|
|
Subject:
Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
Category: Science Asked by: millrite01-ga List Price: $2.00 |
Posted:
21 Aug 2006 20:05 PDT
Expires: 20 Sep 2006 20:05 PDT Question ID: 758264 |
Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture? When emptying stacked ice-cube trays from the freezer, the ice-cubes in the tray on the bottom is always fractured and difficult to free. It is not caused from a specific tray, if I switch the trays, the ice-cubes from the bottom tray still comes out fractured, and if I lay the trays side by side, the ice-cubes all are fine, ie: solid, semi-transparent, and easily "popped" free of the tray. Could it have something to do with the cold mass of the upper tray above? |
|
There is no answer at this time. |
|
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: pinkfreud-ga on 21 Aug 2006 20:20 PDT |
This explanation seems plausible to me: "Wwater will expand when it freezes. Ice made in plastic trays will have a little mound on the top of each cube because the top edges will freeze first, and then as the rest of the water solidifies it will push up through the 'weaker' center. This may push the h2o up against the bottom of the other tray, causing fractures in the crystaline structure of the ice. When you try to pop the cubes out, they will separate at the fractures, making "broken bits" and irking you." http://www.chowhound.com/topics/show/312355 |
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: markvmd-ga on 21 Aug 2006 20:41 PDT |
I will likely regret going against a Pinkfreud statement but my guess has to do with speed of freezing. Faster freezing means larger crystal structures and weaker cleavage lines. Or is it vice versa? Just a SWAG. |
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: dops-ga on 22 Aug 2006 10:58 PDT |
I thought that faster freezing meant smaller crystal. Less cell damge with liq. N2 than -20 freeze. |
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: myoarin-ga on 22 Aug 2006 13:21 PDT |
"Could it have something to do with the cold mass of the upper tray above?" I think it could have more to do with the LESS cold mass above when you put stacked ice trays in the freezer. The bottom tray sits on the shelf with the cooling liquid tubes under it, freezing the water at the bottom quite fast. The water in the tray above keeps the water at the top of the bottom tray from freezing as quickly as it would without the tray on top, upsetting the formation of ice, as Mark suggests. |
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: tomhawk-ga on 25 Aug 2006 21:33 PDT |
Ice is formed first in the top layer of water, and as every one knows ice has more volume than water.. on top of the tray as water freezes, it has room to expand and expands forming ice, no cracks, once the top layer changes to ice, the bottom layer slowly changes to ice but the room for expansion is nil so the ice starts to break struggling against the top, causing cracks in botto, part of tray, the thickly fit top often stays strong and may bulge out or move up but does not break, |
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: knickers-ga on 02 Sep 2006 07:13 PDT |
This is a simple materials problem which is often overlooked. Some of the comments are partially correct. When your water freezes it tends to freeze from the outside inwards. Hence the surfaces (top, bottom and sides will freeze first. Ice has a lower density and hence bigger volume (the reason it floats). THis means that when frozen it expands. So the water in the middle of your ice cube is trying to expand but is prevented from doing so by the freezing of the outer surfaces. This tends to build up very high stresses in the ice cuber which are releived by cracking with slight temperature changes or when the ice cube is relased from the mould. The bottom trays tend to freeze first due to being in contact with the cooling compartment and the heat rising to the other trays. Hence the bottom trays have the most built in stress. So there you go. |
Subject:
Re: Why do the ice-cubes from the bottom ice-tray fracture?
From: mindlab2010-ga on 18 Nov 2006 17:27 PST |
Knickers provides an elegant explanation of the concept. But "if I lay the trays side by side, the ice-cubes all are fine, ie: solid, semi-transparent" In this situation, the surface area (and by extension cooling rate)is increased, with less evidence of "cracking with slight temperature changes or when the icecube is relased from the mould" |
If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you. |
Search Google Answers for |
Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy |