|
|
Subject:
Why do people use Google Answers?
Category: Miscellaneous Asked by: tar_heel_v-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
09 Oct 2002 06:31 PDT
Expires: 08 Nov 2002 05:31 PST Question ID: 74420 |
Why do people use Google Answers? Now, let me clarify. I have learned alot from reading answers to questions here and it is amazing the pure amount of data, trivial and otherwise, that is out there. However, a large of the answers provide are found using basic search engine queries. An example is when someone asks a question and the researcher provides an and answer and their search terms used were taken directly from the question itself. Now, there are several that show obvious heavy duty investigation and research by the researchers. I do not mean, in any way, to belittle the work done by researchers. What I am asking is why would someone pay anywhere from two to five to ten dollars for someone to answer their question when, had they simply typed their question within Google, or used quotes, they would have found it on their own at no cost. Admittedly, I have used GA for a couple of questions that I probably could have found the information for, but I did it for one of two reasons: 1) I simply did not have the time and it was worth a small investment to have someone find the information for me, or 2) I was just lazy. So, is it laziness, lack of time, curiosity, lack of search engine (Google is specific) usage skills or what? Think about it. Unless there has been some marketing that I am unaware of, the only way to find GA is through a search on Google in the first place. Yes, I know, this question is a perfect example of what I am talking about, but I am curious as to what the researchers, haveing seen 1000's of questions, feel the percentage of questions were answered with basic search engine skills. I look forward to the responses |
|
Subject:
Re: Why do people use Google Answers?
Answered By: omniscientbeing-ga on 09 Oct 2002 12:59 PDT Rated: |
tar_heel_v-ga, First of all, I think you generally answered your own question to some degree when you site Questioner lack of time, laziness, and lack of more advanced search skills. But I will add a few things here which you may consider when pondering why people use Google Answers and other Q&A pay services. There are gradations of complexity in the Questions posed to the GA service. As you point out, many Questions priced $10 and less may oftentimes be answered by entering the keywords from the question itself, and visiting a few sites on the page one results, and pasting excerpts to the Question, citing them properly, and adding a bit of explanation to put it in context. [Note: It is this concept which fuels my AnswerBot idea which will operate by automatically inserting the nouns and verbs from a Question title into the Google search engine, locating the first paragaraph from each of the first five links of the page one Google search results, and copying-and-pasting this information to the Answer box for that Question--look for my Question WIFS #1B--Technology, coming soon (also see WIFS# 1A: Human Resources still posted and awating an Answer)]. To directly answer your question, I'd say that 90% of all $10 and under Questions can be answered through basic searches. Now, what percentage of all posted GA Questions are in the $10 and under range, I do not know (although I'd like to), but I suspect it's around 70%. For the people asking these $10 and under questions, I'm sure the reason for not finding the answer themselves has to do with laziness, lack of time, or just a complete lack of computer/internet savvy. Keep in mind that the account holder is not necessarily the person asking the question--they may be doing someone else with no computer skills whatsoever a favor. Also, and no one has touched on this yet--I think another reason for paying people to find answers which are easy to find might be that of corroboration. If the accuracy of the question is extremely important to the Asker (and this is especially true of the market research questions where Askers may be using the information gleaned to seek funding for business ventures), then even if they already found the answer themselves, they may be willing to pay money to feel corroborated (or use as "independently verified data" in a business meeting) when somone else who is completely objective comes up with the same answer. This will also apply to questions priced over $10, now that I think of it, and may be the rationale behind pricing a seemingly "easy" Question at a fairly high dollar amount. [Also note that pricing a quesiton higher tends to increase the likelihood it will be answered in a short period of time]. GA may provide a sense of security to those who think they have the right answer to a pressing question, but just want someone else to concur with them. Consider further that even if you are capable of finding the Answer to a Question, if you have 2 or 3 or 4 or more Questions you need answered "yesterday," then you're going to want some assistance. The following link is to a site which reviews the more popular premium Q&A services, including GA: http://www.dooyoo.co.uk/product/66665.html By perusing these reviews, you will get a sense of what it is customers (i.e. Questioners) are seeking, generally speaking. To sum up, I'd say the answer to your question is, a combination of lack of internet/computer skills, lack of time, corroboration and plain old laziness. (i.e., human nature). Google search strategy: Keywords "google answers reviews" ://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=google+answers+reviews Good luck in continuing your inquiries! ~omniscientbeing-ga |
tar_heel_v-ga
rated this answer:
Very well answered. I agree wholeheartedly with your reasoning and clarifications of the $10 and below questions. I applied as a researcher and find myself researching questions and agree that there are some very detailed questions that would take a much more than a basic search, even with what I feel are well above average search engine query skills. Thanks again and I look forward to seeing your answers on future questions. |
|
Subject:
Re: Why do people use Google Answers?
From: ericynot-ga on 09 Oct 2002 10:41 PDT |
You ask an interesting question. I won't post this response as an answer because I'm not sure there is an "answer". The reasons vary from person to person. I think you've already identified the most common reasons. What may not be obvious if you haven't tried to do much of this type of research yourself is that, for many questions, it isn't as simple as just plugging a couple of words into a search engine and getting back a list of compliant sites. It takes practice, technique, and, above all, patience. For instance, yesterday I answered a question that had me looking at dozens of sites, then finally coming in through the "back door". The questioner wanted information about an accident involving a limousine that hit two policemen "several years ago" in southern New Jersey. Sounds fairly easy, right? But no Google search I could think of came up with anything (as a matter of fact, another researcher locked it and tried before me, and apparently couldn't come up with the answer in the two hour lock period). While Google has several million sites indexed, it doesn't have them all. I finally was able to find the desired information by going into the archives of the Philadelphia Inquirer (which I found through Google) which happens to be the largest major newspaper near southern New Jersey. Not too many people have the experience or time necessary to complete that kind of search. I'm a fairly new Google researcher and I still spend a considerable amount of my time studying answers posted by more experienced researchers just to learn new search techniques and ways of thinking about different kinds of questions. I hope one of these days GAR newbies will look at my stuff for the same reasons. The point is, if you really want an answer to your question, the best way to get it may be to try coming up yourself with the kinds of answers the researchers post each day - I think you'll find it's harder than it looks for most of the questions. I'm guessing the vast majority of question askers have already tried and failed to find the answer for themselves before they decide to pay someone else to do the looking for them. Then, of course, there are the questioners who just want someone to do their homework for them, but that's another matter entirely... |
Subject:
Re: Why do people use Google Answers?
From: mvguy-ga on 09 Oct 2002 17:09 PDT |
I'd agree with Ericynot's comment. I'd also point out that sometimes people (including me!) can't find the answer they seek because they don't have the background information they need to use relevant search terms. Similarly, some questions are very hard to answer using normal searches if you don't already know the answer. For example, the link below is to a question I recently answered. Searching on the obvious search terms would be unlikely to yield the answer, and the resulting term isn't even listed in any dictionary I know of. I could find plenty of definitions on the Web, but only AFTER I already knew the answer. https://answers.google.com/answers/main?cmd=threadview&id=68421 Also, there are some sources of information (such as newspaper archives, mentioned by Ericynot) that aren't available on search engines. And sometimes you have to go to specialty sites, as I did in the question below, to get information that's too recent to be included in search engines. https://answers.google.com/answers/main?cmd=threadview&id=72396 That question is also an example of one that you won't find find the complete answer to anywhere. It requires some background knowledge (not a lot in this case, but some) in order to apply the information available. |
Subject:
Re: Why do people use Google Answers?
From: claudietta-ga on 19 Oct 2002 04:12 PDT |
Dear Tar Heel, I believe that many questions posted here, including your $2.00 question, are not necessarily easy to answer. I often find the more expensive ones easier to answer than the cheapest ones. That has a lot to do with my knowledge base, which may be different from the askers. Conversely, many askers may be able to answer questions I have about the world, which I would be willing to pay a given sum of money, and a larger one depending on my increased wealth, urgency, lack of time, or a moments laziness. My answer is that that this is the place where diverse knowledge bases are aggregated to respond to diverse aggregated demand for answers. In other words, people use this service because as a whole, we all know different things, we all have different needs, and we all value those things/needs differently. Claudietta |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |