Google Answers Logo
View Question
 
Q: Paper Inventor ( Answered 5 out of 5 stars,   2 Comments )
Question  
Subject: Paper Inventor
Category: Reference, Education and News
Asked by: tubular-ga
List Price: $20.00
Posted: 11 Jul 2005 22:38 PDT
Expires: 10 Aug 2005 22:38 PDT
Question ID: 542478
I?ve heard conflicting stories about who invented paper.  Was it the
Chinese or the Egyptians?  Just to let you know, if I get an answer I
like, ten more dollars will be on the way.
Answer  
Subject: Re: Paper Inventor
Answered By: crabcakes-ga on 11 Jul 2005 23:34 PDT
Rated:5 out of 5 stars
 
Hello tubular, 

The Chinese invented paper!

Doing a Google search for 'Chinese + invented paper' gives 603,000  results.
://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=chinese+%2B+invented+paper&btnG=Google+Search

Doing a Google search for 'Egyptian + invented paper' serves up only
341,000 returns. Therefore China wins in an uncontrolled and
non-scientific test!
://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=egyptian+%2B+invented+paper&btnG=Search


Seriously, it appears that China is the winner of your answer!

If you go by the definition of paper, which is a pulpy mixture of
grasses, wood, rags, fibers, and pulp, with water, then China
definitely wins. Chine wins especially if you don?t count papyrus, a
predecessor to paper made by separating layers of papyrus plant, as
paper.

Should you consider papyrus to be paper, then Egypt wins the honor of
being the first place paper was used. But papyrus is NOT paper, and
was used just as bark, leaves, and stone tablets were ? they carried
the message, but they were not paper.

Should you consider paper an invention, as your question indicates,
then China is the winner again, as the papyrus plant was not invented.

Answers.com defines paper as:
?A material made of cellulose pulp, derived mainly from wood, rags,
and certain grasses, processed into flexible sheets or rolls by
deposit from an aqueous suspension, and used chiefly for writing,
printing, drawing, wrapping, and covering walls.?
http://www.answers.com/paper&r=67


Merriam Webster says:
?A felted sheet of usually vegetable fibers laid down on a fine screen
from a water suspension?
http://m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary

?The need for paper began when man first started to record traditions,
religion, and legal documents. Before papermaking, materials such as
clay nails, papyrus, pounded bark, silk and parchment were used to
record information, but none of these materials were either portable
or cost-effective enough to mass-produce. Paper began in China as
early as 200 BC, where the oldest known paper was used for a prayer
found embedded in an adobe brick that was used to bless a home. The
paper was made from recycled fishing nets, bamboo and hemp.?
http://www.cpbis.org/industry/history.html


According to PaperOnline, it appears that China was the first place to
use tapa paper. At least it is the earliest FOUND paper so far:

?Of all the writing and drawing materials that people have employed
down the ages, paper is the most widely used around the world. Its
name derives from papyrus the material used by the ancient Egyptians,
Greeks and Romans. Papyrus, however, is only one of the predecessors
of paper that together are known by the generic term ?tapa? and are
mostly made from the inner bark of paper mulberry, fig and daphne.?

?Tapa has been found extensively in nearly all cultures along the
Equatorial belt and is made by what is possibly the oldest papermaking
technique ? one still practised in some parts of the Himalayas and
South East Asia. Indeed, recent archaeological excavations in China
have revealed some of the oldest ?tapa? paper ever found which shows
that paper was being produced in China before western records began.?
http://www.paperonline.org/history/3000/3000_frame.html

According to Inventors.About, China is the first place paper was used.
?A courtier named Ts'ai-Lun, from Lei-yang in China, was the inventor
of paper (not papyrus) circa 105 A.D. However, the word paper is
derived from the name of the reedy plant papyrus, which grows
abundantly along the Nile River in Egypt. Paper is made of pulped
cellulose fibers like wood, cotton or flax. Papyrus is made from the
sliced sections of the flower stem of the papyrus plant, pressed
together and dried.?
http://inventors.about.com/library/inventors/blpapermaking.htm


TAPPI, the Technical Association of worldwide pulp, paper, and
converting industry gives credit to the Chinese:

?The Chinese government official and scholar is grinding up plants -
mulberry bark, linen and hemp. He makes a big wet mush of separate
fibers, then spreads it all out in a mat made of coarse cloth and a
bamboo frame.
It looks like he's got a mess on his hands, and chances are his
family, friends and neighbors are making fun of him. But when he's
done, and the sun has dried the matted material, he's made something
really remarkable.
Ts'ai Lun, 2,000 years ago, has made paper, and it will become one of
the most important inventions ever.

Even though archaeological evidence shows that paper may have been
made even a little earlier, Ts'ai Lun was the first to have his
efforts recorded. Like many inventors through the centuries, he built
upon the work of others.
Okay, people had written even before paper was invented. They
scratched on cave walls, painted too, and drew characters on wet clay.
They even wrote on papyrus made from thinly-sliced papyrus reed which
they glued together to make a sheet.?
http://www.tappi.org/paperu/all_about_paper/paperHistory.htm


?The word "paper" is derived from the word "papyrus," which was a
plant found in Egypt along the lower Nile River. About 5,000 years
ago, Egyptians created "sheets" of papyrus by harvesting, peeling and
slicing the plant into strips. The strips were then layered, pounded
together and smoothed to make a flat, uniform sheet.

No major changes in writing materials were to come for about 3,000
years. The person credited with inventing paper is a Chinese man named
Ts'ai Lun. He took the inner bark of a mulberry tree and bamboo
fibers, mixed them with water, and pounded them with a wooden tool. He
then poured this mixture onto a flat piece of coarsely woven cloth and
let the water drain through, leaving only the fibers on the cloth.
Once dry, Ts'ai Lun discovered that he had created a quality writing
surface that was relatively easy to make and lightweight. This
knowledge of papermaking was used in China before word was passed
along to Korea, Samarkand, Baghdad, and Damascus.?
http://www.wipapercouncil.org/invention.htm

 ?The first historical mention of paper is 104 A.D. in China. The
Empress of China at that time loved books and wanted to have a lot of
them made. At the time everything was written on silk scrolls which
were extremely expensive and time consuming to make. She wanted
something cheaper and easier to use and so she asked one of her
servants, a gentleman by the name of Tsi Lun to come up with an
alternative. He worked for over nine years experimenting with
different things and finally came up with hemp, mulberry tree bark,
silk and old fishing nets all ground up into a mushy pulp. I wonder
how he ever thought of it; the history books don't say. The Empress
was very pleased and Tsi Lun was elevated to a high rank in the court.
Unfortunately for him, the Empress then asked Tsi Lun to spread
malicious gossip about some of her enemies at court. When the Empress
fell out of power, those people were extremely angry with Tsi Lun and
he was either put to death or forced to commit suicide.

Strange, isn't it, how things go in the world?  And, of course, all of
this that I am sharing with you is just one version of history. 
Others will perhaps be able to give a different rendering.  I have
read many.  I like the story of Tsi Lun. Most people agree on that
one.  But, as for the spread of papermaking as an art, well, there are
different stories told. To gather such accounts and compare them falls
within the discipline of "Historiography", the history of the writing
of history. (If you ever want to scamble your brains and loose all
concept of the solidity of reality, just study the hisotry writing of
history.)  The following, I believe, is most likely closest to the
truth.
Papermaking remained a secret Chinese art until around the year 700
A.D. when, during a war with China the Arab nations captured an entire
town of papermakers and took them back to the middle east as prisoners
where they were forced into labor making paper. The craft was learned
a couple hundred years later by Western Europeans during the Crusades.
Curiously, the Church in Western Europe initially banned the use of
paper calling it a 'pagan art' believing that animal parchment was the
only thing 'holy' enough to carry the Sacred Word.  That strange
prejudice lasted for more than 100 years, but they got over it.? (This
may not be a highly reliable source, but it was interesting!)
http://hometown.aol.com/ppreble2/history2.html


There you go! I certainly hope you liked the answer!

If any part of my answer is unclear, contains broken links, or
contains information you already had, please request an Answer
Clarification, before rating. By not rating until I have responded to
your clarification request, I may continue assisting you on this
question.

Sincerely, Crabcakes


Search Terms
=============
history + paper making
meaning + paper
papyrus
when paper invented
tubular-ga rated this answer:5 out of 5 stars and gave an additional tip of: $10.00
Crabcakes, what a wonderful answer! And prompt! I could not imagine a
better and more complete way to answer this question, starting from
the very basic definition of paper and moving upward in your analysis
from there.  You certainly deserve the tip!

Comments  
Subject: Re: Paper Inventor
From: crabcakes-ga on 12 Jul 2005 10:21 PDT
 
Thank you tubular, for the comments, the stars and the generous tip!
I'm glad you were pleased with the answer. While I don't answer
questions in hopes of a tip, I do appreciate you following through
with your offer of one!

Sincerely, Crabcakes
Subject: Re: Paper Inventor
From: tubular-ga on 12 Jul 2005 11:02 PDT
 
That was such a great research effort on your part -- about how long
did it take you to put that together? Thanks again. ~tubular

Important Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided on Google Answers are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Google does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. Please read carefully the Google Answers Terms of Service.

If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by emailing us at answers-support@google.com with the question ID listed above. Thank you.
Search Google Answers for
Google Answers  


Google Home - Answers FAQ - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy