Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: English Grammar ( No Answer,   6 Comments )
Question  
Subject: English Grammar
Category: Health
Asked by: xxxx12343545-ga
List Price: $2.00
Posted: 06 Mar 2006 11:50 PST
Expires: 07 Mar 2006 08:32 PST
Question ID: 704297
If you are referring to someone who experienced a heart attack. Would
the right English when explaining to someone be: He or She "took a
heart attack"? or He or She had a heart attack?
Answer  
There is no answer at this time.

Comments  
Subject: Re: English Grammar
From: pinkfreud-ga on 06 Mar 2006 12:03 PST
 
Although, in colloquial English, you can say that a person "took
sick," I don't believe I have ever heard anyone say that someone "took
a heart attack."
Subject: Re: English Grammar
From: tlspiegel-ga on 06 Mar 2006 12:09 PST
 
Pinkfreud is correct.  

The only time the word "took" would be appropriate would be in a
sentence such as this:

?My doctor ignored my heart scan. It took a heart attack to prove him wrong!?
http://www.prleap.com/pr/27450/
Subject: Re: English Grammar
From: pinkfreud-ga on 06 Mar 2006 12:16 PST
 
Although I think "took a heart attack" sounds bizarre, some might find
it to be technically acceptable. I found this in Merriam-Webster's
Unabridged Dictionary (CD-ROM edition):

"take...
to strike or affect so as to cause to be in a particular condition
<was taken ill> <found himself taken hoarse> <was taken down with
pneumonia>"
Subject: Re: English Grammar
From: myoarin-ga on 06 Mar 2006 14:03 PST
 
Maybe, but I don't think that helps someone learning English.  It just
is NOT standard English usage to say:  "I took a heart attack."

There is something in the language that suggests that illnesses come
from outside the body, as infectious diseases do.  "One catches the
flu or a cold or measles." Or: "One is taken ill," passive voice, the
illness takes/overcomes one.
Other afflictions from within the person's body are just there, one
"has" them:  a heart attack, a tumor, cancer, a stroke.

So:  "He had a heart attack."

(Now someone explain why we say  "the flu", "a cold", but "measles"
with no article.)  :-?
Subject: Re: English Grammar
From: steph53-ga on 06 Mar 2006 16:23 PST
 
Myoarin...

We say measles because measles are considered plural...eg: many red spots ;)

Steph53
Subject: Re: English Grammar
From: myoarin-ga on 06 Mar 2006 16:53 PST
 
Thanks Steph.  I feel some red spots, myself.  Actually, we say:  "He
caught the measles."  Otherwise, I would agree with you; it is or
sounds plural.
Myo

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy