![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
Category: Computers > Hardware Asked by: truescotsman-ga List Price: $50.00 |
Posted:
04 Dec 2005 08:08 PST
Expires: 03 Jan 2006 08:08 PST Question ID: 601245 |
Nuts I know, but bare with me. I'm wanting to set up an internet connection for my partner and I's flat. We live across the road from the University campus, which give free WiFi access to students, which we both are. However the wifi signals only just reach the front window of the building, no good for my partner wanting to surf the web in the back study. I devised a work around, where we have a pc attached to a high gain antenna, and then attached that PC to a ethernet network switch, which then goes into a Wireless Access Point. Using the Network Wizard on XP, i set the PC to an internet gateway, to the switch which then sent the internet signals to the access point, so my partner could use the net in the back bedroom, as well as sharing files between the Gateway PC and her laptop. The problem with the system is that obviously only works when the PC is on, and being a bit hefty it really chugs on the electricity bill. I looked into getting a wireless access point of the same make/model as the one used by the university itself, so i could set up a simple repeater, but that would have costed $4000, not exactly in my price range. :-s. And even if I did that I wouldnt have the same security of sharing files, as I would be using the university network, and not my own in-house network, with MAC address blocking set up on the Access Point. What I'm looking for is a box, that can sit by the window, using preferably the high gain antenna i already have (from Hawking Technologies http://www.hawkingtech.com/products/productlist.php?CatID=32&FamID=58&ProdID=152 ) as pick up from the source from across the street as the input for a router with Wireless access to the rest of the flat. That way I can share my files around the network without having to worry about anyone else in the street having access to the same files. Still with me here... :-s I know its a pain, and its probably impossible as I'm usually in the knack of coming up for useful products in my head that just havn't been built yet, but if you can help me out here, it would really make my day, and my partners! Good luck... |
![]() | ||
|
There is no answer at this time. |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 06 Dec 2005 20:08 PST |
Hi, I have a potential solution that utilizes two relatively inexpensive components. First, you'll need a Linksys WRT54G that has alternate open-source firmware loaded - eg. DD-WRT (from www.dd-wrt.com). The WRT54G also has removable RP-TNC connectors that allow for higher-gain antennae to be installed. At the same time, the open-source firmware provides some features not available in the factory firmware. The features of import to you are: 1. Increase in signal transmission power (up to 251mW). 2. Operation mode modification that allows the wireless side to act as a wireless client (as opposed to an access point). In this fashion, the WRT54G's wireless interface will be the WAN port and the LAN ports will be the "private" side. The Internet (WAN)port will not be used. Once the client wireless session has been associated, you can connect your PC to the LAN switch ports and access the University's net and beyond. At that point, simply attach an inexpensive access point to any of the LAN ports and you've extended that network wirelessly! Easy! Let me know if you need further clarification! Kaiguy |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: truescotsman-ga on 07 Dec 2005 10:17 PST |
Wow! I am officially impressed, I never thought to think of that kind of solution. Hats off to you. I do have a couple of things I want to straighten out though. Can this edited wireless router, and access point, independently without having to be connected to a pc? Can it just sit by the window, connected to a power supply and function? Also, are there any issues or hang ups with installing this new firmware on the router? My networking knowledge is fairly limited, and my girlfriend Tina even less so. I should be able to install the firmware, but as far changing the options that might prove more difficult unless I have more detailed instructions. And with the changes made to the router, will internet browsing be effected at all. I downloaded the firmware, and there is this mention in the notes attached: "chillispot notes: chillispot works only if the redirect url is a valid url which ends with a slash '/' chillispot should be able to resolve the ip of this url hostname. so please setup your local router network to a valid gateway and dns the userurl field is possibly null in the current chillispot release. this is no dd-wrt issue, but a know issue in the current chillispot release" Also, I take it that there are still no 'all-in-one" solutions to the problem yet? Thanks very much for all your help with this, VERY VERY much appreciated. Andrew |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 07 Dec 2005 21:33 PST |
Hi again, Q: Can this edited wireless router, and access point, independently without having to be connected to a pc? Can it just sit by the window, connected to a power supply and function? A: Absolutely. The units will work together in a stand-alone fashion - no PCs are required. You'll need to configure the units, of course, but once that's done, you're all set - the LAN side of the linksys will provide you with a NATed private IP address. |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 07 Dec 2005 21:39 PST |
Q: Also, are there any issues or hang ups with installing this new firmware on the router? My networking knowledge is fairly limited, and my girlfriend Tina even less so. I should be able to install the firmware, but as far changing the options that might prove more difficult unless I have more detailed instructions. A: The firmware works quite well - we have over 100 of them set up with minimal issues - make sure that you DO NOT enable chilispot - that feature is for setting up a Hotspot (for processing credit cards, using authentication via RADIUS, etc.), which you'll not be using - it simply complicates your setup! Oh, and of course make sure you install the appropriate version of the firmware for the hardware that you have. Q:Also, I take it that there are still no 'all-in-one" solutions to the problem yet? Thanks very much for all your help with this, VERY VERY much appreciated. A: That's correct, in order to do what you want to do, the "unit" will have to have 2 radios that operate independently of each other with firmware sophisticated enough to manage them separately and assign different tasks to each - my solution is - IMHO - the simplest and cheapest. |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 07 Dec 2005 21:42 PST |
Also, Andrew, if you need more detailed instructions, let me know...however, the setup really is pretty straight-forward - just don't be intimidated by the number of features available in the firmware - most of them you'll not need to use. Kai |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: truescotsman-ga on 08 Dec 2005 09:57 PST |
Hi there Kai, That all sounds great, going to start looking into buying the router now. Does it have to be the WRT54G router, or can it be another type of WRT Linksys router? I'm asking because I've got in contact with a local plastics factory, who are going to a build up a custom enclosure, for the two wireless radios and antenna in one box. But obviously the smaller the components, the smaller the box can be overall. What is the smallest linksys router and access point I can use? I realise that this may fall out of bounds of the original question, so I dont mind adding an extra $25 for the fee of the question if you'd like? Also, as you offered it'd be great if you provide me with as full a set of instructions as you possibly could for installing this set up? I dont think this is possible, but if it is, some kind of instructions on how to get the two radios working from one wall socket power supply, (for when they are enclosed in the same box) would be absolutely fantastic. Thanks very much Kai, Andrew |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 08 Dec 2005 20:20 PST |
Hi Andrew, Q: Does it have to be the WRT54G router, or can it be another type of WRT Linksys router? A: Not necessarily, but the WRT54G is the most flexible (and inexpenssive), so I would HIGHLY recommend it. The other unit that works is the WRT54GS, but that's more $. None of the other units support the type of firmware needed for your application. If you need a smaller form factor, you can certainly take the "working parts" out of the case, which makes it MUCH smaller to fit into a custom case - we actually take the electronics (PCB) out and put them into small NEMA enclosures for outdoor deployment. In terms of the access point, you can use anything you'd like - that's not as important a piece of the puzzle, since it'll just be running the factory firmware. For that matter, you could use a dual WRT54G setup where one unit is acting as the wireless client/router and the other is simply acting as an access point! One other thing to consider is that the WRT54G can be set up to use PowerOverEthernet (POE), which makes it easier to install in places where power is not readily available - the WRT54Gs are nice because the board supports power input ranging from 5-12 Volts DC, so it's incredibly flexible. We've actually created our own POE adapters using the existing power adapters and a dual-RJ-48 jack block - one for the data and one to split out the DC. This will require some soldering and will void your unit's warranty, but if you're handy with soldering and are somewhat adventurous, it's kinda fun. Anyway, if distance from the power outlet is not an issue, the simplest way to get both units running off a single transformer is to split the power cable in such a way that you actually have two connectors coming out of the transformer block - you'll need another piece of cable (with the end that plugs into the WRT) and splice that into an existing transformer. Here's where the flexibility of the WRT's power requirements come in - since the voltage supplied will certainly see a drop from the standard 12-13 volts coming out of the transformer (since you're powering 2 units), the WRT will not complain as long as it sees at least 5 volts, which will not be a problem. I hope that makes sense! Regarding the setup, the key items to remember are: 1. Install the DD-WRT firmware and make sure that after you flash it, telnet into it first (username: root, password: admin) and at the #prompt type: mtd erase nvram reboot This will make sure that the config file stored in NVRAM is not corrupted. 2. Log back in and make the WRT a client unit (under the wireless tab, under wireless mode) and input the proper SSID for the university's network. 3. Go to the wireless security subtab and make sure you choose the proper encryption/authorization format for the network. 4. Under the advanced settings subtab, increase the Xmit power to 200mW (that should be more than sufficient) 5. Under setup, define the Internet connection type to be "automatic configruation - DHCP" 6. Specify your internal network address range - you can leave it as 192.168l.1.1/24 7. Make sure you change your password and test it with an ethernet connection into the WRT! That should be it for the client/router. ####### AP config 8. If that worked (the hard part is done!), you can configure the AP. Assuming we use another WRT54G, upload the DD-WRT firmware. 9. Turn off the WAN interface (disable it). Set the LAN address to be 192.168.1.2 and turn off DHCP. Make the gateway address 192.168.1.1. 10. Set your wireless network with the appropriate SSID and wireless channel -0make sure it's different than the client/router unit's. 11. Crank up the Xmit power, change the password and you're DONE! Questions? Kai |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: truescotsman-ga on 09 Dec 2005 13:25 PST |
Hi there, I think I have just stumbled upon a problem, but its my fault as I did not include it in the original question. When accessing the University Wireless network from across the street, you still need to type in a username and password to a VPN to get full internet access. Without that all you can do is kind of pass files around the connected machines. How can I get the Router/AP to enter through the VPN gateway? So sorry for that... :-s If this setup can still work with the new problem of a VPN gateway, can you tell me more about these NEMA enclosures. Would I have to send out another question for this though? I was hoping to find out how I can install the circuit boards into them, as I'm assuming the screws for fixing down the boards not going to have complimentary screw holes in the NEMA plastic case. And where I could get them from in the UK, preferably in Edinburgh, Scotland. And if I was wanting something more sophisticated and custom, what kind of company around here would manufacture the case? Also, how do I increase the monetary amount for this question? You've obviously done a lot more work than a usual $50 dollar question would ask for, and I really do think that the effort you've put in so far is worthy of at least another $25 on top. Thanks very much for all your help Kai, Andrew. PS. Just out of curiousity, what is it that you've done before this or still doing to build up all this experience in computing/networking? |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 09 Dec 2005 15:36 PST |
Andrew, You've just tossed a small wrench into the works here...:-0 I do think that the NEMA enclosure topic should be a separate question if we can get passed the VPN impasse. I'm glad that the answers have been helpful. I think the simplest way to increase the amount for the answer is to add a tip for the additional amount. Now, on to the topic at hand - the question here is: What kind of VNP is it? I need to know protocols. Also, does it require software to be loaded onto a PC to authenticate and establish the tunnel? If that's the case, you may have problems, since it requires the actual binary for the VPN software to be loaded onto the router - since it's the actual "client." And, that's not a very feasible process since the router is just a simple "linux" box... I need to know more information to be helpful, specifically what is the current process of connecting a PC to the wireless network - the more detailed, the better. Regarding your PS question, I run a WISP where we provide broadband wireless Internet access. Cheers, Kai |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: truescotsman-ga on 09 Dec 2005 22:38 PST |
Hi there, Well, firstly good news. You do NOT need to have any software running on the client PC to log into the VPN. There are two methods; 1. Connect to the wireless network (SSID = 'central') and then open up any webpage. The browser is then redirected to a university webpage that prompts you to type in your username and password to continue. Once done, the page refreshes and then redirects you to your original target page within 5 seconds. 2. (my method) Connect to the wireless network (again) and then use the Network Setup Wizard in XP, to create a VPN connection to the address 'vpngate.net.ed.ac.uk'. Then when the 'Connect To' dialog box comes up, set the computer to remember my username and password, by passing the need to log in at the University's own log in webpage. I realise that that may not be enough information for you to go on, so I've taken a few snapshots of my connection settings, and hopefully it will help The most useful one I think is this one; http://static.flickr.com/35/71979696_3ecc2835e5_o.jpg But if you can browse through other snapshots here; http://www.flickr.com/photos/true_scotsman85/sets/1547521/ Hopefully this will be enough information to figure this one out. :-s If you need anymore information or need me to download certain tools to find out other details, just let me know. Thanks again, Andrew |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 12 Dec 2005 19:22 PST |
Hi Andrew, Sorry about the delay in getting back to you - I was out of town on a conference... Anyway, regarding the connection to the UniNet, my recommendation is to attack it step-by-step. First, I would certainly get a WRT54G and have the unit flashed to DD-WRT firmware. After that, connect it to UniNet via the wireless client mode and then connect a PC directly to the LAN port of the WRT. At that point, you will be able to test the connection to see if there's an IP address assigned to it - btw, the UniNet is running hostspot software that does redirection, so you should obtain an IP address on the WRT's wireless interface. Once you've verified that you should be able to open up a browser window and get an authentication dialogue box - the only difference is that the access will be NATed through the WRT. Let me know if that works - if it does, then I think you're home free - you will not be able to establish an IPSEC connection directly from the WRT since it does not support that as protocol. Good luck, Kai |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: truescotsman-ga on 13 Dec 2005 18:35 PST |
Hi there Kai, Went out today to buy the WRT65G, and ran into a few problems. The first one being that the Hawking Antenna that i mentioned earlier in the post, did not attach to the back of the linksys router; wrong type of connection. And the second one, and more importantly, I couldnt update the firmware to the DD-WRT version in the router. I seem to have a Version 5 of the router which seems to causing the problems according to this; http://www.linksysinfo.org/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=9209&highlight=ddwrt Where am I going to find a router of an earlier model that isnt being made anymore, does this mean we're back to square one? Sorry if im sounding a bit panicked, just spent around £70 getting this router, and its all falling apart at the seams... :-s Catch you later, Andrew |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 13 Dec 2005 19:00 PST |
Andrew, Sorry you're having problems...most of the WRT54Gs we're getting stateside are version 3-4...version 5 does not support linux firmware upgrades because it uses another OS called VxWorks. I would return that and see if you can find one between version 3 and 4...btw, pricing for the WRT54G units run about US$60...70 quids is quite a lot to pay! Regarding the antenna, the linksys units have a standard reverse-polarity TNC connector, so it's farily easy to get an antenna for it. The following is a list of serial numbers and what hardware version they match. Serial numbers begin with: CDF0 = WRT54G v1.0 CDF1 = WRT54G v1.0 CDF2 = WRT54G v1.1 CDF3 = WRT54G v1.1 CDF5 = WRT54G v2.0 CDF7 = WRT54G v2.2 CDF8 = WRT54G v3.0 CDF9 = WRT54G v3.1 CDFA = WRT54G v4.0 CDFB = WRT54G v5.0 (runs VxWorks, not Linux) BTW, you can also try getting a WRT54GS if available...the SNs start with: CGN0 = WRT54GS v1.0 CGN1 = WRT54GS v1.0 CGN2 = WRT54GS v1.1 CGN3 = WRT54GS v2.0 CGN4 = WRT54GS v2.1 CGN5 = WRT54GS v3.0 CGN6 = WRT54GS v4.0 I'm really sorry about this...I forgot about the new releases of the WRT54G units since we're not seeing them here yet. Kai |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: truescotsman-ga on 13 Dec 2005 22:02 PST |
Hey there Kai, Seriously, no worries about the firmware mix-up. Easy enough to sort out now that I know we dont have to start from scratch. But now you know why we have the nick-name of 'Rip-Off Britain'. -Warning: Slight Ramble Ahead) Price fixing has always been an issue here. Tina (my girlfriend and also American citizen) has definetely noticed it. Even though the Pound and the Dollar have difference values, they still have the same buying power sometimes, but usually for us brits its even worse than that. So im just stuck paying 60 and 70 quid for the router. But if you're ever in the UK, saying quids is a dead giveaway. If you want to blend in, you can say 70 quid, and always scream at the TV when there's a Scotland/England game on at the pub. Its worked for me for years! But I digress... I was mentioning the antenna before because I already have that one in my house, so I'm assuming I can get some kind of adapter for the antenna connection. I'll try and get my hands on a different model of router, and I'll get back to you. And if you're wondering what the hell I'm on about before, I'm going to put it down to it being really quite late here, so I hope I didnt confuse you too much. Hope you're conference went well, Andrew |
Subject:
Re: Looking for a Wireless Sourced Router with integrated Wireless Access Point...
From: kaiguy-ga on 13 Dec 2005 22:22 PST |
Andrew, Thanks for the explanation... Regarding the antenna, I took a look at the link you provided in your original post and the description of the antenna says that it includes an RP-TNC connector...take a look at the bottom of the page... FYI, I just went over to our local walmart and picked up a version 4.0 WRT54G for $49.95... Kai |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |