Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Hot Showers and breating Chlorine ( Answered 3 out of 5 stars,   3 Comments )
Question  
Subject: Hot Showers and breating Chlorine
Category: Health
Asked by: vanraw-ga
List Price: $20.00
Posted: 28 Oct 2002 08:21 PST
Expires: 27 Nov 2002 08:21 PST
Question ID: 91008
What are the "documented / real medical" health risk of prolonged
breathing of Chlorine from long Showers or Steam Sauna's?

Background of question; Ive seen resently that Chlorine filters for
showers are being sold to eliminate breathing of chlorine in city tap
water. Ive heard that Breathing Chlorine from steam, enters the body
at over 100 times the concentration then drinking tap water and ther
are adverse health risk. These claims however seem to be advertisment
based. I take long showeres and I like to sit in the steam bath at the
local YMCA. Neither have Chlorine filters.

Thanks:
Vanraw
Answer  
Subject: Re: Hot Showers and breathing Chlorine
Answered By: sublime1-ga on 28 Oct 2002 20:00 PST
Rated:3 out of 5 stars
 
Vanraw...

The following page, authored by Monte Kline, Ph.D., on the
Pacific Health Center site, cites several believable studies:
http://www.pacifichealthcenter.com/updates/50.asp

"You get more toxic exposure from taking a shower than from 
 drinking the same water. So reported Science News about a 
 recent study by a major U.S. university."

"Health and Longevity in August 1994 reported:
 The skin, the body's largest organ, can easily absorb 
 contaminants found in water which pass through it into the 
 bloodstream. The experts are justbeginning to understand 
 the potential health hazards from skin absorption of water 
 contaminants."

"The Nader Report-Troubled Waters on Tap stated:
 A professor of water chemistry at the University of 
 Pittsburgh claims that exposure to vaporized chemicals in 
 your shower and bath water is 100 times greater than through 
 drinking the same water."

"U.S. News & World Report on July 29, 1991 noted:
 Studies indicate that chlorine can also be inhaled and 
 absorbed through the skin during showering and bathing. 
 Ironically, even the chlorine widely used to disinfect 
 water produces carcinogenic traces."

"Dr. Lance Wallace of the Environmental Protection Agency stated:
 Showering is suspected as the primary cause of elevated levels 
 of chloroform in nearly every home because of the chlorine in 
 the water."

"Studies have shown that your body can absorb more chlorine
 in a ten minute shower than in drinking eight glasses of the
 same water!"

The Pacific Health Center site seems relatively objective,
as it is not selling products based on its recommendations.
Unfortunately, the citations are not linked to the actual
studies. Nonetheless, other pages, though perhaps slanted
with the intent to sell products, such as shower filters,
cite the same sources, among others.

The following page, from YourNutrition.com, cites
14 authoritative sources:
http://www.yournutrition.com/shower-filters.html

 "A long, hot shower can be dangerous. The toxic chemicals
 are inhaled in high concentrations."
- Bottom Line - August 1987, J Andelman, Ph. D.

"We conclude that skin absorption of contaminants in drinking
 water has been underestimated and that ingestion may not
 constitute the sole or even primary route of exposure."
- American Journal of Public Health, May, 1984, Vol. 74, No. 5

"Ironically, even the Chlorine widely used to disinfect water
 produces Carcinogenic traces. Studies indicate the suspect
 chemicals can also be inhaled and absorbed through the skin
 during showering and bathing."
- U. S. News & World Report - 29 July 1991, Is your Water Safe
 - The Dangerous State of Your Water

"Taking showers is a health risk, according to research
 presented last week in a meeting of the American Chemical
 Society. Showers - and to a lesser extent baths - lead to
 a greater exposure to toxic chemicals contained in water
 supplies than does drinking water. The chemicals evaporate
 out of the water and are inhaled. They can also spread
 through the house and be inhaled by others."
- New Scientist -18 September 1986, Ian Anderson

"Studies have documented the presence in the drinking water
 of many potentially toxic volatile organic chemicals
 (VOC's)- from chloroform and pesticides to carbon
 tetrachloride. Such findings have spurred investigations
 into the inhalation hazards these compounds may pose when
 released in the air during baths and showers. However,
 because shower and tub equipment, as well as other design
 features, differed widely in these experiments, air
 releases for a single VOC could vary up to 10-fold from
 one studied system to another."
- John C. Little, Lawrence Berkeley (California) Laboratory,
 Science News, August 15, 1992

"The steamy air of a shower contains significant amounts of
 a least two cancer-causing chemicals that evaporate out of
 water."
- J Andelman, Professor of Water Chemistry,
 University of Pittsburgh

"Almost two decades have passed since known or suspected human
 carcinogens were first found in municipal water supplies.
 One of them, chloroform, produced by the chlorination process,
 exposes millions of Americans. The potential for a major
 public health problem is unquestionably there, and yet,
 progress has been slow."
- Dr. Peter Isacson, M.D., Professor of Epidemiology, Department
 of Preventive Medicine, University of Iowa College of Medicine

"Skin absorption of contaminant has been underestimated and
 ingestion may not constitute the sole or even primary route
 of exposure."
- American Journal of-Public Health - Dr. Halina Brown

"Showering is suspected as the primary cause of elevated of
 chloroform in nearly every home because of the chlorine in
 the water. Chloroform [a known carcinogen] levels increase
 up to 100 times during a ten-minute shower in residential
 water"
- Environmental Protection Agency - Dr. Lance Wallace

"I tell my friends to take quick, cold showers", said
 Julian B. Andelman, Professor of Water Chemistry,
 University of Pittsburgh, who claimed that the longer
 and hotter the shower, the more chemicals build up in
 the air.
- San Jose Mercury News, September 11, 1986

"Many investigators have reported on the toxicity and
 unexpected high penetration rates of volatile organic
 chemicals."
- American Journal of Public Health

"A Professor of Water Chemistry at the University of
 Pittsburgh claims that exposure to vaporized chemicals
 in the water supplies through showering, bathing, and
 inhalation is 100 greater than through drinking the
 water."
- The Nader Report, Troubled Waters on Tap - Center
 for Study of Responsive Law

"The National Academy of Sciences estimates that 200 to
 1000 people die in the United States each year from
 cancers caused by ingesting the contaminants in water.
 The major health threat posed by these pollutants is
 far more likely to be from their inhalation as air
 pollutants. The reason that emissions are high is
 because water droplets dispersed by the shower head
 have a larger surface-to-value ratio than water
 streaming into the bath."
- Science News-Vol. 130, Janet Raloff 


Searches done, via Google:

chlorine shower studies
://www.google.com/search?num=50&hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&safe=off&q=chlorine+shower+studies

If you need further assistance, please feel free to post
a request for clarification BEFORE rating this answer.

sublime1-ga
vanraw-ga rated this answer:3 out of 5 stars
Thanks for the answer. Although the long term studies dont seem to be
available, It does look like its an active issue. I think I will look
to install some filters either in the house or inline to the supply.
Nice service. Hopefully you will keep it past the beta.

Vanraw

Comments  
Subject: Re: Hot Showers and breating Chlorine
From: laner-ga on 28 Oct 2002 18:09 PST
 
As a long time asthma sufferer I can say it does bother me at times
but have never heard of a long term study as there arn't many
complaints. Since chlorine dissapates rapidly into the air I would
suggest some ventalation would be appropiate. An electritain can
install a bath fan that will pull the chlorine from the shower air.
Filters are inefficient and can't be relied on.

Laner
Subject: Re: Hot Showers and breating Chlorine
From: rupert_sg-ga on 29 Oct 2002 22:40 PST
 
Careful... it looks as if a lot of what you have quoted is junk
science. The likelihood of (even midly hazardous) quantities of
chlorine being inhaled (or even less likely, absorbed through the
skin) is remote. Remember the concentration of chlorine in tap water
is *much* less than in swimming pools and no studies have revealed any
harm caused by the chlorine in this case. And the concentration of
VOCs is even smaller, in this case drinking the water is far more
likely to be the point of entry in your body than showering...
Unfortunately this is just yet another case of supposedly impressive
science being used to force people into paying for unnecessary
'protection' devices. Another case is electromagnetic protection
devices for mobile phones, but this is another story....
Subject: Re: Hot Showers and breating Chlorine
From: researcher7-ga on 04 Nov 2002 17:37 PST
 
As a person , who did a pharmacy internship at a major Poison Control
Center, I never heard of anyone being poisoned by chlorine in a steam
bath or shower.  I have heard of people becoming very ill from
ingesting swimming pool water, heavily contaminated with chlorine.

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy