Where can I buy a Bartlet For America pin?

Although there isn't a "Barlet for America" pin here, you will find
other items of "West Wing" merchandise at the NBC Store:

http://www.shopnbc.com/nbcstore/depts/default.asp?deptid=50

You might want to consider getting a custom pin made. There are many
places online to choose from, and there may also be a place local to
you that can accomodate custom pin production.

Search 'custom pins' on Google:
://www.google.com/search?q=custom+pins

Thanks, those are both good points.  I'm already aware of those two
options, though.  There must be some fans out there who've put
together an imitation of the buttons worn on the show!  I was hoping a
few bucks would save me the time I don't have for mocking up my own.

Eck -- you're passing up a big business opportunity!  Someone in my
house would buy a dozen for her friends.

Ebay has three campaign caps and a campaign shirt for "Bartlet for
America" posted as current auctions/buy it now items.  It looks like
they're about $10-$15 dollars for the current bid.  To find them,
search for "bartlet for america" or "bartlet campaign" in titles and
descriptions.  I didn't find the buttons for sale in either current or
completed auctions, but you never know, one could show up.

librariankt