion, Elí |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: pinkfreud-ga on 18 Nov 2005 11:10 PST |
You might be interested in a collection of science fiction stories called "Perpetual Light," edited by Alan Ryan. http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00005WLQO Here's a nice list of science fiction works which deal with religion: http://www.adherents.com/lit/sf_rel.html |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: joatman71-ga on 18 Nov 2005 14:42 PST |
Why would our view of God need to change? Isn?t God unchangeable? Perhaps our needs from him would change, but God would not need to. It sounds to me like in 5000+ years the human race could have some characteristics that are closer to God?s, but we will not be perfect. Will pain and suffering be gone? Will there still be crime? Will everyone be equal? Will children need to be raised? If not I think many prayers spoken today could easily be spoken 5000 years from now. If the future turns out to be a much more utopian society we would be thanking God a lot more than we do now. Could we exist in a society where everyone?s worth was the same? |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 19 Nov 2005 13:01 PST |
elids-ga, I am more interested in god than religion. Religions have much smaller lifespan than concept of god. There are many amongst who are agnostic or even theistic (without believing in a particular god projected by a particular religion). pinkfreud-ga, Thanks for the interesting link. I will look into it. joatman71-ga, Good opinion. Your opinion belongs in one school of thought. What I am looking at is for many such opinions that are more elaborately discussed and more vivdly illustrated. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: fisherofmen-ga on 22 Nov 2005 08:47 PST |
Jesus said in John 3.3 "unless you are reborn spiritualy you cannot SEE?" This means you cannot understand God in any way, and you cannot enter the Kingdom of God, without being Born again spiritualy. Man was seperated spiritualy from God in the garden through SIN, this is what keeps you in the dark spiritualy, you cannot have knowledge without Gods enlightenment. Seeing Yahshua, Jesus for who he is God incarnett, who made himself sin for you and me, showing His love for this fallen world. Repent of all your sins,turn from sin beleiveing on Him for forgiveness, and you will be (saved) and SEE!May God take the scales from you eyes.Mark |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 22 Nov 2005 11:52 PST |
fisherofmen-ga: Your kind of response I can do without. Which is why I added "those that espouse a certain religious faith" in my question. FYI, I can't care less about what Christ said to John I am not seeking god. Only theories of him. Again not of the present but of the future. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: boyo62-ga on 22 Nov 2005 15:30 PST |
I suppose that's why I found this such a brilliant question, nhsrikanth-ga, your desire to know what man's idea of God will be in +/- 5000 years time extends roughly equally far into the future, as the length of recorded history is behind us. I must confess to having no special knowledge of theology and the only theologians I have personally known were both uncles of mine, both Ministers in the church. Like almost all theologians, I must assume, both were only interested in theological events of the past. On the whole, and with few notable exceptions, I would tend to agree with the remarks made by Pinkfreud. I also believe that the kind of thinking that would interest you is mainly done by science fiction authors. The exceptions are nonetheless not to be ignored. Firstly I would mention someone you have certainly already heard of: Pierre Teilhard de Chardin: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Teilhard_de_Chardin His book, "Le Phénomène Humain", published only after his death, by decree of the Catholic Church, is a remarkable document in every respect. Secondly, the book "The Anthropic Cosmological Principle", written by John D,Barrow and Frank J.Tipler (ISBN 0-19-851949-4) casts a mathematically scientific eye on the question and arrives at conclusions remarkably similar to Teilhard de Chardin. Further information on Barrow is available at: http://www.isepp.org/Pages/03-04%20Pages/Barrow.html and Tipler has his own website at: http://www.math.tulane.edu/~tipler/theologian.html Now that we are halfway between the dawn of recorded history and the period of interest to you, I can only agree that theologians should spend more time on questions such as this. After all,by now we should all know how many angels can reasonably be expected to dance on the head of a pin!! ? |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: pugwashjw-ga on 25 Nov 2005 05:04 PST |
Lots of good opinions. But what does the Bible say. The very basis of our belief. Revelation 16;14,16 "14 They are, in fact, expressions inspired by demons and perform signs, and they go forth to the kings of the entire inhabited earth, to gather them together to the war of the great day of God the Almighty". 16 And they gathered them together to the place that is called in Hebrew Har?Ma·ged´on". God will wage war with the governments of the earth. Satan, the cause of all our troubles [Rev. 12;7-9,12 "7 And war broke out in heaven: Mi´cha·el and his angels battled with the dragon, and the dragon and its angels battled 8 but it did not prevail, neither was a place found for them any longer in heaven. 9 So down the great dragon was hurled, the original serpent, the one called Devil and Satan, who is misleading the entire inhabited earth; he was hurled down to the earth, and his angels were hurled down with him . 12 On this account be glad, YOU heavens and YOU who reside in them! Woe for the earth and for the sea, because the Devil has come down to YOU, having great anger, knowing he has a short period of time.? Then Jesus, with God's approval, steps in and locks up Satan for a thousand years, ridding the earth of his evil influence. Rev. 20;1-3 "20 And I saw an angel coming down out of heaven with the key of the abyss and a great chain in his hand. 2 And he seized the dragon, the original serpent, who is the Devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years. 3 And he hurled him into the abyss and shut [it] and sealed [it] over him, that he might not mislead the nations anymore until the thousand years were ended. After these things he must be let loose for a little while". While satn is locked up, 'abyssed', those righteous ones remaining on the earth, can grow to perfection and also work to bring the earth back into perfection also [ Psalm 72;16 There will come to be plenty of grain on the earth; On the top of the mountains there will be an overflow] At the end of the thousand years, Satan will be 'let loose for a little while' [ Rev.20;3 cited] as one last final test of peoples loyalty to God. And then God destroys Satan forever [ Rev 20;10 And the Devil who was misleading them was hurled into the lake of fire and sulphur, where both the wild beast and the false prophet [already were]; and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever. ] The 'wild beast' and the 'false prophet' are worldly governments and false religion. Organisations as such cannot suffer pain, so the torment must be to be nullified, made non-operational. And we know how governments love that!. Real TORMENT. sO WHERE ARE THE REMAINING RIGHTEOUS ONES?. They were promised that death and suffering will be done away with [Rev. 21;4 And he will wipe out every tear from their eyes, and death will be no more, neither will mourning nor outcry nor pain be anymore. The former things have passed away.? They are described in Psalms 37;9-11, 29 & 34 [ 9 For evildoers themselves will be cut off, But those hoping in Jehovah are the ones that will possess the earth. 11 But the meek ones themselves will possess the earth, And they will indeed find their exquisite delight in the abundance of peace 29 The righteous themselves will possess the earth, And they will reside forever upon it. 34 Hope in Jehovah and keep his way, And he will exalt you to take possession of the earth. When the wicked ones are cut off, you will see [it]. Without death, people will then live forever. And it will all take place within a short time from now. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 25 Nov 2005 12:11 PST |
boyo62-ga: Right on. You have exactly understood my question, an understanding which seem to elude fisherofmen-ga and pugwashjw-ga. Your reference to Pierre Teilhard de Chardin is interesting and is exactly how curent beliefs could be extraploated. I will be visiting the other two links as well, which are promising, after I browse through Pierre Teilhard de Chardin and his work. What I want is more of the same (but different schools of thought) if you can afford the time. In any case, go ahead and present it as answer so that I could compensate your efforts. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: boyo62-ga on 25 Nov 2005 15:04 PST |
nhsrikanth-ga: Sorry for the misunderstanding but I'm not a GA researcher, just an interested reader of Google Answers. The comment I made was not the result of any search work but rather the product of quite a bit of general reading, spread over the years. Which is the reason why I can't promise any additions, I'm sorry to say. Anyway, may I wish you every success in what looks like becoming an interesting quest!. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 26 Nov 2005 07:02 PST |
pugwashjw-ga, I re-read your comment and I apologize for lumping you with fisherofmen-ga. Yours is a lot more relevant than his comment in that it deals with future and god had predicted the future of mankind would be. Still, I am interested in what would be "human-kind's" concept of god in future and not in what god is supposed to have said would happen to humans in future (unless of course, you offer bible as a document that a bunch of humans concocted from what they believe to be god's word - which, I presume, based on your fervent belief, is not what you consider bible to be). boyo62-ga: Thanks for your generous help in my quest. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: pugwashjw65-ga on 28 Nov 2005 22:51 PST |
Thanks for the apology. But further to what I have already posted. You will note that none of it is of my own estimation. It is there in the Bible for anyone to read. It is not based on "feelgood" emotions. It is really ' nuts and bolts'. Jesus said that anyone who is not with him is against him and wuill be scattered. [ Matthew 12;30 & Luke 11;23]. When God instals his new system, EVERYONE left on the earth will really KNOW about Him and OBEY Him. Those choosing NOT to do so will be simply destroyed. Revelation 21;8 But as for the cowards and those without faith and those who are disgusting in their filth and murderers and fornicators and those practicing spiritism and idolaters and all the liars, their portion will be in the lake that burns with fire and sulphur. This means the second death.? To specifically answer your query. human-kind's view of God will be loving obedience to His peaceful ways, without any outside evil influence, either from Satan or any persons not prepared to obey. Certainly a different world to what we see today. Isaiah 9;. 7 To the abundance of the princely rule and to peace there will be no end, upon the throne of David and upon his kingdom in order to establish it firmly and to sustain it by means of justice and by means of righteousness, from now on and to time indefinite. The very zeal of Jehovah of armies will do this. This certainly is in the future. "And to peace there will be NO END |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 29 Nov 2005 07:21 PST |
Thanks for your follow up pugwashjw-ga. I will file that under Biblical school of thought. "Those choosing NOT to do so will be simply destroyed. Revelation 21;8 But as for the cowards and those without faith and those who are disgusting in their filth and murderers and fornicators and those practicing spiritism and idolaters and all the liars, their portion will be in the lake that burns with fire and sulphur." "human-kind's view of God will be loving obedience to His peaceful ways, without any outside evil influence, either from Satan or any persons not prepared to obey. Certainly a different world to what we see today." I don't know which of the two is more scary. Being floatsam in a lava river or being a god's pet puppy for eternity. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: pugwashjw65-ga on 30 Nov 2005 02:41 PST |
Back again. the 'Lake of fire', is not literal in this sense. It just means complete destruction, or doing away with, no no trace is left. If you did fall into a stream of lava, literally, there would be nothing to recover, or even indicate you had even fallen in. The concept is based on the burning pit outside the walls of Jerusalem that was kept continually burning for the disposal of dead animal carcasses and even the bodies of executed criminals. That it is not a literal scenario is shown by Revelation 20;14,15 [ . 14 And death and Ha´des were hurled into the lake of fire. This means the second death, the lake of fire. 15 Furthermore, whoever was not found written in the book of life was hurled into the lake of fire". Death and Hades are conditions. Verse 15 specifies people. Conditions cannot experience anything, but they can be eliminated. So too can people. Simply eliminated. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: fractl-ga on 30 Nov 2005 07:13 PST |
There are many biblical arguments here...but the bible (and more so, it's interpretation/translation) has changed VERY drastically with time. As is I question its accuracy, in another 5000 years I see it as being any bit as credible as a collection of fairy tales. One interesting question, though, is 'will people still follow it word-for-word'? Even now the bible is being cited to (ironicaaly) both support and oppose modern developments that could not possibly have been considered in the time of it's creation. Even if God knew the path humanity would take and included references to this future within the bible, I would assume interpretation would have lost any meaning. That tangent aside, my opinion is that major religions don't have much of a future left. Globalization no longer allows religion to thrive as it once did in areas untouched by conflicting theories of a creator. Religious law is being frowned on by the global community, and seems to be in recession. There is an argument that in the future (I can't find the estimated date) the majority of people in the world will be multiracial. Religion will see a major change as a result of this. I think in the end religion will lose its meaning. I don't see this taking 5000 years to happen, either; perhaps in as little as a few centuries. Religion and culture, as always, will go hand in hand. People will continue to celebrate holidays and make references to 'god' in their speech, but formal practice of religion is already in a very noticable decline. Consider the days when athiesm was a crime, and working on Sabbath was unthinkable...any religious rule that becomes inconvienient is dropped. People don't rely on God as heavily anymore, either. Since the discovery of modern medicine people have realized that prayers don't have nearly the healing power of a good drug, or a well-performed surgery. Science is giving people the answers religion used to be looked to for (and is contradicting many biblical 'truths' along the way). I doubt that feeling that there must be a greater cause, or that there is a hand guiding fate will ever leave the human mind. It helps us see ourselves as something more than a speck on a rock in an unimaginably large universe. The more we learn about the scale of the universe, the more I cling to the thought that theres a purpose to it all. Formalized religion may simply be replaced by personal philisophy. -Fractl This is 100% speculation, of course...for all I know Zeus himself will compete in the 2006 Olympics and make everyone a beleiver. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 30 Nov 2005 13:01 PST |
fractl-ga: My personal thinking is pretty close to yours. Which is why I sought to make a distinction between "god" and "religion". "I doubt that feeling that there must be a greater cause, or that there is a hand guiding fate will ever leave the human mind. It helps us see ourselves as something more than a speck on a rock in an unimaginably large universe." Very probable. In such scenario, what would be the capabilities associated with the guiding force ? Does the perceived capability of god change with capability of humans ? Also, What guidance we may seek from god, in the future, when the knowledgebase of humans could be considerable in itself. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: pinkfreud-ga on 30 Nov 2005 13:10 PST |
You might enjoy this old joke: http://www.wilk4.com/humor/humorm373.htm |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: guillermo-ga on 30 Nov 2005 19:36 PST |
Great joke, Pink ;) From a non-believer's viewpoint it makes a good metaphor of the Bible -- a culture's creation to give life to its God. I like Fractl's comment, mostly agree with it. However, I actually tend to imagine that in the future, people will rather reconcile with the idea of being just "a speck on a rock". I see human kind as an animal that long ago developed ingenuity as an adaptive resource for survival. Eventually, ingenuity developed into consciousness and our ancestors faced our constituent vulnerability, our loneliness, the innumerable mysteries surrounding our existence, the fact of our death. Out of that anguish, religion and the idea of god emerged as the shelter to protect themselves from it. In time, humans began to build other shelters that little by little replaced religion - medicine, science, philosophy as Fractl pointed out very well. It was hard to learn that the universe doesn't actually turn around us. It's being hard right now to understand that we may spoil the biosphere so that it won't keep us alive -- while some ecosystem would probably remain even though unsuitable for us. It will still be hard to go along with the idea of being just a tiny particle within a huge existence, and also a huge existence made of infinitesimal particles. So I imagine that as we reconcile with that idea, religion will be replaced by the hope of reaching a total knowledge through science. Then eventually - I guess - future mankind (if there'll be such) will end by understanding that the whole existence is just too huge for a complete knowledge and will accept that there'll always be more mystery than certitude. And that mystery, our acceptance of it, will be the closest that will remain in the future to what once was God and religion. Of course, as Fractl said, this is also 100% speculation. I've heard from a reliable source that Odin has decided to challenge Zeus in the Olympics and the loser will invite us all to a barbecue either at the Olympus or Valhalla ;) |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: myoarin-ga on 01 Dec 2005 05:03 PST |
Can Baal join the competition, Guillermo? (I have recently been rehearsing Mendelssohn's "Elias". It has a great chorus for the bystanders.) If it is going to be a test of fire-making, I have my money on Thor. ;) Myoarin |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: fractl-ga on 01 Dec 2005 07:09 PST |
I doubt fire-making is an Olympic sport (but hey, if they have curling why not?) Perhaps Thor could get into the opening ceremony at some point, but fire and winter olympics may not mix well. Who invited the Norse/Egyptian gods to the Olympics anyhow? |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: myoarin-ga on 01 Dec 2005 08:48 PST |
Zeus did. As the president of the original Olympic Committee, under a "grandfather clause" in the rules - which no one ever thought would be invoked - he may invite worthy non-members and define new sports disciplines, like that beauty contest which Paris judged. But, as you know, one of the girls cheated, so for a very long time there were no more female events. But seriously, I think Nhsrikanth raised a very interesting question, and I especially enjoyed Fratl's comment - quite my own opinion, and better expressed. Myoarin |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: techtor-ga on 01 Dec 2005 08:49 PST |
Following my belief, founded on the Christian Bible, I'd quote one very characteristic verse about God: "...the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever" (Heb. 13.8). Of course, while he reacts the same way, will always have the same opinions and behavior as before, 5000 years we'll see a different world... and who knows, by that time, we'll have a more established and tangible world relationship with Him. But I'd leave the really good theories to the sci-fi writers... |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: damonhoppe-ga on 08 Dec 2005 04:13 PST |
Interesting question...However it is premised on a false assumption that you are asking about mans relationship to God. 99% of people's idea of God is a false one, created by non-believers to decieve and manipualte people, what Marx called the 'opium of the masses'. Most religions texts actually speak of this state as being a sign of the end times... Okay, so if you have a correct understanding of God as the Absolute, inifinte and eternal that means man's relationship with God would be the same as it was in the dawn of religion. Thus even in 5000 years time and indeed 20,000 years time the problematic would remain. That is we are finite temporal 'beings' and therefore can never experince the infinte etneral 'Being' in an empirical or intellectual sense. Thus we will still have a philosophical and religous character to our existance, probably more so as I would expect false religion might well be gone...More fundementall religion teaches us that we can experince God in the religous sense (the sacred now, satori, etc) through mediation, devotional pray, etc... What is holding us back is the worhsip of Mammon (Capitalism - Money and Power). Persumbly in this 5,000 year future Marx's prediction of revolution would of become true, which means as Nietzsche declared the false 'god is dead' and the Ubermensch (Jesus) would of emerged. (The revolution of materiality is co-dependent on a revolution of consciouness). Man would be free from false consciousness produced by bourgoise control of the means of production and therefore able to become one with God....Excatly as predicted in the Book of Revelations... Until that time false gods would remain in abudance. Some people will worship 'a man in the sky', who they think listens to thier prays for more money and will speak of gods will...others will pray at the alter of money, worship celebrities and speak of market forces...others still will merge both into one religion and call themselves the Christain Right. So unfortuantly the nature of True religion will not have changed therefore making a boring hypothesis. SO the only issue is wether people still worship false gods are the One True God, which is to be found in ever religion. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: damonhoppe-ga on 08 Dec 2005 04:17 PST |
Actually that could make a good basis of a story. The very struggle of enlightened people against the false religions to bring God to the people despite the persecution that they face adn the false consciouness of those people... |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: fractl-ga on 20 Dec 2005 11:18 PST |
There are quite a few people who are under the impression they're living that story. |
Subject:
Re: Ideas of god in a (distant) future
From: myoarin-ga on 12 Jan 2006 14:12 PST |
I don't know what brought this question back to the top of the deck, but I'll take the opportunity to say that I think Fractl's last comment is very insightful. |
Subject:
boyo62 - Your Reference just won the Templeton award
From: nhsrikanth-ga on 15 Mar 2006 09:12 PST |
boyo62-ga : Your referred author John Barrow won the Templeton award for his work. Thanks again for your superb contributions to my question. |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |