![]() |
|
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
$20 tip, correctly tell me what's the point of me asking this
Category: Miscellaneous Asked by: doctorchou2-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
01 Apr 2006 16:01 PST
Expires: 01 May 2006 17:01 PDT Question ID: 714435 |
In 30 characters or less, and within 30 minutes of reading this, what is pi? For a $20 tip, correctly tell me (then tell your boss) what's the point of me asking this and similar questions: http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=709019 http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=709020 http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=709025 This portion of your response is not counted as part of the 30 characters. Hint: I am in fact a happy person; but alas, not as happy as I would be if I worked for Google Answers and could simply have them implement my suggestions directly. If you're a frequent answerer, this question is made for you. Come on, pinkfreud. |
![]() | ||
|
There is no answer at this time. |
![]() | ||
|
Subject:
Re: $20 tip, correctly tell me what's the point of me asking this
From: pinkfreud-ga on 03 Apr 2006 14:22 PDT |
Thanks for mentioning me. I am indeed a "frequent answerer" (though not the most frequent: my friend and colleague bobbie7 has me beat by a huge margin). I'm stumped. I have no idea whatsoever regarding your point in asking these questions. Hope someone else is more clueful than I am. |
Subject:
Re: $20 tip, correctly tell me what's the point of me asking this
From: myoarin-ga on 14 Apr 2006 16:55 PDT |
Doctor Chou, There is no doubt that brevity has its virtues, and one of Pinkfreud's frequent comments often is an adequate answer. (Something like: "Perhaps this site/answer to this question could be of interest.) But few questions here can be satisfactorily answered in 30 words. Maybe some of them can be, but the asker most probably would reply with a request for clarification - perhaps unnecessarily - but persons paying for an answer want to have confirmation that alternatives have been ruled out - or included, as in your question here: Pi is a number, but it is also the ratio of the circumference of a circle to its diameter in Euclidian geometry. A complete answer requires both definitions and also the statement that it is a Greek letter. Just the number alone with 30 characters would not be entirely accurate; the second and third definitions are also necessary. Yes, if people stated their questions precisely enough to allow the reader to understand that a yes or no answer would be entirely satisfactory, such an answer would be possible, but since questions to G-A are seeking a researched answer, it needs to be supported and circumscribed. (We all are sloppy in formulating questions, asking: "Can you find ...?" Answer "yes/no" is precisely correct but inadequate. You didn't specify which definition of Pi you wanted. :) And, by the pricing parameters, more expensive questions deserve a greater search effort, which needs to be justified. Three or four links to absolutely pertinent websites may be entirely sufficient, but the human asker expects some demonstration of the effort expended to earn his $100 or $200. I think that Hammer-ga deserves at least five stars for answering your question correctly and - as Tutuzdad adds - exceeding your expectations. Cheers, hoping you are still happy, Myoarin |
Subject:
Re: $20 tip, correctly tell me what's the point of me asking this
From: pinkfreud-ga on 14 Apr 2006 17:27 PDT |
Well, I've read the lengthy explanation of the point behind the question, and I'm still baffled. There is no requirement that an official answer from a Google Answers Researcher needs to be of any particular length. If a customer requests an answer of a certain length, we try to oblige. It has been my experience that longer answers with more links generally receive better ratings and higher tips. Unless a customer specifies that brevity is essential, I think GARs assume that more is better. You see many more complaints from customers who think they've received an inadequate amount of information than from customers who are peeved because they've been given too much. |
Subject:
Re: $20 tip, correctly tell me what's the point of me asking this
From: hammer-ga on 15 Apr 2006 05:42 PDT |
DoctorChou, I answered your question because I was interested in what you were looking at. I left the 30 word answer instead of amending to 30 characters in case you were specifically looking at something to do with the effects of word/structure repetition. (It wouldn't be the first one of those we've had here.) Now that I see your premise, I see some issues. Using your priest example above: The user would have no way of knowing how much brevity would still get a sufficent answer, unless they already know the answer. By hamstringing the researcher to a one word Yes/No answer, they would be unlikely to get any answer at all. The researcher would likely discover that the answer is "Yes, but only under the following circumstances and by following the following procedures" or "No, unless the following circumstance exists". In the case of your example, they would also have to ask clarification questions like "Which country?" to determine even a Yes or No answer. As most of us are unwilling to answer a question without answering it, we would feel unable to post anything at all. In addition, for a person in a time-sensitive emergency situation, a service like Google Answers might not be the most appropriate choice in the first place. Another issue is that, when a question includes that sort of requirement, it often turns out to be a red flag that the Customer will reject or poorly rate any answer that is attempted. You "favorite pet" question is an example of this. You gave a poor rating. In your comment, you said that you rated low because the researcher did not specify *why* they chose a dog. Your question demanded brevity and specifically did not ask the researcher to explain their reasons, only to state their favorite animal for a pet. You asked for 30 words or less. The meat of the answer was 9 words and answered your question precisely. Yet, the researcher was censured for doing exactly as you asked, rather than providing information you did not ask for. This is not an uncommon occurence. The questions are freeform, thereby allowing the Customer (as you did) to add any content, time or length requirements they see fit. With this freeform format, all options are available. The Asker simply needs to tell us what they want, without being limited by whatever options the Google Answers designers thought in advance to include. - Hammer |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |