Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Difference Between Red and Yellow Saffron ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   2 Comments )
Question  
Subject: Difference Between Red and Yellow Saffron
Category: Family and Home > Food and Cooking
Asked by: tj1976-ga
List Price: $2.00
Posted: 30 May 2003 08:46 PDT
Expires: 29 Jun 2003 08:46 PDT
Question ID: 210719
I tracked down a great recipe for saffron shrimp.

The thing is, the magazine I got it from shows them using *yellow*
saffron threads. I only have *red* saffron in the house.

Can red and yellow saffron be used interchangeably?

Thank you!
Answer  
Subject: Re: Difference Between Red and Yellow Saffron
Answered By: journalist-ga on 30 May 2003 10:59 PDT
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Greetings TJ1976:

If you are seeing yellow threads, it's probably a less expensive grade
of saffron though it could also be bastard saffron.

"Saffron from Spain has been traditionally broken down into four
quality categories:

1)      Coupe

2)      Mancha

3)      Rio

4)      Sierra

"Coupe" is extremely rare and is not sold in any significant
quantities.  "Mancha" saffron is characterized by a deep red color and
very few off color filaments; it is the best quality readily available
on the market.  "Rio" and "Sierra" qualities have a greater number of
white or yellow filaments, and thus weaker coloring power, and less
flavor and aroma."
From http://www.occidentalfoods.com/safron.htm

From http://216.239.37.100/search?q=cache:UawI7kxGJl8J:www.florilegium.org/files/PLANTS/saffron-art.rtf+Rio+saffron+color&hl=en&start=2&ie=UTF-8
comes this:
"If you see short, angular threads of a yellow-red color, you've got
yourself Safflower, also called "Bastard Saffron" or "Osfor". It's a
good coloring agent but has little or no taste and is nothing like the
real deal. This is the stuff you get in Istanbul for $5 the pound."

To compare pricing, "Saffron is the most expensive spice known with
retail prices reaching up to several hundred dollars per pound. It
takes from 35,000 to 75,000 flowers to make a pound of saffron."
From http://www.sycamorefarms.com/2001SaffronUpdate.html

and

"Each saffron crocus flower has 3 stigmas, it takes about 80,000
flowers (240,000) stigmas to make a pound of saffron. It takes an
experienced picker about 12 days to pick this many. By the time
saffron gets to retail stores, its cost is $600 to $2000 per pound. 
In 1444 any merchant caught selling adulterated saffron in Bavaria was
burned alive."
From http://www.foodreference.com/html/fsaffron.html

Concerning color "Saffron contains a water-soluble coloring matter
known as crocin, which provides a golden-colored dye which is
effective even at a dilution of 1:100,000."
From http://www.tis-gdv.de/tis_e/ware/gewuerze/safran/safran.htm#informationen

And please visit http://www.foodreference.com/html/artsaffron.html
where you will see excellent photos of the styles attached to the
stigmas.  Those may be what you are seeing, too.  It is noted there
"As you examine the image on the left, you see that the stigmas are
attached to a slender white style, which, when dried, turns pale
yellow.  The Style of the saffron plant, has NO CULINARY VALUE, that
means NO AROMA, FLAVOR or COLOR. If is left attached to the red
stigmas, it adds 30% to 50% DEAD weight to the saffron, and you pay
for it. Note it’s as long as 1 3/4 inches. When dry, it curls and you
can hardly see it."  The entire article there is very informative.

The crocus stigmas known as saffron are described on various Internet
sites as deep red to orange with the reddest being the best.

"Saffron is the reddish-orange stigmas of a special variety of crocus.
It originated in Arabia and was brought to Spain in the eighth century
and today Spain is the major exporter of this spice...It is sometimes
adulterated with other spices. True saffron is expensive and has a
deep orange to brownish red color. The redder the strands, the better
the quality."
From http://nmnm.essortment.com/whatissaffron_rbck.htm

From http://www.chefsresource.com/saffron.html
"Saffron has long been considered the world's most highly valued
spice. The fertile high plain of La Mancha in Spain is the source of
the finest quality. Here, in the shadow of the legendary windmills of
Don Quixote, grow tiny crocus flowers. Each flower produces three
delicate, aromatic red stigmas known as saffron. Each stigma thread is
carefully handpicked and packed to assure you of the highest quality
saffron product."

There is also a "yellow saffron" which is not associated with the
crocus:
"Yellow (American) saffron is not related to the expensive culinary
(Spanish) saffron.  American Saffron is the Safflower.  Today this
plant is grown mostly because for its high percentage of
polyunsaturated oil, which tends to lower blood cholesterol...".  See
the image of a safflower at
http://www.biosurvey.ou.edu/okwild/images/safflower.jpg to compare it
with your picture.  However, this is seldom used in cooking; it's used
more as a tea and "the heads produce an intense yellow or red
substance which is used for dye.  In the past the dye was used for
cosmetic rouge, to dye mummy wrappings, color silks and other
textiles.  The seeds produce oil which is popularly  used in cooking. 
The oil is also used in paints and varnishes.  Medicinally, the
flowers of yellow saffron have a laxative and diaphoretic action used
to treat measles, fever, and erruptic skin disorders."

So, either you are seeing "bastard saffron" in the picture that is
just being used for color or a very weak grade of real saffron whose
yellow styles are being passed off as the real thing.  I'd go ahead
and use the red but use less than the recipe calls for to be certain
the saffron flavor wouldn't overpower the taste.

Should you require clarification of any of the links or information I
have provided, please request it and I will be happy to respond.


SEARCH STRATEGY:

red saffron yellow color
spanish saffron color
"red saffron"
"yellow saffron"
"red saffron" taste
"yellow saffron" taste
saffron cost per pound
tj1976-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars and gave an additional tip of: $1.50
Absolutely amazing! 

Thank you for such a thorough (and interesting) answer.

You've not only given me information about ingredients but have also
provided the makings of excellent dinner conversation.

Thanks, journalist...and have a great weekend,
TJ

Comments  
Subject: Re: Difference Between Red and Yellow Saffron
From: journalist-ga on 30 May 2003 13:07 PDT
 
Same to you and thank you for your rating, comments and added
generosity!  I, too, now have a most interesting topic for
converstaion.  In fact, I spoke to a friend after I answered your
question and told her all about it, too.  :)  Have a happy shrimpfest!
Subject: Re: Difference Between Red and Yellow Saffron
From: journalist-ga on 30 May 2003 14:17 PDT
 
Add these to your saffron facts collection.  :)

"20.Saffron yileds greens/golds. Cultivated throughout the world. 
Persian Emperors wore saffron dyed robes and had documents dyed from
it
as well. The Bible mentions saffron in the SONG OF SOLOMON. In the 
12th century the Arabs introduced saffron to Spain and by the late 
Middle Ages it was cultivated throughout Europe. Used as a hair dye 
by ladies of Venice in the late 1500's." From
http://www.florilegium.org/files/TEXTILES/dye-list-art.html
Quoted from ["Dye Plants" [ISBN 1-871569-74-5] by John and Margaret
Cannon, illustrated by Gretel Dalby-Quenet"]

"In the 15th century...Blond hair was considered to be a sign of
beauty and high class. As a result, both men and women attempted to
turn their hair blond by using bleach, saffron or onion skin dye..."
From http://tlc.discovery.com/convergence/humanface/timeline/timeline.html

"Romans used many different types of natural hair dyes. Mineral
quicklime gave their hair a lustrous, red-gold tinge. Walnut oil was
made by steeping walnut shells in olive oil and used to keep hair dark
brown when it began to turn grey. In ancient Rome blonde hair was
initially considered to be a symbol of a prostitute. When slave girls
were acquired from Scandinavia, noblewomen began to dye their hair
lighter shade using a concentrated infusion of saffron
flowers...Venetian noblewomen in the 1500s would dye their hair by
applying lotions derived from saffron flowers or sulphur. The color
was set by by the hot summer sun, then the hair was rinsed."
From http://www.geocities.com/Athens/4177/beautyhist.html

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy