Dear Annejohansen-ga,
What an interesting question, and one in which I too have long had a
personal interest.
By way of background, I was raised in the Lutheran Church and have
been well steeped in its historical teachings, practices, and
particular theology. And then, I was married to a Roman Catholic for
many years, as was my sister, whose children and grandchildren are
practicing Catholics. My son is also married to a Catholic, was
married in the Catholic Church, and my grandchildren are currently
attending Catholic church and catechism classes. In addition, as a
matter of intellectual and religious curiosity, I am rather widely
read on a variety of religious topics, and have studied other
theologies than just Lutheran, and even other religions than only
Christian. So you can see I?ve had exposure to and opportunity to
learn from both, indeed many sides.
I am currently attending a small Emergent church, which is in
actuality a tiny LCMS mission, begun by a slightly maverick
Lutheran-ordained pastor/professor of theology. Interestingly enough,
Emergent itself is more comfortable not only with Lutheran doctrine,
but also with Catholic tradition and expression, than with modern
Protestant Evangelicalism/Fundamentalism.
First of all, I?d like to comment that the person who wrote the piece
in the blog you referenced is writing from the Roman Catholic
viewpoint, and making a common mistake, which is to lump all
Protestants together into one big pot. However, in fact, Lutherans
have much more in common with Roman Catholics than they do with many
Protestants. The blog author liberally quotes from Hank Hanegraaff,
who, while he is an erudite and articulate Christian apologist, is
nevertheless teaching from an evangelical viewpoint that does not
represent Lutheran theology.
Although its objectivity might be a bit questionable itself, there is
an interesting article in Wikipedia about Hanegraaff, here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hank_Hanegraaff
Hanegraaff?s own website for his ?Christian Research Institute? is
here: http://www.equip.org/
If nothing else, these two sources show that Hanegraaff is not
affiliated with any of the main Protestant denominations, but rather
touts what amounts to his own personal version of Christian
apologetics. Therefore, he is clearly not a useful source as a basis
for comparison between especially Lutheran Protestantism and Roman
Catholicism.
So then, for instance, when the blog author, basing his understanding
largely on Hanegraaff?s teaching, states that, ?Protestants see
justification as a single act in time,? and that they believe in ?an
exact moment of decision,? he is not entirely correct. While these
statements are true of some Protestants, they do not accurately
reflect Lutheran theology. Rather, Lutherans share with Catholics the
belief that ?There is not a single moment which one can point to where
one is considered right with God. Indeed ... as long as you are alive
on earth, God is still working out your own salvation with you. There
is God's initiation and then there is the response of the human
person. This is not a one time deal, but an ongoing relationship made
possible by what Jesus did on the cross.?
That?s not to say there are no significant differences between
Catholic and Lutheran theology. There are, but to understand and judge
them fairly, it would be best to understand both theologies from
within each tradition, and not base a comparison on comments from
someone whose understanding somes from a third party outside either.
Just for what it?s worth, here?s an interesting comment on that
subject, with an exhortation for people to see for themselves what
some religion or other teaches and make up their own minds:
http://www.mazes.com/questions/BodyBlood.htm
So, in line that that, I?ll do my best give you information and
resources from both the Lutheran and Catholic viewpoints, so that you
might more clearly see/understand what each church teaches, how they
view each other from within their respective doctrines, and then how
they compare.
Here, then, are links to some of what I believe are excellent
resources for exploring this topic further, from the standpoint of
theology, or dogma, which of course in turn influences practice or
ritual. I have organized them into four areas, first those from the
?Lutheran-Roman Catholic Dialogue,? then from the Protestant (and
especially Lutheran) point of view, then from the Catholic, and
finally some that come from outside both, though I would take these
with a grain of salt as they may not be entirely accurate about
either.
====================================
LUTHERAN-ROMAN CATHOLIC DIALOGUE
====================================
The ?Lutheran-Catholic Dialogue? refers to a series of discussions
between representatives of the Roman Catholic Church and the Lutheran
World Federation, that has been ongoing for more than thirty years,
since just after Vatican II.
A history and overview of the dialogue can be found on
the LWF site, here: http://193.73.242.125/what_we_do/oea/bilateral_relations/oea-lutheran-roman_catholic.html
The Vatican also has information about the dialogues on its website,
here: http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/sub-index/index_lutheran-fed.htm
The results of these dialogues are published in a series of books.
They are available from a variety of sources, including Amazon, here:
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_b/104-5030481-8839135?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=Lutheran-Catholic+Dialogue&Go.x=0&Go.y=0&Go=Go
In addition, here are links to the most recent papers online:
?JOINT DECLARATION ON THE DOCTRINE OF JUSTIFICATION?
by the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church
Lutheran: http://www.elca.org/ecumenical/ecumenicaldialogue/romancatholic/jddj/index.html
Catholic: http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-joint-declaration_en.html
?OFFICIAL COMMON STATEMENT?
by the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church
Lutheran:
http://www.elca.org/ecumenical/ecumenicaldialogue/romancatholic/jddj/common.html
Catholic:
http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-official-statement_en.html
================================
PROTESTANT (LUTHERAN) VIEWPOINT
================================
?SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE LUTHERAN AND ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCHES?
This article is written by a Lutheran pastor, who has boiled the
differences in question down to two main points: ?What is the
authority of the Christian church?? and ?How are we saved?? He argues
that all other differences are related in one way or another to these
questions.
http://www.goodshepherdcollinsville.org/Biblestudy/catholic_lutheran.htm
DIFFERENCES WITH CATHOLICS
Comments on these differences from the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod
(LCMS), the most conservative branch of American Lutheranism, on their
official website:
http://www.lcms.org/pages/internal.asp?NavID=2968
LUTHERAN (ELCA) ANSWERS TO ?QUESTIONS FROM CATHOLICS? about various
church practices and teachings:
http://www.peopleofhope.com/im-new/catholic-questions.shtml
(A brief discussion of the divergence between the LCMS and the more
liberal ELCA is here: http://www.elca.org/communication/roots.html )
LUTHERANS IN DIALOGUE: BASIC DIFFERENCES? by Marc Kolden
This article discusses a number of Lutheran-Catholic differences,
especially from the standpoint of law and gospel. It?s scholarly, but
very interesting.
http://www.luthersem.edu/word&world/Archives/7-3_Wisdom/7-3_Kolden.pdf
*Note: the above article requires you to have Adobe Acrobat Reader
to view. If you don?t already have it, you can download a copy here:
http://www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/readstep2.html
===================
CATHOLIC VIEWPOINT
===================
?REPORT ON CATHOLIC-LUTHERAN RELATIONS-2005? ?Climbing the Ecumenical
Mountains? by Fr. Matthias Turk of the Pontifical Council for
Promoting Christian Unity
http://www.ewtn.com/library/Theology/CATLUT05.HTM
?What Do Catholics Believe?? by a former Lutheran, also includes
dialogue between Catholics and Lutherans.
http://www.greenspun.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=00BO50
?WHAT CATHOLICS TEACH ABOUT COMMUNION AND HOW THAT DIFFERS FROM WHAT
LUTHERANS TEACH?
http://net-abbey.org/luthcomm.htm
?HOW I BECAME THE CATHOLIC I WAS,? by Richard John Neuhaus
?This article is adapted from a presentation at Concordia Theological
Seminary, Fort Wayne, Indiana, a seminary of the Lutheran
Church-Missouri Synod? and is an account of how and why this former
Missour-Synod Lutheran pastor converted to Roman Catholicism.
http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft0204/articles/neuhaus.html
CATHOLIC ANSWERS TO TOP 40 FAQ:
http://mafg.home.isp-direct.com/que4014.htm
===================================
OUTSIDE and/or OBJECTIVE VIEWPOINTS
===================================
COMPARISON CHART showing differences between Catholics and various
Protestant denominations, including Lutheran, on general practices:
http://www.religionfacts.com/christianity/charts/denominations_practices.htm
This excerpt from ?WHAT?S THE DIFFERENCE ? A COMPARISON OF THE FAITHS
MEN LIVE BY,? by Louis Cassels, Ch. 3 entitled, ?THE
CATHOLIC-PROTESTANT DIFFERENCES? digs deep into this subject, and does
place a specific emphasis on the differences between Lutheran and
Catholic teachings on a number of points. I think you?ll find it very
interesting:
http://www.religion-online.org/showchapter.asp?title=1623&C=1563
Book review on ?CHRISTIAN CONTRADICTIONS: THE STRUCTURE OF LUTHERAN
AND CATHOLIC THOUGHT? by Daphne Hampson; review by Michael Root in
?Christian Century,? Sept. 12, 2001
The reviewer recognizes that this author, like so many others, betrays
a misunderstanding of both Lutheran and Catholic dogma. Read it here:
http://www.religion-online.org/showarticle.asp?title=2195
HISTORY AND COMPARISONS OF MAJOR RELIGIONS
http://www.greatdreams.com/religin4.htm
================
OTHER RESOURCES
================
Catechism of the Catholic Church:
http://www.vatican.va/archive/catechism/ccc_toc.htm
Catholic Biblical Apologetics (a series of lecture notes used to teach
key doctrines and dogmas of the Roman Catholic Church):
http://www.catholicapologetics.org/
Luther?s Small Catechism: http://www.bookofconcord.org/smallcatechism.html
Luther?s Large Catechism: http://www.lcms.org/pages/internal.asp?NavID=585
The Book of Concord (The Lutheran Confessions): http://www.bookofconcord.org/
Differences Between ?Low Church? and ?High Church? in worship practices:
http://www.cresourcei.org/lowhighchurch.html
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I hope this information and these resources will be enough to give you
a good foundation for exploring the complex relationship between the
Roman Catholic and Lutheran churches. If anything still isn?t clear,
please ask in a ?Request for Clarification? before rating and closing
your question, as I want to be sure you?re happy with the information
provided. Good luck on your quest to understand this complicated
subject.
Best wishes,
Byrd-ga
Search strategy:
I already had a few of these links in my own bookmarks as a result of
my own interest in and study of this subject. In addition to those, I
also used the following search terms:
[Lutheran Catholic differences OR similarities OR compare OR comparison]
[communion catholic lutheran comparison OR difference]
["the joint declaration on the doctrine of justification"]
[differences comparison lutheran catholic traditions OR practices]
[lutheran catholic dialogue] |