|
|
Subject:
Would light from one projector interfere with another?
Category: Science > Physics Asked by: keithc-ga List Price: $10.00 |
Posted:
23 Feb 2006 12:35 PST
Expires: 25 Mar 2006 12:35 PST Question ID: 700062 |
I have an application where I need two computer projectors to project images on facing walls. To get the size and position right, the projectors may need to shoot through one another's projection -- the walls are 35 feet apart and the projectors each need to be 20 feet off the walls. (They'll be angled down from the ceiling so the projectors themselves won't block each other, but the beams would pass thru). Will this cause interference of some sort or will the projected images look the same as they would if they were projected on their own? (If this is more complex physics than I'm thinking please let me know and I'll raise the price.) |
|
Subject:
Re: Would light from one projector interfere with another?
Answered By: sublime1-ga on 23 Feb 2006 14:44 PST Rated: |
keith... Well naturally, the first thing I did was get two strong flashlights and fit one with a color filter, go to a windowless room and see what happened when I crossed the beams of the two flashlights. Nothing that I could detect. Then I went digging through the internet. Though I didn't find an explanation (if there is one) the consensus is that two beams won't interfere with one another. In this discussion of the Physics of Light and Color - Light: Particle or a Wave?, it says: "Some argued that if light consisted of particles, then when two beams are crossed, some of the particles would collide with each other to produce a deviation in the light beams. Obviously, this is not the case, so they concluded that light must not be composed of individual particles." http://www.mic-d.com/curriculum/lightandcolor/particleorwave.html Obviously... ; ) In this scholarly discussion about passing matter through walls, on the Hypography Science Forums, Fishteacher73 notes: "I suppose if one could remove the charge from the atoms in the wall one could just slide through, just as two light beams can pass through each other." http://www.sciencelists.com/scienceforums/showthread.php?goto=newpost&t=1769 Nanogasm, on the Interesting Nonetheless forum posed your question precisely: "I was thinking... if you took two movie projectors, each with their own movie screen, but you positioned the projectors so that the light beam of each projector's movie intersects each other.....what would be displayed on each screen?" Despite conflicts about the nature of light, it was generally agreed that, as with my experiment: "if you take two flashlights and make them face a similar direction so that thier paths cross, they will still have the same pattern of light as they did without the other flashlight." and "neither projection or beam of light would affect the other" http://forums.interestingnonetheless.net/display.php?tid=1469&postid=182246 Experientially, this is borne out by the fact that radio waves, or other frequencies of the electromagnetic spectrum, don't interfere with each other. In a city with 20 radio stations, this would be a major problem, if it were the case. Other citations: "Two light beams pass through each other without affecting each other at all." http://www.exo.net/~pauld/summer_institute/summer_day8interference/Interference_laser.html "If, for example, two light beams of flashlights (bosons) are aimed at each other the two beams pass right through each other, nothing at all happens." http://www.hyperhistory.com/online_n2/people_n2/science_n2/atomic_theory.html "The fact that two light beams can pass through each other makes possible much of the microwave and optical communication of today." http://www.physics.montana.edu/faculty/babbitt/Physics353/holoQandA.htm "'At the most fundamental level,' Leonberger explains, 'electrons like to interact with each other, and photons don't. So you can send two light beams through each other, and they both keep going.'" http://www.zinkle.com/p/articles/mi_m1511/is_n2_v14/ai_13381537 Light, then, does not interfere with itself. Interference only occurs when the medium through which it passes affects it, as when it is subject to refraction when passing through water. Please do not rate this answer until you are satisfied that the answer cannot be improved upon by way of a dialog established through the "Request for Clarification" process. A user's guide on this topic is on skermit-ga's site, here: http://www.christopherwu.net/google_answers/answer_guide.html#how_clarify sublime1-ga Additional information may be found from an exploration of the links resulting from the Google searches outlined below. Searches done, via Google: "two projectors" beams passing through interference ://www.google.com/search?q=%22two+projectors%22+beams+passing+through+interference "two beams" passing through interference ://www.google.com/search?q=%22two+beams%22+passing+through+interference "two light beams" "passing through each other" ://www.google.com/search?q=%22two+light+beams%22+%22passing+through+each+other%22 "two light beams" "pass through each other" ://www.google.com/search?q=%22two+light+beams%22+%22pass+through+each+other%22 |
keithc-ga
rated this answer:
and gave an additional tip of:
$5.00
Wow! That's a fast and excellent answer! 6-stars! |
|
Subject:
Re: Would light from one projector interfere with another?
From: sublime1-ga on 23 Feb 2006 15:48 PST |
keith... Thanks very much for the rating and the tip! sublime1-ga |
Subject:
Re: Would light from one projector interfere with another?
From: juanmoreira-ga on 23 Feb 2006 16:53 PST |
Hey, I liked the question, and answer, very much. I agree with sublime1 on that the final effect, as seen on the two projector screens, is that the two projectors won't interfere. And I think that answers keithc question. Now, I don't agree with the general statement that the two beams of light don't interfere at all. If one were to look at the portion of space where the two beams cross each other, there are situations were the beams will definitively interfere. This will mean, that at an specific point in space, the two beams could add to zero light!! Still, the beams continue marching on, and the image on the two screens will not be affected. Cool, ah? The trick is that light is a time-dependent vector field, that can be added at any point in space. Light is NOT particles bouncing. Of course, to produce any interference at all one needs some technicalities to be in effect, such as the two light sources (the projectors) be "coherent" meaning that the light vectors oscillate together. I doubt that keithc went into that expense for his projector. This little fact pretty much seals the fate of the experiment with two flashlights More interesting, and accesible, stuff of this sort can be achieved with another time-dependent vector: sound. There is a lot of cool stuff out there, people using the interference of several speakers to create spots with zero sound, while focusing it on a paser by, etc. The thing with soud is that because of its longer wavelenght, it is easier to "feel" the interference spots Cheers |
Subject:
Re: Would light from one projector interfere with another?
From: kottekoe-ga on 23 Feb 2006 21:21 PST |
For all practical purposes, electromagnetic radiation does not interact with itself, which implies it is totally linear, meaning that the field at any point is simply the sum of the fields from each source. Where the light from two sources pass each other, you have interference effects, since the fields can add constructively or destructively depending on the relative phase, but in regions where the light comes from only one light source, it makes no difference whether it passed through a region with light from other sources. The reason for this is that electromagnetic fields only interact with things that are electrically charged, and the fields themselves have no charge. Thus, Maxwell's equations, that describe electromagnetism are linear. However, at very high field strength, elecromagnetic fields can cause the vacuum to ionize, creating electron-positron pairs, which are charged and thus, interact with the electromagnetic field. Thus, very high intensity light does interact with other light. Fortunately this would only happen for impractically high intensities and is not a concern in any practical situation. |
Subject:
Re: Would light from one projector interfere with another?
From: keithc-ga on 24 Feb 2006 06:21 PST |
Thanks juanmoreira and kottekoe for the added explanation! |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |