|
|
Subject:
English Grammar
Category: Health Asked by: xxxx12343545-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
06 Mar 2006 11:50 PST
Expires: 07 Mar 2006 08:32 PST Question ID: 704297 |
If you are referring to someone who experienced a heart attack. Would the right English when explaining to someone be: He or She "took a heart attack"? or He or She had a heart attack? |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: English Grammar
From: pinkfreud-ga on 06 Mar 2006 12:03 PST |
Although, in colloquial English, you can say that a person "took sick," I don't believe I have ever heard anyone say that someone "took a heart attack." |
Subject:
Re: English Grammar
From: tlspiegel-ga on 06 Mar 2006 12:09 PST |
Pinkfreud is correct. The only time the word "took" would be appropriate would be in a sentence such as this: ?My doctor ignored my heart scan. It took a heart attack to prove him wrong!? http://www.prleap.com/pr/27450/ |
Subject:
Re: English Grammar
From: pinkfreud-ga on 06 Mar 2006 12:16 PST |
Although I think "took a heart attack" sounds bizarre, some might find it to be technically acceptable. I found this in Merriam-Webster's Unabridged Dictionary (CD-ROM edition): "take... to strike or affect so as to cause to be in a particular condition <was taken ill> <found himself taken hoarse> <was taken down with pneumonia>" |
Subject:
Re: English Grammar
From: myoarin-ga on 06 Mar 2006 14:03 PST |
Maybe, but I don't think that helps someone learning English. It just is NOT standard English usage to say: "I took a heart attack." There is something in the language that suggests that illnesses come from outside the body, as infectious diseases do. "One catches the flu or a cold or measles." Or: "One is taken ill," passive voice, the illness takes/overcomes one. Other afflictions from within the person's body are just there, one "has" them: a heart attack, a tumor, cancer, a stroke. So: "He had a heart attack." (Now someone explain why we say "the flu", "a cold", but "measles" with no article.) :-? |
Subject:
Re: English Grammar
From: steph53-ga on 06 Mar 2006 16:23 PST |
Myoarin... We say measles because measles are considered plural...eg: many red spots ;) Steph53 |
Subject:
Re: English Grammar
From: myoarin-ga on 06 Mar 2006 16:53 PST |
Thanks Steph. I feel some red spots, myself. Actually, we say: "He caught the measles." Otherwise, I would agree with you; it is or sounds plural. Myo |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |