Carpetbag Mayoral Candidates - Is it possible today?
Category: Relationships and Society
Asked by: townattorneygeneral-ga
List Price: $50.00
20 Dec 2005 17:07 PST
Expires: 19 Jan 2006 17:07 PST
Question ID: 608232
Are there any towns, villages or other municipalities in any of the 50 states in which a non-resident of the town, village or municipality (and state) can lawfully run for mayor? It seems to me that residence requirements are easily evaded, and even that a mayor after election probably remains mayor even if he moves out of town. I live in New York and would like to run for mayor somewhere in the U.S. without having to move. City managers probably have no residency requirement.
Re: Carpetbag Mayoral Candidates - Is it possible today?
Answered By: pafalafa-ga on 20 Dec 2005 19:20 PST
townattorneygeneral-ga, Nice to see you again, and thanks for an intriguing question. Looks like you have a few options available, at least. A nice place to start might be taking a shot at being mayor of New York City, especially since you live in the state already: http://www.slate.com/id/1007216/ ...Klein may protest that he's not a resident of New York City--he lives in the suburbs. But that's no excuse. There's no residency requirement! Klein can be a candidate for mayor the same way Bill Clinton, who also lives in the suburbs, can be a candidate for mayor. Maybe if Klein wins he'd have to move into the city. But the way I see it, he has no excuse for not running. It seemed hard to believe this, but I spent quite a while checking a variety of city and state election law documents, and found nothing about residency requirements for mayor. You can look for yourself, at the New York State election laws (which, as far as I understand things, set the rules for NYC as well): http://www.vote.nyc.ny.us/pdf/documents/nys/elaw2004.pdf ========== There are multiple options in Maryland, though there a bit hard to pin down: http://www.cityoffrederick.com/Commissions/Archives/MayorBoardWorkshop/October%2013%202004.htm ...Alderman Lenhart stated that according to the Maryland Municipal League (MML), the average residency requirement for Mayor is one (1) year. Ten municipalities have no residency requirement. Unfortunately, a search of the site of the MML: http://www.mdmunicipal.org/mmlhome/index.cfm didn't uncover a list of the ten towns, but if MD sounds of interest, you can always get in contact with the MML for more details. ========= Caņon City, Colorado might be nice: http://www.canoncity.org/mayor.html ...The Mayor and three Council members are elected with no residency requirements; the remaining four Council members each have districts for which they must meet residency requirements. You can get in touch with the city clerk's office at: City of Caņon City P.O. Box 1460 128 Main Street Caņon City, CO. 81212 Tel. (719) 269-9011 Fax. (719) 269-9017 ========== I trust the above examples are enough to whet your appetite, and make for a complete answer to your question. However, please don't rate this answer if you find you'd like any additional information. If there's a particular town or area for which you'd like more details, be sure to let me know. Just post a Request for Clarification to let me know how to assist your further, and I'm at your service. Best of luck, pafalafa-ga search strategy -- Google searches on [ mayor ] along with other terms like: "no residency" "non-resident"
rated this answer:
and gave an additional tip of:
Thanks to the Answer and the 1st comment, I (as the person submitting the original question) have spent some time looking up case law, both federal and state, on the matter of residency requirements for local office. An apparent majority of the cases dealing with the issue have struck down the residency requirement, for various reasons. One of the most compelling is 1st (freedom of speech) and 14th (denial of equal protection) because the requirment prevents citizens from having a mayor or other elected official of their choice. The standard for the court's review of the restriction is strict, and requires the municipality to show that there is no less restrictive way to accomplish a legitimate interest of the municipality. One decision said that residency does not ensure knowledge of government, but the requirement could exclude someone with more knowledge than a resident. The conclusion I have reached, and offer it as an amendment to the answer above, is that virtually anyone in the United States could probably run for mayor of any town, village or other municipality, although the right to such candidacy might have to be enforced by seeking judicial relief. The researcher did not have access to the federal and state decisions and could not have come up with the answer, more than likely, by searching newspaper and magazine articles. The comment by tcrimsonk-ga (see below) inspired me to do a fairly good search of federal and state cases, although I could not find any published decision relating to Frederick City, MD. In light of this, it seems possible for a group of reform-minded residents in a town to find and promote their own reform candidate, even if the candidate is not a resident of the town. townattorneygeneral-ga 12/23/05
Re: Carpetbag Mayoral Candidates - Is it possible today?
From: tcrimsonk-ga on 23 Dec 2005 06:53 PST
This has come up recently in local politics in Frederick City, Maryland. A man moved into Frederick County (the county that Frederick City is a part of), and ran for mayor, despite the 3 year residential requrement. When the existing city government tried to keep him from running, he sued the City. Ultimately, he won the law suit, on the basis that the residential requirement was unconstitutional. The Judge went so far as to say that the people of Frederick have the right to vote for whomever they like, and that no law can stand in the way of that right. Ironically, the US Constitution itsself contains similar restrictions, on who can be elected as the US President.
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at firstname.lastname@example.org with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
|Search Google Answers for|